I don't see the difference between her and the other than minks(except for inu Pedro and Neko) 🤷♀️ like oda give they a good backstory also connect what happening in Roger's era also even the mink doctor and nurse have a moment in the raid so u are trying me that Carrot was treated better than them too?
General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Because you don't pay attention. I do for Carrot and the difference is like night and day.
Like I said (for the 100 times) the fact that Oda gave a backstory to Inu and Neko doesn't make them more relevant for the minks, it just makes them more relevant as scabbard as the story wasn't focus on them but the relationship between the scabbards and Oden.
Yes, Carrot was treated better than anymink in this raid (except Inu and Neko who shined more). In the rest of the story however, Carrot is ni front of all the mink. Be it by her treatment and the outlinings of the panels, her moments as a character, a emotionnal relevancy, Her character arc, her post or her dynamic with the story. But as you can't accept what I'm saying.. you are bound to ask me the same question again.. and again.. and again.. until soon..
Where Carrot will jump on the ship.. and you won't understand why.
Like I said (for the 100 times) the fact that Oda gave a backstory to Inu and Neko doesn't make them more relevant for the minks, it just makes them more relevant as scabbard as the story wasn't focus on them but the relationship between the scabbards and Oden.
Yes, Carrot was treated better than anymink in this raid (except Inu and Neko who shined more). In the rest of the story however, Carrot is ni front of all the mink. Be it by her treatment and the outlinings of the panels, her moments as a character, a emotionnal relevancy, Her character arc, her post or her dynamic with the story. But as you can't accept what I'm saying.. you are bound to ask me the same question again.. and again.. and again.. until soon..
Where Carrot will jump on the ship.. and you won't understand why.
The minks doctor and nurse help chopper cue the ice oni disease and also help Zoro too even have more panels than carrot in the raid right now and u so on the jump on the ship without being asked to join are u really okay with that? Didn't they also tell nami that she was on the right track to the one piece? 🤔 also went to the island with Roger. Backstory is one of Oda's specialists some he always goes out and gives his characters right now u keep clingy on that Pedro's death like it is more trauma than Yamato and other straw hats been through 🤗 even jinbei have a good backstory before joining the crew where is carrot?
The mink doctor are treated as background character. You can see that by the way Oda makes them interact (as story "pupets") and the way Oda is outlining them in term of paneling (meaning, not at all, Oda is focusing on chopper)
You really have a bias problem if you think those two doctor have a better treatment than Carrot.. and I would say it goes beyond the simple bias here.
Yes I'm okay with someone jumping on the ship without being ask, that's exactly what Robin did and she had less development than Carrot had in the entirerity of Whole cake. (and don't start to argue with that, not only it is a narrative fact prooved by an analysis of the different moment of CArrot but you already know what I think, check the historic, I'm done repeating the things 100 to you)
So what ? Because you know a bit about the journey to the One Piece doesn't make you more relevant. There is plenty of background characters in rogers crew.
Not always. In fact we can see that lately, Oda is according less importance to the backstory and more importance to the present development of the characters (Pudding/Katakuri)
Furthermore, carrot don't need one, so there is no need for Oda to create one.
A backstory is only important WHEN IT'S NEEDED. That's one of the first thing you learn in a writing class.
Irrelevant argument as always. In One Piece, Oda never compare the level of trauma to recruit someone. If that was the case, Oda wouldn't have recruited Sanji when it was shown at the beginning that he didn't lose anyone atfirst. Same for Luffy. Carrot's trauma is the same as any strawhat with few exception.
If you think that losing someone close (Pedro/Kuina/Bellmere/Hilluluk) is not a Trauma worthy of a strawhat (even if traumas are not something you should be worthy of).. then you don't understand One Piece at all.
Wrong. Jinbe was treated as a secondary protagonist in the fishmen Island backstory. The two real protagonist were Otohime and Fisher Tiger. Jinbe only shined in the very end.
You really have a bias problem if you think those two doctor have a better treatment than Carrot.. and I would say it goes beyond the simple bias here.
Yes I'm okay with someone jumping on the ship without being ask, that's exactly what Robin did and she had less development than Carrot had in the entirerity of Whole cake. (and don't start to argue with that, not only it is a narrative fact prooved by an analysis of the different moment of CArrot but you already know what I think, check the historic, I'm done repeating the things 100 to you)
So what ? Because you know a bit about the journey to the One Piece doesn't make you more relevant. There is plenty of background characters in rogers crew.
Not always. In fact we can see that lately, Oda is according less importance to the backstory and more importance to the present development of the characters (Pudding/Katakuri)
Furthermore, carrot don't need one, so there is no need for Oda to create one.
A backstory is only important WHEN IT'S NEEDED. That's one of the first thing you learn in a writing class.
Irrelevant argument as always. In One Piece, Oda never compare the level of trauma to recruit someone. If that was the case, Oda wouldn't have recruited Sanji when it was shown at the beginning that he didn't lose anyone atfirst. Same for Luffy. Carrot's trauma is the same as any strawhat with few exception.
If you think that losing someone close (Pedro/Kuina/Bellmere/Hilluluk) is not a Trauma worthy of a strawhat (even if traumas are not something you should be worthy of).. then you don't understand One Piece at all.
Wrong. Jinbe was treated as a secondary protagonist in the fishmen Island backstory. The two real protagonist were Otohime and Fisher Tiger. Jinbe only shined in the very end.
Zoro - 2nd protagonist of Marine Arc
Nami - 2nd protagonist of Arlong arc
Usopp - 2nd protagonist of Syrup Village
Sanji - Main plot driven character of Baratie
Chopper - main fight along with Luffy in Drum Island
Nico Robin - FB plus EL & W7
Franky - FB plus W7
Brook - Fuckin ZORO fought for his shadow lmao + Much needed Musician
Jinbei - Fishman Island big role
Yamato - Biggest roles in Onigashima
Carrot - offscreen chewing grass half the arc lmao
gtfo clown ass
Nami - 2nd protagonist of Arlong arc
Usopp - 2nd protagonist of Syrup Village
Sanji - Main plot driven character of Baratie
Chopper - main fight along with Luffy in Drum Island
Nico Robin - FB plus EL & W7
Franky - FB plus W7
Brook - Fuckin ZORO fought for his shadow lmao + Much needed Musician
Jinbei - Fishman Island big role
Yamato - Biggest roles in Onigashima
Carrot - offscreen chewing grass half the arc lmao
gtfo clown ass
What even makes u feel better cause if u think there will be more backstory of carrot when they keep using that one scene with her and Pedro good luck cause that is the only time carrot was heartbroken those no more for her cause she was happy in Zou am I right? But at least they weren't gone for entire chapters just to come back as to say yes in a panel 🤭 , where will carrot have more storyline in wano? U need to know this is A BIG ARC FOR THE STRAWHATS A YONKO IS ABOUT TO LOSE TO LUFFY AND HIS CREW AGAIN this is why Oda give everyone a moment to shine but u think someone who got off-screen is important in this arc u are stupid 😒.
If panel times is that important that it makes her the most special mink. Why doesn’t she have any now in wano? There is panel time and panel relevance and Carrots panel relevance is basically ZERO. Inu and Neko might have less panel time but the panel relevance is of the charts. And Yamato the future nakama has both.
Well I'm holding out hope that Pedro is given some relevance when the battle has ended and that his death is a fake out like the other Will of P characters.
The manga is currently on its 2nd Cover Story about Whole Cake Island. Pedro and/or Pekoms may show up in Germa's story or in their own in the return of the Nox Pirates.
The real story is hers you say. If that's true than instead of Pedro's past we should have seen more of Carrot's. The fact that Pedro has flashbacks that don't relate to Carrot yet Carrot has flashbacks that only relate to Pedro states the opposite.
Lacking a purpose is part of the point why she won't join. It's not going to magically appear now after her "mentor" Pedro's "death" and after excluding Carrot from the main plot in Wano. What did Pedro transfer to Carrot right before? The words that she will understand someday why the Strawhats are important. She didn't learn anything about a shared dream. For her ignorance of the "Dawn" dream to be explained to her by someone other than Pedro defies how Oda displayed past relationships.
The manga is currently on its 2nd Cover Story about Whole Cake Island. Pedro and/or Pekoms may show up in Germa's story or in their own in the return of the Nox Pirates.
No need to scream my boy
Carrot DID talked about the will of Pedro. It can be found in chapter 888 "I will fight for you too, Pedro"
The fact that she hasn't talked about that precise panel but that Oda mentionned that flashback is a clew that this moment is about to happen.
That's called jumping and dodging. Those are the "woosh sounds of a rapid movement" Like you can see, Neko even tho he appears like it, is not flying, he is just teking a big step (you can see his paw on the ground). What Carrot did is completely different, she modified her trajectory mid flight:
And that, only Carrot can do.
No. She doesn't need to be as strong as nekomamushi as they are far more trained than her. She just has a natural capacity for it. And who tells you that Carrot is not as strong as Pedro? Of course it's impressive. You really can't accept that Carrot can do something exceptionnal can't you? lol
Headcanon. It doesn't explain this post at all.
Carrot IS special, you will just have to accept it my dear.
Pedro was just a vessel to transfert a will to Carrot. The real story is hers, to him.
What Carrot lacks is the purpose mainly. But this is something that can be constructed and it has been setup in the story. So the probabilities for this to happen was the Dawn becomes a real subject are very high. This will be enough for Carrot to developp something.
Carrot DID talked about the will of Pedro. It can be found in chapter 888 "I will fight for you too, Pedro"
The fact that she hasn't talked about that precise panel but that Oda mentionned that flashback is a clew that this moment is about to happen.
Post automatically merged:
That's called jumping and dodging. Those are the "woosh sounds of a rapid movement" Like you can see, Neko even tho he appears like it, is not flying, he is just teking a big step (you can see his paw on the ground). What Carrot did is completely different, she modified her trajectory mid flight:
And that, only Carrot can do.
No. She doesn't need to be as strong as nekomamushi as they are far more trained than her. She just has a natural capacity for it. And who tells you that Carrot is not as strong as Pedro? Of course it's impressive. You really can't accept that Carrot can do something exceptionnal can't you? lol
Headcanon. It doesn't explain this post at all.
Carrot IS special, you will just have to accept it my dear.
Pedro was just a vessel to transfert a will to Carrot. The real story is hers, to him.
What Carrot lacks is the purpose mainly. But this is something that can be constructed and it has been setup in the story. So the probabilities for this to happen was the Dawn becomes a real subject are very high. This will be enough for Carrot to developp something.
Lacking a purpose is part of the point why she won't join. It's not going to magically appear now after her "mentor" Pedro's "death" and after excluding Carrot from the main plot in Wano. What did Pedro transfer to Carrot right before? The words that she will understand someday why the Strawhats are important. She didn't learn anything about a shared dream. For her ignorance of the "Dawn" dream to be explained to her by someone other than Pedro defies how Oda displayed past relationships.
That's called jumping and dodging. Those are the "woosh sounds of a rapid movement" Like you can see, Neko even tho he appears like it, is not flying, he is just teking a big step (you can see his paw on the ground). What Carrot did is completely different, she modified her trajectory mid flight:
And that, only Carrot can do.
And that, only Carrot can do.
Preposterous, Pedro Sulong would be able to have an extreme diff fight with Perospero.. Every Yonko commanders level and above must be extraordinary as kids, Jinbei for instance whos 3rd-2nd Yonko commander was a prodigy as a child earning a black belt in fishman karate.. Neko and Inu who are of similar strenght must have been prodigy themselves at a young age, Carrot is just a talented teenager she's not a child prodigy..
Wanda was hinted in her vivre card to be related to Inuarashi from him letting her use his personal steed and her having given to Nami the country's Royal dress that she was in possession.. Its very clear that Wanda is her caretaker for Carrot begged Pedro not to tell Wanda fearing her anger..
Wanda and Carrot's title is pretty useless..
Don't worry that will never happen she's a shitty character and not special at all..
That's pretty much it Carrot being used to hype others, never having the focus on her bar perhaps when she went Sulong and thats debatable too..
Yamato is just one of the biggest role in onigashima lmao, but You did well by stating she was just a role in Onigashim, which is part of the Wano arc ...where she is not lol
I don't think there will be more backstory for Carrot, I think carrot don't need a backstory. Did I made myself not clear enough the first ten times I said that ?
And she is still happy, she just has now a scar. Like every strawhats.
I would say either now, the next time we see her or at the very end of the arc, in the very last chapter
That's not what One Piece 1006 is hinted us at
Become the Job needed for her is done. She had here introduction, her relevance as a character, her post, her emotionnal relevancy. Now Oda can let her cook a bit in the background, she won't be forgotten". He will take her back later once hereally needs to develop her story.
Only in Onigashima. And Yamato yet has to have a real character arc in this war. Right now, her story is shallow at best:
- No real development
- No real struggle (I mean mentally and not just physically)
- No hard choice to make
This is a shallow development for now.
Not really. Pedro's past was important to setup his will, in other words to understand his reasons to fight and desires. This was needed in order to pass on the will.
Like I said, Carrot don't need a backstory (for now), meaning that Oda needed to find a way to developp the will of Pedro without having to deal with Carrot.
The thing is, Carrot don't lack purpose. As I said, that purpose was hinted MULTIPLE TIMES to happen sooner or later. It's therefore just a question of "when"
That is one of those setup.
Not at all. In fact Oda has already done that with others strawhat. The will of Hilluluk for exemple, was put in perspective by Kureha. And it's through her that Chopper grew while Hilluluk was still his moral Pillar.
Nah, they are "whooshing" Meaning strong jumping power (as the paw hit prooves it). In Sulong however, Minks are indeed flying or at least they appear so. (CArrot is really flying on her part in Sulong tho)
And still was put down in a matter of second. Nothing in the story shows us that Carrot is weaker than Pedro. The story is actually hinting us at the opposite.
So you are telling me that Carrot can be a commander level threat ? If not, this is irrelevant, there is no rule about that.
You might be right on that, but I would need a quote for that. I don't remember quite clearly that fact.
So powerful that they were put on sticks to feed the crabs by regular humans
She is tho. This is what implied by her Vivre Card. This is really no difficult to understand.
You are right, I forgot this information. But this is even more suspicious now. Why would Carrot be on the same level ? Is she related to a place of power. Being here only because she knows Wanda doesn't make sence. Oda doesn't do things for shallow reasons like that. And if Wanda is Carrot caretaker, there is here.. a story to tell..
In fact even if I think that Carrot doesn't need a backstory, I think that there is a little story to tell about her birth. There might be reasons to believe that Carrot wasn't born on Zou.. but this is another debate.
The treatment in taht chapter PROVES that Carrot is the protagonist and that Sulong is just a way to make HER shine. I already explained that clearly, go read the historic.
I don't think there will be more backstory for Carrot, I think carrot don't need a backstory. Did I made myself not clear enough the first ten times I said that ?
And she is still happy, she just has now a scar. Like every strawhats.
I would say either now, the next time we see her or at the very end of the arc, in the very last chapter
That's not what One Piece 1006 is hinted us at
Become the Job needed for her is done. She had here introduction, her relevance as a character, her post, her emotionnal relevancy. Now Oda can let her cook a bit in the background, she won't be forgotten". He will take her back later once hereally needs to develop her story.
Only in Onigashima. And Yamato yet has to have a real character arc in this war. Right now, her story is shallow at best:
- No real development
- No real struggle (I mean mentally and not just physically)
- No hard choice to make
This is a shallow development for now.
Not really. Pedro's past was important to setup his will, in other words to understand his reasons to fight and desires. This was needed in order to pass on the will.
Like I said, Carrot don't need a backstory (for now), meaning that Oda needed to find a way to developp the will of Pedro without having to deal with Carrot.
The thing is, Carrot don't lack purpose. As I said, that purpose was hinted MULTIPLE TIMES to happen sooner or later. It's therefore just a question of "when"
That is one of those setup.
Not at all. In fact Oda has already done that with others strawhat. The will of Hilluluk for exemple, was put in perspective by Kureha. And it's through her that Chopper grew while Hilluluk was still his moral Pillar.
Nah, they are "whooshing" Meaning strong jumping power (as the paw hit prooves it). In Sulong however, Minks are indeed flying or at least they appear so. (CArrot is really flying on her part in Sulong tho)
And still was put down in a matter of second. Nothing in the story shows us that Carrot is weaker than Pedro. The story is actually hinting us at the opposite.
So you are telling me that Carrot can be a commander level threat ? If not, this is irrelevant, there is no rule about that.
You might be right on that, but I would need a quote for that. I don't remember quite clearly that fact.
So powerful that they were put on sticks to feed the crabs by regular humans
She is tho. This is what implied by her Vivre Card. This is really no difficult to understand.
You are right, I forgot this information. But this is even more suspicious now. Why would Carrot be on the same level ? Is she related to a place of power. Being here only because she knows Wanda doesn't make sence. Oda doesn't do things for shallow reasons like that. And if Wanda is Carrot caretaker, there is here.. a story to tell..
In fact even if I think that Carrot doesn't need a backstory, I think that there is a little story to tell about her birth. There might be reasons to believe that Carrot wasn't born on Zou.. but this is another debate.
The treatment in taht chapter PROVES that Carrot is the protagonist and that Sulong is just a way to make HER shine. I already explained that clearly, go read the historic.
I don’t get all these people thinking Carrot has any chance of joining the SHs. He seems like such a random ass character to join the SHs as opposed to anyone else.
First of all Carrot is all the way back in Syrup Village. How on Earth is he gonna be able to get to the SHs all the way in the New World when he’s still in the East Blue?
Second of all, Carrot’s dream of opening up a bar can be accomplished without having to join the SHs. He can get that done by staying in Syrup Village.
And finally, what would Carrot actually bring to the SHs? He’s only 11 years old and the only experience he has fighting is with a wooden sword and against Jango. All the monsters residing in the New World makes Jango and even Kuro look like fodder.
So I don’t get all these people wanting Carrot to join the SHs. And why him over Onion and Pepper from the former Usopp pirates? Carrot would just be dead weight to the SHs
First of all Carrot is all the way back in Syrup Village. How on Earth is he gonna be able to get to the SHs all the way in the New World when he’s still in the East Blue?
Second of all, Carrot’s dream of opening up a bar can be accomplished without having to join the SHs. He can get that done by staying in Syrup Village.
And finally, what would Carrot actually bring to the SHs? He’s only 11 years old and the only experience he has fighting is with a wooden sword and against Jango. All the monsters residing in the New World makes Jango and even Kuro look like fodder.
So I don’t get all these people wanting Carrot to join the SHs. And why him over Onion and Pepper from the former Usopp pirates? Carrot would just be dead weight to the SHs
- Status