General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Animangaboy]

fact that after 70 chapter we still don't have a introduction for a capacity to a post on the Sunny
- The fact that she had 0 dynamic with the crew beside helping Franky
- The fact that her story right now is completely turn toward Momo and Wano despite what she is saying about the sea
- The fact that her affirmation to Luffy "As Ace brother you should be giving me a ride on the ship" is most likely a subversion, meaning that when Yamato says I'll go with Luffy, Oda is actually planning the opposite.
- The fact that her treatment is closer to a main arc character than a strawhat (the way she is drawn, the way Kaido outline her presence)
- The fact that there is right now more probable candidate and that there will likely be only one spot
- The fact that despite her backstory, she has close to no character arc in the present as of yet.

? She is doing to same as luffy right now which is saving Wano?
Also why u keep on using that she hadn't met the rest of the crew during a war is it right that important to stop helping wan9 just to say hi to the crew, she already met the captain which is more important
U act like luffy was ignored by what Yamato said as Ace's brother something when jinbei use ace as a way to help luffy during they first meet
Where did it show that Yamato's story/backstory is finished?
Didn't all of the strawhats were mainly important in their own arc (FOR EXAMPLE Sanji in WCI, Nami, etc)
She said that she is going to sea with luffy to her father(another time she states that will leave wano but a different subtext)
And carrot still hasn't shown that she wants to join the crew but ODA makes Yamato do so? 🤔
All of the so-called reason u made is too dumb cause carrot don't even pass all of this bad stuff you made about Yamato cause we don't see anything that makes carrot a crewmate

 

[Logiko]

? She is doing to same as luffy right now which is saving Wano?

Not like Luffy. The difference is in the treatment. Yamato is treated like a shadow agent. She is not fighting like the strawhat, in the front line, she is fighting behind the lines. Like a guardian. That's why I say that Yamato is turn toward wano and it's protection rather than the strawhat. It's a matter of treatment.

Also why u keep on using that she hadn't met the rest of the crew during a war is it right that important to stop helping wan9 just to say hi to the crew, she already met the captain which is more important

Because EVERY strawhat met and interacted deeply with the future strawhats before they were recruted. Yamato lacks that dynamic.

U act like luffy was ignored by what Yamato said as Ace's brother something when jinbei use ace as a way to help luffy during they first meet

Jinbe didn't affirmed that he Luffy be giving him a ride on the ship

Where did it show that Yamato's story/backstory is finished?

When I say that yamato is a bad candidate, Im actually saying that Yamato is a bad candidate "RIGHT NOW". Things can change. But right now, Yamato doesn't have a strong character arc in Onigashima.

Didn't all of the strawhats were mainly important in their own arc (FOR EXAMPLE Sanji in WCI, Nami, etc)

Yes, what's your point ?

She said that she is going to sea with luffy to her father(another time she states that will leave wano but a different subtext)

As I said, it's a subversion dialogue. It won't happen, at least not like she think it will.

And carrot still hasn't shown that she wants to join the crew but ODA makes Yamato do so?

Usually, strawhats don't want to join the crew. It's Luffy who convinces them.

All of the so-called reason u made is too dumb cause carrot don't even pass all of this bad stuff you made about Yamato cause we don't see anything that makes carrot a crewmate

Carrot only misses the last parameters, she has everything else.

 

[Animangaboy]

like Luffy. The difference is in the treatment. Yamato is treated like a shadow agent. She is not fighting like the strawhat, in the front line, she is fighting behind the lines. Like a guardian. That's why I say that Yamato is turn toward wano and it's protection rather than the strawhat. It's a matter of treatment.

Ok? What u want Yamato to do? Cause we don't know why Oda do that

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

Usually, strawhats don't want to join the crew. It's Luffy who convinces them.

Hmmm not with brook usopp robin and jinbei thou

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

I said, it's a subversion dialogue. It won't happen, at least not like she thinks it will.

ODA could have made Yamato says something else but he make Yamato want to join the crew this is the second time Oda has done this why would he do something without planning about it? Like I said u are not The Write of One Piece u are just sharing your thoughts and opinion to what u want to happen because what u want isn't going to happen that's why u mad for Yamato joining the crew than carrot who just is friends with they doesn't show a big reason to make her a crewmate 😉.

 

[Logiko]

Ok? What u want Yamato to do? Cause we don't know why Oda do that

Fighting with the strawhats for starter.

Hmmm not with brook usopp robin and jinbei thou

Yes

ODA could have made Yamato says something else but he make Yamato want to join the crew

In a story, when a character states something that he wants.. It's very unlikely that this desire will be fullfilled with very few exceptions. That's a general rule of storytelling. It's done like this in order to add conflict.

A good dialogue for Yamato in that case would have been: "would you take me with you Luffy?"

u want to happen because what u want isn't going to happen that's why u mad for Yamato

I'm not mad about Yamato.

 

[Roo]

- The fact that after 70 chapter we still don't have a introduction for a capacity to a post on the Sunny
- The fact that she had 0 dynamic with the crew beside helping Franky
- The fact that her story right now is completely turn toward Momo and Wano despite what she is saying about the sea
- The fact that her affirmation to Luffy "As Ace brother you should be giving me a ride on the ship" is most likely a subversion, meaning that when Yamato says I'll go with Luffy, Oda is actually planning the opposite.
- The fact that her treatment is closer to a main arc character than a strawhat (the way she is drawn, the way Kaido outline her presence)
- The fact that there is right now more probable candidate and that there will likely be only one spot
- The fact that despite her backstory, she has close to no character arc in the present as of yet.

I may have forgotten something, I don't know

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

So, why are you bringing it in a context where you are trying to contradict me?

What do you mean by the way she’s drawn

 

[Animangaboy]

Fighting with the strawhats for a starter.

Then who would have protected momo,with save luffy from using gear 4 and stop kaido from going down to the live floor?

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

In a story, a character states something that he wants. It's very unlikely that this desire will be fulfilled with very few exceptions. That's a general rule of storytelling. It's done like this to add conflict.

A good dialogue for Yamato, in that case, would have been: "would you take me with you Luffy?"

, Well this isn't the story u have been reading this Oda's story he's the one who makes Yamato says what she said for a reason.

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

Yes

No, he just asks them and robin says she wants to join not the same thing

 

[Logiko]

What do you mean by the way she’s drawn

For example let's take her transformation.

With a strawhat, Oda would have taken the time and effort to display it. Sadly, Yamato only gets one very fuzy back shot and one close up.

If Yamato were to be a strawhat - furthermore with such a character - he would have taken the time to draw her and create a stronger composition. yamato's transformation was treated like any regular transformation.

Now, compare this to the way Carrot was depicted in chapter 888. Put the transformation side by side. Look at the outlining and the composition. Look also at the way they are drawn, the style, the lines etc..

This is the different between a transformation that matter, and a transformation that is only here to add depth to the character.

Then who would have protected momo,with save luffy from using gear 4 and stop kaido from going down to the live floor?

Then Oda would have created another storyline for Momo, simple.

Well this isn't the story u have been reading this Oda's story he's the one who makes Yamato says what she said for a reason.

You'll see. And the end of Wano, come back to what I told you.

No, he just asks them and robin says she wants to join not the same thing

Your point ?

 

[Animangaboy]

This is the difference between a transformation that matters and a transformation that is only here to add depth to the character.

Yamato transformation is much better than carrot sulong form so let's not try to say Yamato hybrid form is not good because Yamato ate a Mythical Zoan devil fruit one of the rarest fruit in one piece and don't have to use moonlight to transform cause how will carrot fight the black beard pirates without moonlight?

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

Then Oda would have created another storyline for Momo, simple.

Or maybe Oda should have a storyline for carrot in wano other than the Pedro situation 🤷‍♀️, blaming Perospero for his death is one of the worst things I ever read.

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

You'll see. And the end of Wano, come back to what I told you.

But we already know only u carrot fans hate the idea that why u guys are being salty about She Leaving wano idea, trying to find a different reason to make her stay in wano When Oda/Toei shows that Yamato wants to leave but u see otherwise
:cheers:

 

[Logiko]

Yamato transformation is much better than carrot sulong form so let's not try to say Yamato hybrid form is not good because Yamato ate a Mythical Zoan devil fruit one of the rarest fruit in one piece and don't have to use moonlight to transform cause how will carrot fight the black beard pirates without moonlight?

Oh yes I will try. Carrot Sulong transformation is miles in front of Yamato at least in term of treatment (the rest is completely subjective)

Or maybe Oda should have a storyline for carrot in wano other than the Pedro situation 🤷‍♀️, blaming Perospero for his death is one of the worst things I ever read.

Because you have a completely twisted logic:

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1492596255964467202

But we already know only u carrot fans hate the idea that why u guys are being salty about She Leaving wano idea, trying to find a different reason to make her stay in wano When Oda/Toei shows that Yamato wants to leave but u see otherwise

Oh no. You don't know..
You don't know at all lol

 

[Animangaboy]

Oh yes I will try. Carrot Sulong transformation is miles in front of Yamato at least in term of treatment (the rest is completely subjective)

To you only cause you such a cocksucker when it comes to that rabbit and Oda gives Yamato a beautiful transformation with both hybrid and full-on forms with Yamato devil fruit. Meanwhile, carrot just gets electric and long hair so let's not compare treatment between Mythical and once time under the moonlight transformation

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

Because you have a completely twisted logic:

Didn't Sanji choose to go on his free will because of his family?
And chopper and brook did challenge perospero also didn't they try to kill big mom who is their mother?
Also, he defends himself while using his devil fight against chopper and brook?
Pedro was the one that sacrificed himself? But Prospero once again uses his devil fruit to survive the bomb attack? So how is it his fault?
Also didn't wanda try to do the same thing when she meets nami too?

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Because you have a completely twisted logic:

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1492596255964467202

@Natalija Time for another mod to tag in and dunk on this guy

 

[Natalija]

@Natalija Time for another mod to tag in and dunk on this guy

Perospero is the best pirate and they all had it coming

 

[Logiko]

@Natalija Time for another mod to tag in and dunk on this guy

It's a twitter link, those are allowed ;)

To you only cause you such a cocksucker when it comes to that rabbit and Oda gives Yamato a beautiful transformation with both hybrid and full-on forms with Yamato devil fruit. Meanwhile, carrot just gets electric and long hair so let's not compare treatment between Mythical and once time under the moonlight transformation

I'm sorry, what ?

Let's leave homophobia at the door please. It's the second time I have to say that here. It's starting to feel like a lot.

Didn't Sanji choose to go on his free will because of his family?

Not at all, he was given no choice.

And chopper and brook did challenge perospero also didn't they try to kill big mom who is their mother?

Because of the abduction of Sanji. It's therefore not their responsibility

Pedro was the one that sacrificed himself? But Prospero once again uses his devil fruit to survive the bomb attack? So how is it his fault?
Also didn't wanda try to do the same thing when she meets nami too?

The good choice, the ethic one, was to let Pedro and the gang leave. Nothing was in danger in Big Mom's side, so there was no reason other than revenge to stick the Sunny to the floor.

The responsibility of PEdro's death is therefore on Perospero. Not the strawhat.

Accusing Pedro of being responsible is like accusing a victim of abuse of being responsible. It's deeply twisted.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

It's a twitter link, those are allowed ;)

I know that, but I also know that Nat responds to criticism of Perospero like Kiwi does for Perona, just wanted to make sure she didn’t miss the opportunity

 

[Logiko]

Perospero is the best pirate and they all had it coming

Now I'm triggered

 

[Natalija]

Now I'm triggered

 

[Logiko]

 

[Animangaboy]

Let's leave homophobia at the door please

I am not being homophobic it's just a figure of speech and a metaphor to describe your behavior about the rabbit that's all😒.

 

[Logiko]

I am not being homophobic it's just a figure of speech and a metaphor to describe your behavior about the rabbit that's all😒.

This is an homophobic figure of speech.

 

[Animangaboy]

The responsibility of PEdro's death is therefore on Perospero. Not the strawhat.

Accusing Pedro of being responsible is like accusing a victim of abuse of being responsible. It's deeply twisted.

I guess prosperso tell him to blow himself up 🤔?

Post automatically merged: Mar 9, 2022

This is a homophobic figure of speech.

It's just the word “cocksucker" it's not like I say the F word btw cocksucker is a noun too 😒, also if offend u I apologize for it ❤