General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

Who will be the next Strawhat

  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sir Yasheen

Sir Yasheen

‎
#17,804
#17,804
CarrotForNakama said:
How is that relevant ? Does the absence of panel in one arc negates her huge panel time in another ?




Because Oda clearly show Carrot's wonderous side after whole cake and at the begining of Wano. So her desire for adventure is still there.




Luffy shared food with Carrot. Something he only do with his CLOSE friends. I don't even need to show you a panel, this simple sentence is enough to debunk your statement. Plus this has nothing to do with "Luffy not accepting Carrot"




I'm talking about Carrot.

And Yamato never stated that she dreamed of going out to sea. She only DESIRES to go to sea. Quote me ONE panel when the word "dream" is stated (and don't move the goal post)
Click to expand...
Luffy literally shared food with entire countries before???? Are all the people of Water 7 his close friends
 
IIskandar1997

IIskandar1997

‎
#17,805
#17,805
CarrotForNakama said:
Exactly. Now, you understand why Carrot doesn't need a dream
Click to expand...
:nicagesmile: I never said they didnt have dreams, I meant that the character does need to literally say "My dream is ..." for you to know their dream, its very much inferred through their dialogue and characterization, Brook wanting to fulfill his promise is his dream, Jinbe wanting to change the world for the better for the sake of the fishmen is his dream, and Yamato wanting to be free is her dream, they dont need to scream it like they were Luffy
 
Monkey D Al

Monkey D Al

‎
#17,806
#17,806
CarrotForNakama said:
Nah.

Carrot is a good friend of Luffy and Luffy never showed those kind of link with Yamato. Accept it. Deal with it.
Click to expand...
Bro luffy shares food with people Wohnparke starving and he just met. They were hungry for days in that chapter and just caught a fish. They were all hungry. They are definitely friends. I might joke around but Luffy considers everyone who was on board with him a friend. And sadly that includes Larrot. But she is definitely not gonna join. Yamato on the other hand is 100% confirmed nakama. And yes she has had interactions with SH yet. But we are at war, in manga time it’s been only a few hours since she had been introduced. The SH interactions will come later.
Post automatically merged:

Yasheen said:
Luffy literally shared food with entire countries before???? Are all the people of Water 7 his close friends
Click to expand...
Thats what he does
Post automatically merged:


@CarrotForNakama Show me a panel like this where Luffy and carrot fight together and he thanks her afterwards
 
Last edited:
Cockycent

Cockycent

‎
#17,813
#17,813
Van said:
This is a lie cause she thought Momo was dead.
Click to expand...
Might have to reread then. She ran to Kuri to save his life. The other guy said the same, reread, then had to take it back.
Post automatically merged:

Animangaboy said:
Idk why u kept saying that the anime isn't important when Oda is the one that is giving the go-ahead for it. are really that dumb to think the anime isn't important like the manga?
Click to expand...
You sure you want to involve the anime lol?
 
Uncle Van

Uncle Van

Monké Don't Do Taxes
‎
#17,814
#17,814
Cockycent said:
Might have to reread then. She ran to Kuri to save his life. The other guy said the same, reread, then had to take it back.
Click to expand...
I figured you meant that, and that is not an argument in the slightest. 20 years ago, she wanted to help Momo but didn't. 20 years later, she wanted to help Momo again but needed Luffy's permission to do so. She also left Momo behind to declare she's leaving with Luffy.
 
Cockycent

Cockycent

‎
#17,815
#17,815
Van said:
I figured you meant that, and that is not an argument in the slightest. 20 years ago, she wanted to help Momo but didn't. 20 years later, she wanted to help Momo again but needed Luffy's permission to do so. She also left Momo behind to declare she's leaving with Luffy.
Click to expand...
Looks like you went back and read. Good for you. Thought you'd stick to your original post of Oda's writing being a lie.
 
Cockycent

Cockycent

‎
#17,817
#17,817
Van said:
I didn't reread. I took your wording "Yamato wanted to help Momo before Luffy was born" as "Yamato been wanting to help Momo for 20 years, which is longer than her wanting to meet Luffy."
Click to expand...
So, you're saying Yamato wanted to help Luffy before he read the journal and talked to Ace?

Both are incorrect if so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top