General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Animangaboy]

Well, good luck. All of the anime is canon for you.

I didn't say all of the anime is canon there are filtered episodes but this is an arc that is going on in both the anime and manga right now.

 

[jordin]

?
I practically admitted that I misunderstood what you said.

I can't tell if he's playing dumb to bait people or to cover up his bad arguments. He did the same earlier when I proved the scabbards babied Momo while Yamato and Luffy are different.

 

[Logiko]

Luffy literally shared food with entire countries before???? Are all the people of Water 7 his close friends

Luffy never shares food. It's his moto. Read the story again.

I never said they didnt have dreams, I meant that the character does need to literally say "My dream is ..." for you to know their dream, its very much inferred through their dialogue and characterization, Brook wanting to fulfill his promise is his dream, Jinbe wanting to change the world for the better for the sake of the fishmen is his dream, and Yamato wanting to be free is her dream, they dont need to scream it like they were Luffy

A future strawhat doesn't need that in fact neither Yamato or Carrot did that. Same as multiple strawhats. A strawhat needs a strong desire. Not a dream. A dream is something that the fanbase created. In reality, most strawhats don't have dreams, they have strong desires and goals.

Bro luffy shares food with people Wohnparke starving and he just met.

He only do that with his friends. Luffy didn't shared food, he gave water. Completely different. It was a gift, not an act of sharing. Luffy doesn't share. (usually at least).

Or are you saying that Oda are Luffy are lying ? (it's litterally written in the story, don't try to counter that just for the sake of countering what I say, there is no argument for you here, Accept it)

Yamato on the other hand is 100% confirmed nakama.

Still no.

And yes she has had interactions with SH yet.

No.

SH yet. But we are at war, in manga time it’s been only a few hours since she had been introduced. The SH interactions will come later.

Wrong and irrelevant argument. It has been 70 chapter since Yamato was introduced. Just so you understand, 70 chapters is TWO TIMES the size of the Marineford arc. During this time, Luffy had the privilege of meeting nearly every commanders of white Beard's fleet. The number of chapter or the war are therefore not an excuse to explain the lack of interaction between the strawhats and Yamato.

Oda is showing that he is not interested in having those kind of interaction, period.

So u are just going to forget about chapter 1025 and 1026? With luffy smile and share combo attack together?

Luffy is smiling a lot to his ally (like Law for exemple) does it mean that Law have the same bond with Luffy that Luffy has with the strawhat ?

No. Mentionning the chapters 1025/26 is therefore irrelevant.

Idk why u kept saying that the anime isn't important when Oda is the one that is giving the go-ahead for it. are really that dumb to think the anime isn't important like the manga?

Oda is not giving the "go ahead" for the anime. In fact there is occurence of the anime going the opposite way of the canon material.

I understand simping for Carrot but saying Yamato doesn't have a dream is the most delusional thing I've ever read LMAOOOOOOO

She has a desire, we don't know what her dream is.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Luffy never shares food. It's his moto. Read the story again.




A future strawhat doesn't need that in fact neither Yamato or Carrot did that. Same as multiple strawhats. A strawhat needs a strong desire. Not a dream. A dream is something that the fanbase created. In reality, most strawhats don't have dreams, they have strong desires and goals.



He only do that with his friends. Luffy didn't shared food, he gave water. Completely different. It was a gift, not an act of sharing. Luffy doesn't share. (usually at least).

Or are you saying that Oda are Luffy are lying ? (it's litterally written in the story, don't try to counter that just for the sake of countering what I say, there is no argument for you here, Accept it)



Still no.




No.




Wrong and irrelevant argument. It has been 70 chapter since Yamato was introduced. Just so you understand, 70 chapters is TWO TIMES the size of the Marineford arc. During this time, Luffy had the privilege of meeting nearly every commanders of white Beard's fleet. The number of chapter or the war are therefore not an excuse to explain the lack of interaction between the strawhats and Yamato.

Oda is showing that he is not interested in having those kind of interaction, period.




Luffy is smiling a lot to his ally (like Law for exemple) does it mean that Law have the same bond with Luffy that Luffy has with the strawhat ?

No. Mentionning the chapters 1025/26 is therefore irrelevant.




Oda is not giving the "go ahead" for the anime. In fact there is occurence of the anime going the opposite way of the canon material.




She has a desire, we don't know what her dream is.

So Luffy bought all that meat for water 7 not to share it?

 

[Cockycent]

Tbf, retainers wouldn't leave Momo if he was begging them to stay with him or tell him to fight Kaido even if it kills him.

They did attempt to leave him tho lol

 

[jordin]

They did attempt to leave him tho lol

Right, in the arms of a scabbard.

 

[Logiko]

So Luffy bought all that meat for water 7 not to share it?

He gifted that meat, what was for him, he did not share.

"Pirate don't share meat, I want ALL the meat" - Luffy (Fishmen Island)

There is no point in trying to twist your way out of the argument. Luffy don't share, Period. That's why Luffy sharing food with Carrot is exceptionnal and Oda knows that.

 

[Topi Jerami]

Show me a panel where Luffy and Carrot interact. He doesn’t even notice her existence. You are lying here

Difference between Carrot and Yamao is Luffy remembers Carrot's name correctly, while Yamao is Yamao.

 

[Cockycent]

Exactly! Yamato went from someone who sounded like she was ready to literally give up her life for Momo to someone who put Momo on the same level as her!
To me, this clearly shows clear development on their relationship (btw before you ask, I think Yamato will definitely make Momo aware that she wants to go out to the sea with Luffy)

Umm, I don't think Yamato has to even share that with him. Just get on the ship and away from Retainer Duty. Easy as that.

Post automatically merged: Mar 12, 2022

Right, in the arms of a scabbard.

You said they wouldn't leave him if he was begging and that is a situation that actually took place
Gotta reread man

 

[Animangaboy]

Luffy is smiling a lot to his ally (like Law for exemple) does it mean that Law have the same bond with Luffy that Luffy has with the strawhat ?

No. Mentionning the chapters 1025/26 is therefore irrelevant.

Both law and the strawhats have a bond together, he was literally with them through Punk Hazard and more also luffy call law his friend if u think that luffy and law doesn't have a bond u are stupid af

 

[Cockycent]

Difference between Carrot and Yamao is Luffy remembers Carrot's name correctly, while Yamao is Yamao.

Maybe Joyboy might say Yamato, but so far Luffy has not. Yamato shouldn't be hard to remember. Luffy just doesn't want to say the Retainer Duty guy's name right.

 

[Animangaboy]

He gifted that meat, what was for him, he did not share.

"Pirate don't share meat, I want ALL the meat" - Luffy (Fishmen Island)

There is no point in trying to twist your way out of the argument. Luffy doesn't share, Period. That's why Luffy sharing food with Carrot is exceptional and Oda knows that.

Wasn't all of them was hungry during the time? Why u think that when luffy tells carrot to have some means something?

Post automatically merged: Mar 12, 2022

Mentionning the chapters 1025/26 is therefore irrelevant.

Keep telling yourself that

 

[jordin]

Gotta reread man

If he's meant to be baby'd and protected, why take him to Onigashima?

 

[Animangaboy]

Oda is not giving the "go ahead" for the anime. In fact there is occurence of the anime going the opposite way of the canon material.

So how is the anime is going on without ODA orders? Then

 

[Monkey D Al]

"Pirate don't share meat, I want ALL the meat" - Luffy (Fishmen Island)

You know what heroes do? They share their meat, I want all the meat for myself. I like heroes but I don’t wanna be one. -Luffy in fishman Island and zoro said the same about liquor. Yet both have shared their meat and liquor.

70 chapters don’t matter or a 100 chapters. They are at war she didn’t have the time to go around and meet people. Luffy during Marine Ford arc has had interactions with Marco when he saved him and that was literally it. Vista saved him from mihawk and he said thanks old dude and left.

Yamato was busy being helpful during the war Larrot was busy getting owned by perospero

 

[Cockycent]

Got you to go back and reread twice now. I've done my part.

Just need Yamato to escape Retainer Hell.

 

[Logiko]

Both law and the strawhats have a bond together, he was literally with them through Punk Hazard and more also luffy call law his friend if u think that luffy and law doesn't have a bond u are stupid af

Reread what I wrote AND CAREFULLY before putting irrelevant words in my mouth that I didn't say.

Wasn't all of them was hungry during the time? Why u think that when luffy tells carrot to have some means something?

He gifted that meat, what was for him, he did not share.

"Pirate don't share meat, I want ALL the meat" - Luffy (Fishmen Island)

There is no point in trying to twist your way out of the argument. Luffy don't share, Period. That's why Luffy sharing food with Carrot is exceptionnal and Oda knows that.

Read

So how is the anime is going on without ODA orders? Then

The anime is following the manga. Oda doesn't need to be involved.

 

[Roo]

Luffy literally called Law his nakama and considers him in the same vein as Jinbe. If it was up to Luffy Law would never leave them alone. It's to the point where Oda himself mocks Law via Kid.

 

[Logiko]

You know what heroes do? They share their meat, I want all the meat for myself. I like heroes but I don’t wanna be one. -Luffy in fishman Island and zoro said the same about liquor. Yet both have shared their meat and liquor.

Wrong. Luffy almost never share. Buying meat with Nami's money is not "sharing"

70 chapters don’t matter or a 100 chapters. They are at war she didn’t have the time to go around and meet people. Luffy during Marine Ford arc has had interactions with Marco when he saved him and that was literally it. Vista saved him from mihawk and he said thanks old dude and left.

70 chapter MATTERS. Wether you like it or not, if Yamato wasn't introduced with a strong dynamic with the strawhats, it says narratively that she DOESN'T NEED to have one. Luffy met multiple friends both during the war and impel down where the situation was also extreme, so again.. the war is NOT an excuse for the lack of dynamic.

 

[Animangaboy]

The anime is following the manga. Oda doesn't need to be involved

But who created the manga? U do realize Oda can sue Toei for using his manga without his say in 😴.