General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Logiko]

Every scene in The Room is crafted with more consideration and narrative know how than anything you’ve said and we both know it

LMAO - I won't lie.. I almost spilled out my water

end of Wano maybe lol

Sooner than that.

Even after Yamato possibly joins he will call it a red herring, so never...

No. If Yamato join I will be glad. I like her. But it won't negate everything I said about Carrot. One doesn't exclude the other.

So because she is white that why she different? Also bepo is white so that means he is a special mink too?

She Bepo is different. He is also a special mink. Not as important as CArrot but special nonetheless.

What her jumping to tell wanda what's up?

OOps sorry, 804, when she floats to avoid ZOro.

so aren't you contradicting yourself by what you just said here??

No. The fight doesn't matter. I COULD matter only if Oda were to choose a different pass for Carrot.

Before the fight, I also thought that this fight would matter. But seing the result, it was not the case. Only the defeat is important. Because the fight was not about values put in conflict, it was about Carrot witnessing how far she was from understanding how a Pirate Life was working.

 

[Kuruka]

Why would they ? Most youtubers are not analyst

youve shown that you arn't either

There is a rule with Oda. If a fight don't matter, there is no need to show it. That was the case here with Carrot. Her fight wasn't the focal point of her action. On the contrary, her defeat was, we can see that because of the treatment of that defeat. It has impact, it has value. In that matter, the speech of Perospero is very important because he is a bad guy and Carrot a good one. This must not be ignored. This defeat will come into play in the arc of Carrot, must it be with a simple flashback or something more.

not showing her struggle to win makes the defeat that much more empty.
imagine if we skipped most of the lucci fight and skipped to his defeat...it would be empty.
the fact that he skipped over carrots fight shows he is unwilling to give her proper development of a strawhat.

Nah, this was in fact a pretty basic and objective deconstruction

you're not qualified to speak on that...and what you did was pretty embarrasing.

If you only took her lack of panel in Wano has a counter indication that she wasn't going to be one, then you ignored all that happened in whole cake. That's not called analysis, that's called blindness.

I definitely didn't ignore what happened in whole cake...because after WCI I thought she was the strongest contender..but the lack of focus and the lackluster development with perospero(which ended in WANO) lowered her chances.

Nami doesn't nullifies anything, she is here as a focus helper, her body acts as a frame to help the reader focus on the center of the panel. Much like parenthesis. "( )"

"focus helper" is not an actual term in composition of shots...you just made that up on the spot.
like i said, the more you type the more you embarass yourself as a carrot fan...youre actually more like a blind fanboy really.

Nah

you really cant debunk any of my analysis at this point lol

Still no. I have my reasons. You have my profil picture which is a simple outlining. This should be enough.

I already know your reasons...youre simply not qualified..
.youre on a anime FORUM, theres honestly no need to pretend to know stuff..especially when there are people here that ACTUALLY do.

Yes, her head and torso.

her whole body should be front and center. its not.

 

[Fuckthis3]

by the looks of it this won't end till one joins

Or you close the thread right now till someone joins

 

[Jew D. Boy]

LMAO - I won't lie.. I almost spilled out my water



Sooner than that.




No. If Yamato join I will be glad. I like her. But it won't negate everything I said about Carrot. One doesn't exclude the other.




She Bepo is different. He is also a special mink. Not as important as CArrot but special nonetheless.


OOps sorry, 804, when she floats to avoid ZOro.




No. The fight doesn't matter. I COULD matter only if Oda were to choose a different pass for Carrot.

Before the fight, I also thought that this fight would matter. But seing the result, it was not the case. Only the defeat is important. Because the fight was not about values put in conflict, it was about Carrot witnessing how far she was from understanding how a Pirate Life was working.

I mean, people still pay to go see Wiseau at live screenings all the time and enjoy his vision, how much money do YOU make off this “analysis” bullshit??

 

[AL sama]

No. The fight doesn't matter. I COULD matter only if Oda were to choose a different pass for Carrot.

Before the fight, I also thought that this fight would matter. But seing the result, it was not the case. Only the defeat is important. Because the fight was not about values put in conflict, it was about Carrot witnessing how far she was from understanding how a Pirate Life was working.

so if only the result mattered then why wasn't the fight fully off screened??

according to you that should be the rule

 

[Animangaboy]

She Bepo is different. He is also a special mink. Not as important as CArrot but special nonetheless.

Please bepo is more important than carrot he's is part of law crew, and also have more character moment than carrot

Post automatically merged: Mar 13, 2022

OOps sorry, 804, when she floats to avoid Zoro.

Dude that's called dodging in mid-air not floating

 

[Logiko]

youve shown that you arn't either

Well you haven't listen enough

not showing her struggle to win makes the defeat that much more empty.

COmpeltely wrong. It makes her defeat unexpected.

The result of a fight doesn't apply because of the status of said fight but because of expectations around it. That's why the ending between Katakuri and Luffy wasn't accepted well at first.

the fact that he skipped over carrots fight shows he is unwilling to give her proper development of a strawhat.

Wrong. This has nothing to do with it.

you're not qualified to speak on that...and what you did was pretty embarrasing.

To someone who is not willing to listen .. yes.. Your deconstruction was lazy.. at best. Don't try to make yourself better than you are.

I definitely didn't ignore what happened in whole cake...because after WCI I thought she was the strongest contender..but the lack of focus and the lackluster development with perospero(which ended in WANO) lowered her chances.

Meaning that what you see in Wano, ereases what you saw in whole cake. That's exactly my point. You are ignoring what happened because of a bias telling you that the present is all that matters.

"focus helper" is not an actual term in composition of shots...

Indeed, that's a neologism. The concept of focus helper doesn't have a name. Usually people say "an object that helps the focus of the eyes on a target" (a different thing that the usual line of sights) I love to categorize things so "focus helper" it is.

you really cant debunk any of my analysis at this point lol

Already done.

I already know your reasons...youre simply not qualified..
.youre on a anime FORUM, theres honestly no need to pretend to know stuff..especially when there are people here that ACTUALLY do.

When 10 or more people insult you or are calling you dellusional for stating an analysis. Yes. it's necessary. But don't worry, I enjoy this.

her whole body should be front and center. its not.

No. That's not how composition works.

Or you close the thread right now till someone joins

I'm okay with that. I need some vacancy.

so if only the result mattered then why wasn't the fight fully off screened??

It was.

Only the introduction of the fight was not. Precisely because Oda needed to subvert the readers expectation.

By showing Carrot in a shining light in chapter 995, Oda created the expectation that Perospero would get destroyed by the girl.

This expectation works both for the reader, and for Carrot. So.. when Carrot is defeated, it works both way too. It's a simple storytelling trick but very impactfull and clever one.

Please bepo is more important than carrot he's is part of law crew, and also have more character moment than carrot

Yeah.. you just forfeited you right of legitimacy here

Dude that's called dodging in mid-air not floating

No, that's called floating. There is no dodging here. Carrot doesn't have gepo. If you can't see that... No wonder you can't see anything else.

 

[Blizz532]

Or you close the thread right now till someone joins

I second this

 

[Animangaboy]

, that's called floating. There is no dodging here. Carrot doesn't have gepo. If you can't see that... No wonder you can't see anything else.

So that makes carrot so special?

Post automatically merged: Mar 13, 2022

Yeah.

Also what color does a bunny have in real life isn't white?

 

[Roo]

@CarrotForNakama

I know I said whoever joins the SH vs Kaido is likely joining but I think we can always give a small chance to someone sneaking in and leaving with them or joining through other unconventional means

So I think it is safe to say this current competition will be over whenever the SHs finally sail away from Wano

 

[Fuckthis3]

Ya heard them AL close this shit and let em find a new life

 

[Logiko]

So that makes carrot so special?

Already told you. Listen or don't reply.

Also what color does a bunny have in real life isn't white?

Bunny are usually not white.

So I think it is safe to say this current competition will be over whenever the SHs finally sail away from Wano

Of course. But by that point, there will be enough evidence to rule out one or the other candidate.

Ya heard them AL close this shit and let em find a new life

Or everyone starts to listen on why Carrot has her chances and stop the "Carrot is irrelevant" Bias just because she was not depicted to much in this arc.

 

[AL sama]

It was.

Only the introduction of the fight was not. Precisely because Oda needed to subvert the readers expectation.

By showing Carrot in a shining light in chapter 995, Oda created the expectation that Perospero would get destroyed by the girl.

This expectation works both for the reader, and for Carrot. So.. when Carrot is defeated, it works both way too. It's a simple storytelling trick but very impactfull and clever one.

uh no it wasn't fully off screened cause the fight was shown regardless of how little content there was

that according to you should be going against oda's rule of not showing a fight if its not important

 

[Fuckthis3]

Already told you. Listen or don't reply.




Bunny are usually not white.



Of course. But by that point, there will be enough evidence to rule out one or the other candidate.




Or everyone starts to listen on why Carrot has her chances and stop the "Carrot is irrelevant" Bias just because she was not depicted to much in this arc.

Agree but they won't so close time

 

[Staticshadic]

Already told you. Listen or don't reply.




Bunny are usually not white.



Of course. But by that point, there will be enough evidence to rule out one or the other candidate.




Or everyone starts to listen on why Carrot has her chances and stop the "Carrot is irrelevant" Bias just because she was not depicted to much in this arc.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/247wal...03/28/39-most-famous-bunnies-of-all-time/amp/

 

[AL sama]

No, that's called floating. There is no dodging here. Carrot doesn't have gepo. If you can't see that... No wonder you can't see anything else.

are you talking about when zoro attacked her in zou??

 

[Animangaboy]

Already told you. Listen or don't reply.

It's not a big deal to be honest look at yamato and the other tobi roppo we can tell the difference between them

Post automatically merged: Mar 13, 2022

Bunny are usually not white

Are you sure about this one?

 

[AL sama]

Or everyone starts to listen on why Carrot has her chances and stop the "Carrot is irrelevant" Bias just because she was not depicted to much in this arc.

why can't people have their own stances??

 

[Roo]

Carrot being irrelevant is a very good point. Put your bias aside and ask yourself, how many actual candidates were treated like she was in Wano?

 

[AL sama]

Are you sure about this one?

the most common colors for rabbits are white brown gray and black