Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
Lupines being Rabbit creatures established Rabbit behavior in One Piece.
Not really a leap of logic to think Oda had more foresight with Carrot than Yamato. I showed you a timeline with established behavior and interactions.
Your dumb as hell mate.

Please get help.
Post automatically merged:

This is like saying Shu’s a white guard dog from the first few chapters of One Piece and that is somehow foreshadowing Yamato.
Pretty much.

I mean how dumb does a person have to be?
 
Last edited:
Is Carrot in such a bad place that the Yamao cult has to add on to her bad arguments? :kidwat:

You could do this same compilation for the dozens of wolves and oni references throughout the story. The cloud wolves were drawn to the SH's fire and instantly bonded with them at their Skypeia party. Does that mean Yamato was foreshadowed to instantly help Luffy over 800 chapters ago?
Dozens!?!? I doubt it. You named one reference showing Normal Wolf behavior. Jabra shows Normal Wolves are typically vicious. Though in the end, Yamato being a Mythical Wolf throws out most of the Normal Wolf comparisons. Yamato doesn't even look like a Normal Wolf.

And yeah, apparently Yamato is similar to those cloud wolves being drawn to Luffy and teaching Momo about creating clouds like Kaido.
:goatasure:
 

Uncle Van

Bullets don't hurt. But Taxes do.
I mean...yeah...but no lol.

Carrot states going on a Wonderland adventure while on Sunny. She happens to be a white rabbit going to a Wonderland themed Totto land. This reference is directly connected with volume 2. The connection is two-fold: Rabbit and Wonderland.

Shu is a white Normal Dog guarding their dead master's shop. Yamato is a Mythical Dog guarding Oden's Journal until Momo came along. Is there an Oda reference in the manga, volume, or SBS about Mythical Dogs?
There's so many things you'd have to disregard in order to push the idea that Carrot was foreshadowed/planned since 2000.

1. Nowhere to be seen in any of the SH concepts even when it was supposed to end in 2002

2. The white wolves in Skypia

3. The supernovas being last minutes creations yet being important to the plot.

4. Every SH planned ahead were actually important to the series

5. Carrot's utter lack of creativity and relevance, which would make her the first and only supposedly important character foreshadowed way back to be treated such a way

This once again boils down to claiming Oda is changing his writing style for Carrot alone.
 
Your dumb as hell mate.

Please get help.
Post automatically merged:


Pretty much.

I mean how dumb does a person have to be?
Nah I'm not dumb. If you don't understand, that's on your competence.

It's simple. Carrot is connected to Wonderland. A rabbit character from Alice in Wonderland was mentioned in volume 2. Then there is a list of rabbit behavior and characteristics followed by potential hints of design with Minks on auction list and rabbit doll. If you actually thought about what I'm stating maybe you'd understand.
 
The White Rabbit was referenced by Oda. I'm establishing Oda was thinking about it way back then. When the Wonderland connection to Carrot happened from there is unknown. It could have lingered until Mink concepts.

Chapter 175 cover of a jaguar with a rabbit hat is at least questionable given the relation we saw with Pedro and Carrot.

I'm not serious about rabbits flying. It's just a funny coincidence the flying statement was stated in the manga about a rabbit creature.
U really think all of that is connected to carrot? I thought u were smarter than that but I guess you are just like C4N trying to prove something that oda never said and hints about 😑
 
Last edited:
Nah I'm not dumb. If you don't understand, that's on your competence.

It's simple. Carrot is connected to Wonderland. A rabbit character from Alice in Wonderland was mentioned in volume 2. Then there is a list of rabbit behavior and characteristics followed by potential hints of design with Minks on auction list and rabbit doll. If you actually thought about what I'm stating maybe you'd understand.
No mate your pretty dumb
 

Uncle Van

Bullets don't hurt. But Taxes do.
Nah I'm not dumb. If you don't understand, that's on your competence.

It's simple. Carrot is connected to Wonderland. A rabbit character from Alice in Wonderland was mentioned in volume 2. Then there is a list of rabbit behavior and characteristics followed by potential hints of design with Minks on auction list and rabbit doll. If you actually thought about what I'm stating maybe you'd understand.
Can you explain how Carrot was foreshadowed since the year 2000 when she's completely absent from all the SH concept art when even Jinbe was present?

SH pirates were also originally planned to be complete preskip with Jinbe, no Carrot to be mentioned.
 
Yet another chapter where future Strawhat Carrot does fuck all to distinguish herself from the background characters. :suresure:
What do you mean? Carrot, the unique designed and long planned future SH, is right here bearing witness to Jinbe's fishman karate.



Chopper also knows she's near Jinbe so that's why he doesn't bother to look for his little sis.

 
What do you mean? Carrot, the unique designed and long planned future SH, is right here bearing witness to Jinbe's fishman karate.



Chopper also knows she's near Jinbe so that's why he doesn't bother to look for his little sis.

Damn, even Chopper and Nami who were the closest to Carrot don’t give a fuck about her. Even for Oda that’s cold. :kobeha:
 
There's so many things you'd have to disregard in order to push the idea that Carrot was foreshadowed/planned since 2000.

1. Nowhere to be seen in any of the SH concepts even it was supposed to end in 2002

2. The white wolves in Skypia

3. The supernovas being last minutes creations yet being important to the plot.

4. Every SH planned ahead we're actually important to the series

5. Carrot's utter lack of creativity and relevance, which would make her the first and only supposedly important character foreshadowed by back to be treated such a way

This once again boils down to claiming Oda is changing his writing style for Carrot alone.
Chapter 501 Minks were introduced. That was June 2, 2008. Inuarashi and Nekomamushi designs would be among the first as Kozuki Clan retainers. Build the Mokomo Kingdom from there in Zou on Zunesha who knows about Joy Boy which is HUGE to the overall plot. This importance is why the Minks creation could be much earlier. Look how big the One Piece world is. That's a lot for Oda to consider and weave together. That's what, about 11 years from start of the series. We are now in year 25. Halfway mark.
Can you explain how Carrot was foreshadowed since the year 2000 when she's completely absent from all the SH concept art when even Jinbe was present?

SH pirates were also originally planned to be complete preskip with Jinbe, no Carrot to be mentioned.
I'm not saying Carrot's character was definitively established that far back. It's that Oda has shown to display multiple types of rabbits in manga or reference in volume/SBS/etc. Carrot's exact creation is unknown but I'd say Rabbit Mink concepts were likely in his earlier drafts of the Mink Tribe. And going by what we know, Oda likely thought of characteristics from his earlier representations of Rabbits in One Piece in designing Carrot.

To again clarify, I am not stating Carrot has been given crewmate treatment. Oda has designed/created characters in advance that were not Strawhats.

The topic was foreshadowing of Carrot and Yamato. From there it is now establishing a timeline of development.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top