General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Logiko]

Nah, wth did I just read, Carrot is more important than Robin in the overall arc?

You seems to have a problem reading simple things. That's not what is written here. But yes Carrot is indeed more important in Whole cake than Robin in Alabasta hands down. Just because of her treatment only. If you can understand that you may have a reading problem.

The fact that Robin knows about the Ancient Weapon Pluton but lies about it to crocodile goes over everything that carrot does in the ONE PIECES story 👀.

It only makes Robin important for the story, not for the arc in itself. Narratively Robin is not that important for the arc itself. It's basic storytelling.

This thread. Read your comments and you’ll understand why you got banned.

There is nothing problematic with my comment on the countrary to yours and multiple people here who are often going as far as insults.

In fact use your advice. Go read the thread again. I've never insulted directely anyone.

You guyz can't phasm the fact that I won't move one bit on my point of view. You are ten sometimes more and you are still losing in the argument against one single Carrot fan. You don't have knowledge, you are using fallacious arguments, you are unable to brings narrative evidences while I can do all of that and more.

So you get toxic.. both you and the mods.. so of course I will be the one to get ban.. it always easier to get rid of the opposition rather than taking a good look at ourself lol

 

[BOCCHI]

In fact Yamato is missing the same exact things Carrot is missing:

The understanding of Luffy's importance and the reason why they MUST follow HIM and not someone else. The reason why they would be willing to put their life on the line for him

By no means is Yamato missing this part. She even acknowledge it. Yamato knows how significant Luffy is. Can’t say the same about little bunny girl.

 

[Ballel]

We are not about the character here, we are talking about the actions. What you just said is irrelevant to the conversation. In term of character of course Robin has an advantage over Carrot as she can read poneglyph. But reading poneglyph doesn't make her more important that Carrot in the overall arc.

That's basic storytelling and you can't understand that.

Serious question now: are you a troll???

Because I really hope you are.

 

[Monkey D Al]

There is nothing problematic with my comment on the countrary to yours and multiple people here who are often going as far as insults.

In fact use your advice. Go read the thread again. I've never insulted directely anyone.

Neither have I or should I say we. We’ve only said the truth and the truth can not be an insult

 

[BOCCHI]

Nah, wth did I just read, Carrot is more important than Robin in the overall arc?

Carrot was never more important than anyone in any arc lol

 

[Monkey D Al]

Carrot was never more important than anyone in any arc lol

Words of wisdom. I dare say that Sakura haruno is more important to the one piece story than Larrot

 

[KenshiraSonata]

Here we have a proof that mods only give a fuck about clicks and posts to have huge traffic.

Because there was no reason to unban that guy from this thread

We really missed him and mods know that :)

Post automatically merged: Apr 19, 2022

Carrot was never more important than anyone in any arc lol

without a doubt one of most bland and boring character in all of OP

 

[Logiko]

By no means is Yamato missing this part. She even acknowledge it. Yamato knows how significant Luffy is. Can’t say the same about little bunny girl.

She know how important Luffy is for Wano, not for the world or the realm of piracy.

Serious question now: are you a troll???

Because I really hope you are.

There is nothing difficult to understand in what I'm writing and no, I'm not a troll.

Neither have I or should I say we. We’ve only said the truth and the truth can not be an insult

I treat you as a group because it can't be done otherwise for me, but if you specifically were not, good for you!

Carrot was never more important than anyone in any arc lol

Yes she was. For example, Carrot was more important than Chopper in whole cake.

without a doubt one of most bland and boring character in all of OP

Only for you.. the poll begs to differ:

 

[Monkey D Al]

Only for you.. the poll begs to differ:

The poll is wrong. There is a lot of kids voting who like her for being cute and fun. They don’t care for character depth.

 

[Animangaboy]

Yes she was. For example, Carrot was more important than Chopper in whole cake

Chopper was fighting Bigmom and was also taking attacked from her? Not to mention chopper was the one who come up with the idea in the Mirror world 😭😭😭😂

 

[Rootbeer]

When Carrot will see Luffy defeated on the live floor she’s going to go from dogshit to apeshit.. She will betray the Strawhats and her race, it’s going to be glorious..


Dark Carrot incoming

 

[Logiko]

The poll is wrong. There is a lot of kids voting who like her for being cute and fun. They don’t care for character depth.

Maybe for a small fraction.. the fact is here.. She outmatch the majority of the character.

Carrot is not "bland" only primary anti-Carrot and some Yamato fans think that. I don't even need to reply to this, the story speak for itself :cheers:

Chopper was fighting Bigmom

Can you show me a panel of Whole cake showing Chopper attacking Big Mom please ?

Also Yeah a little plan while Carrot had two chapters dedicated to her saving the crew. Your argumentation is irrelevant here. Carrot was more important than chapter both in term of character and narratively period.

 

[AL sama]

almost 6 years and carrot is still in primary phase

 

[Finalbeta]

Oda is a man possibly capable to even allow Pedro to "come back to life".

I don't see it still

 

[Monkey D Al]

Carrot is not "bland" only primary anti-Carrot and some Yamato fans think that. I don't even need to reply to this,

Okay than mentioned(you don’t even need to show me, just mention) one instance where she had an interesting moment, where she said something deep. Mention a moment where she said something similar of importance and impact like Yamato “we will die together” or yamatos “I will protect you with my life”.

 

[Logiko]

Okay than mentioned(you don’t even need to show me, just mention) one instance where she had an interesting moment, where she said something deep. Mention a moment where she said something similar of importance and impact like Yamato “we will die together” or yamatos “I will protect you with my life”.

Chapter 902 - The entire interaction between Carrot and Sanji.

Not only it is an amazing characterization moment for Carrot with even more emotionnal weight that what you just mentionned, but it helps setting up the entire tone of the chapter while making Carrot help Sanji getting rid of his final burden in the arc.

Carrot is not a bland character. Only ignorant people or people that are not interested in One Piece's storytelling can say that.

 

[Animangaboy]

you show me a panel of Whole cake showing Chopper attacking Big Mom please

I don't see a panel of it but it was in the anime thou 🤔

 

[BOCCHI]

Okay than mentioned(you don’t even need to show me, just mention) one instance where she had an interesting moment, where she said something deep. Mention a moment where she said something similar of importance and impact like Yamato “we will die together” or yamatos “I will protect you with my life”.

It simply doesn’t exist. Even Tama had more focus, significance and closer relationship with the SHs than what Carrot had in 3 arcs lol

 

[Logiko]

I don't see a panel of it but it was in the anime thou 🤔

Only the manga counts when we are analysing One Piece. There was no panel showing Chopper fighting Big Mom. It was a mendela effect due to the opening.

Carrot was undeniably more important than Chopper in Whole cake. And for good reasons. The point was to make Chopper react to Carrot doing amazing stuff while giving both a good relationship.

It simply doesn’t exist. Even Tama had more focus, significance and closer relationship with the SHs than what Carrot had in 3 arcs lol

Chapter 902 - The entire interaction between Carrot and Sanji.

Not only it is an amazing characterization moment for Carrot with even more emotionnal weight that what you just mentionned, but it helps setting up the entire tone of the chapter while making Carrot help Sanji getting rid of his final burden in the arc.

Carrot is not a bland character. Only ignorant people or people that are not interested in One Piece's storytelling can say that.

 

[JohnnyBme]

Oda is a man possibly capable to even allow Pedro to "come back to life".

I don't see it still

perospero should have died or at least more seriously injured but no we on shonen jump