[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Michelle]

I felt it was odd no one claimed being shot at during the night and survive, apparently Gram told me players won't be told about it unless hypothetically they've a role of such functionality.​

share your reads please

Scum will never say who they shot overnight isn't it?

 

[Michelle]

I am working so this is all i can do for now, catching up on the last few pages

Spoiler

What meta do you have for him?

No, but we need a counter wagon and Neeko is a good one

yes


What other explanation can be? What if he wants to go under the radar?
Like few others tbh. Lack of activity from few people is concerning if they are town

Makes sense but you can't judge the others after your own behaviour

Most probably yes, if they are partners and if Arp's role is not so important in the pack

not really, except i have SK as solid town read, with Ekko, Pein and Pet Goblin.
In scum reads Neeko, Cooler (just sheeping because I didn't pay attention to him), Lethal.

The other very low poster who talked about us being in scum chat together can go either way. One, if he is scum he thought he can link me with him and make me go down with him at his flip, the other, he as town looked like he wanted to test me by joking and that is a very towny attitude. I need to Iso.

I have to think at Kagu, some of his posts are good thoughts, idk if he posts like that as scum, I don't know scum range, so he is null for me, going up from scum read.

I dislike strongly the way Cal posted at SoD and the way he played gives me a policy lynch urge, but I don't want to go in that part, I put Cal in null as well, no more town read. The way he linked himself to Fuji/Professor deserves some analysis.

Ratchet idk and that is worrisome.

I need to put a lot of work itt today, but after my actual work day :)

@SoulKiller you asked me about reads, this is what I have without rereading what I want to read

I find very good your post on Neeko and I support the wagon, i prefer this instead Cooler because no matter alignament Cooler will not endgame, while Neeko is keeping a low profile for now which is never towny behaviour.
If we let him go today, tomorow one or 2 towny voices will cease to exist and scum will have a more comfortable thread postition, so if he is scum indeed like we suspect we may not have the possibility to lynch him.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

share your reads please

Scum will never say who they shot overnight isn't it?

I'm not reading the game much but i trust you, SK, Ekko and T Pein since D1.

Lord Melkor played little scummy EoD D1 but he gave 2 allignment ratios which is more likely to be genuine than not.

Pott Goblin as scum make tryhard posts. It doesn't feel like he's doing so here, he's coming out very casual i think he's town.

Cooler is definitely scum.
Kaguu is another person likely to be scum here, I've her quotes saved I'd make it a new post. Ratchet and Fuji are two i want to Iso. Got nothing on em but gut reads.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Scum will never say who they shot overnight isn't it?

No but townies do who gets shot at. But this game they wouldn't be told if a kill fails on em,

 

[Nana]

thinking about it more, i think ekko should duel cooler if his ability gets refilled or vig should just off cooler if that isnt an option

cooler has been largely inactive and i doubt hes going to be more present going forward based on his last few posts so i dont think his flip will really give us much insight on who his potential scum mates might be if he is red

Why is cooler sus in the first place?

 

[Nana]

Hammer this dude.
Claims being vanilla then says he wont claim
Wut.

What? He claimed vanilla?

 

[T-Pein™]

What? He claimed vanilla?

Keep reading a page further.
Twitter quotes it

 

[Mashiro Blue]

Your Queen thinks Pot is Town

I am pretty confident on meta reading Ultra and it really strikes me as his Town play.

He may stay around the palace and help find the ones who conspire against the Throne

 

[Michelle]

Pero might just be too scummy to be scum idk

oops

Day 1 Vote Count 5

Ekko 2 - TAC, Cooler
Arp 6 - Neeko, Soulkiller, Tpein, Blue, Phoenix, Ultra
Charlie 1 - Chevy
Ratchet 1 - Ekko
Pero 4 - Lord Melkor, RippedCal, Worst, Dofla
TAC 1 - KWEH
Chevy 2 - Michelle, Kagurashii
Dofla 2 - Broki, Pero

32 players alive, 17 votes to lynch. You have approx 20 hours remaining.​

in the 10 players voting for red scum I would be surprised to not have at least a mate

what do you think of wifom kagu?

what do you want to achieve with this question Neeko?|

i got somewhat similar vibes. the level of indignation doesn't seem appropriate for a scum player.

If Neeko is red scum, i think Ultra is not aligned with him because of this post. When a townie is wrong, scum likes to take that post and make a comment on it, either supporting or pushing that wrong idea.

 

[Michelle]

Blue back to RPing is deffinitely cool, but is not AI

 

[Ratchet]

VC pl0x

 

[Michelle]

Day 1 Vote Count 7

Ekko 4 - TAC, Cooler, Phoenix, hime, Neeko
Arp 5 - Soulkiller, Tpein, Blue, Ultra, KWEH
Pero 5 - Lord Melkor, RippedCal, Worst, Dofla, Chevy
Chevy 1 - Michelle
Dofla 2 - Broki, Pero
Charlie 1 - Fuji
Blue 1 - Kagurashii
Cooler 1 - Ekko

32 players alive, 17 votes to lynch. You have approx 8 hours remaining.​

this wagon is rised as cw to red mafia, so everyone on it needs scrutiny, especially who changed the vote from scum to Ekko.

Not surprisingly, Neeko is there, and also is Phoenix.

 

[Nana]

Haha bad day to lie my friend

Vote Lynch Cooler

how dou know he is lying?

 

[Michelle]

Day 1 Vote Count 10

Ekko 4 - TAC, Cooler, Phoenix, hime, Neeko
Arp 3 - Soulkiller, Blue, KWEH
Pero 4 - Worst, Dofla, Wakanda, Michelle
Dofla 1 - Pero
Melkor 1 - Ratchet
Charlie 1 - Fuji
Blue 1 - Kagurashii
Wakanda 7 - RippedCal, Ultra, Arp, Melkor, Chevy, Broki, Tpein
Ratchet 1 - Ekko

32 players alive, 17 votes to lynch. You have approx 2 hours remaining.​

2 hours before Eod Wakanda's counter wagon started to grow bigger.
People with fluid voting pattern changed vote, I remember Wakanda claimed and everyone looked back at Pero more than at Arp because of the claim.
I see Ekko's wagon was frozen.

Inactivity at Eod is one of the worst moments of inactivity in mafia because if town is not there to catch the feeling of the thread then mafia can do whatever they like. I think people who pushed for Pero back then were not red mafia but not all townies because other scum faction/s need to townside and show they are active scum hunting.

 

[Ratchet]

this wagon is rised as cw to red mafia, so everyone on it needs scrutiny, especially who changed the vote from scum to Ekko.

Not surprisingly, Neeko is there, and also is Phoenix.

Good post.

 

[T-Pein™]

2 hours before Eod Wakanda's counter wagon started to grow bigger.
People with fluid voting pattern changed vote, I remember Wakanda claimed and everyone looked back at Pero more than at Arp because of the claim.
I see Ekko's wagon was frozen.

Inactivity at Eod is one of the worst moments of inactivity in mafia because if town is not there to catch the feeling of the thread then mafia can do whatever they like. I think people who pushed for Pero back then were not red mafia but not all townies because other scum faction/s need to townside and show they are active scum hunting.

Who started this wakanda wagon?
I think it was ultra?

 

[WakandaForever]

2 hours before Eod Wakanda's counter wagon started to grow bigger.
People with fluid voting pattern changed vote, I remember Wakanda claimed and everyone looked back at Pero more than at Arp because of the claim.
I see Ekko's wagon was frozen.

Inactivity at Eod is one of the worst moments of inactivity in mafia because if town is not there to catch the feeling of the thread then mafia can do whatever they like. I think people who pushed for Pero back then were not red mafia but not all townies because other scum faction/s need to townside and show they are active scum hunting.

This reminded me that Melkor and Pero both panicked massively when they were linked together in thread on D1. I think Melkor's slot is worth investigating further.

 

[T-Pein™]

Wakanda is scummier

Yeh he was the one trying to counter wagon

 

[Michelle]

Day 1 Vote Count 12

Ekko 4 - TAC, Cooler, Phoenix, hime, Neeko
Arp 2 - Soulkiller, Blue
Pero 16 - Worst, Dofla, Wakanda, Michelle, RippedCal, Kweh, Chevy, Charlie, Ekko, Ratchet, Tpein, Tyler Herro, Arp, YTW, Broki, Kagurashii
Dofla 1 - Pero
Charlie 1 - Fuji
Wakanda 2 - Ultra, Melkor

32 players alive, 17 votes to lynch. You have 6 minutes remaining (EOD is 17:12 British Summer Time)​

without the Arp vote on Pero I would think the last votes, the bolded, are never aligned, and Idk how to take it... but maybe in scumchat there was a permission to bus for Arp to save him in case Pero flips?
Is hard to obtain a certain read from this VC unfortunately

Good post.

Join me, Ratchet sama!

 

[WakandaForever]

I wouldn't be surprised at all of Melkor and Arp are both red given the order of my wagon - waited for a few people to start voting as they didn't want to be the first and then piled on. They possibly could have also said in their QT that they should get involved in the wagon which is why they would have voted in a similar timeframe.