[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
No 24 hour days are not better. We have majority lynch lol, we can end the day whenever. If you want to wrap it up let's get some votes going and move on into night.

I've never understood the complaining. You are given the option to end the day when you want, and instead of doing so, you complain about the days being too long. Like do you need someone to tell you when you need to vote by to pick your lethargic arse off the ground and do something?
Agree, 24 hour phases are garbage.
 
Hmm, Why do you think he would be so forthright claiming abilities but not flavor?
0 clue

as town he just has to say his character (and it will probably be a towny character bc he has not claimed miller)
as scum he just has to pick a character out of the ones gram provided all the scum

makes no sense either way and i doubt he is an indy if he has no abilities

maybe hes unlynchable like how pero was unkillable but eh, i say take the chance now and not wait to vig in np bc if hes scum, his teammate could have a protective ability (i think its likely considering red scum teams wincon is to get voting majority and theres like only 6 of them in a 32 player game)
 
@Michelle



@bold pings me the most.


She definitely were against both the lynches.

This part and her few posts arround Pero at times gave me vibes she might not be alligned with him, but I've been wrong last game overthinking like that.

When Broki questioned what should be her vig targets she name these three and also agree with vigging Zolo in next post. She's clearly naming the ones that had the lowest post count aka inactivity.

But here she defends Cooler when sussed based on activity. If she believes Cooler inactivity is not sus why suggest vigging him off at all.

She do says so but it is all talks.

I don't remember she mentioned or talked about me, or tagged me,, asked reads at all before suggesting vigging me off.

There's also something off about the way she write some posts.

Anyhow i really don't think Town Kaguu would suggest vigging me off without interacting with me. Doing that to player she don't personally know add up but townie Kagu would try to figure me out, do some efforts to solve me anyhow.
I think she mentioned me again in her reads last day phase based on low inactivity despite my love for GOT flavour but no question on game stuff or reads at all. I'd definitely want her checked out.
@SoulKiller
 
I'm not on board with this building Neeko case btw, I still think he's town. While he voted Arp early and later found a reason to unvote, I maintain that he probably wouldn't want to bus a new player at the first opportunity - he'd do it to an experienced player, but not a newbie. Also his reasons for backing off of Arp looked genuine to me.
You need to look at it from the perspective that the dude had TMI all along. You can't just assume people would do certain actions cause you know them, from the looks of it he did not ever seem to wanna commit to arp wagon and just did it for reasons. His explanation for backing off arp before the dude even claimed were weird and made little sense. He knew arp had a strong fake claim and people would back off of it. What he miscalculated is that arp would get investigated.
 
Checking Ultra's entrance, posting it for reading it on pc (phone posting is hard)
About 10 pages in.

Early impression is that Chevy comes off as fairly scummy. It feels like he defended Cal rather positionally and made up his reasoning for doing so ad-hoc. Because basically his push on Neeko was that Cal had done nothing to earn critique, but Cal himself basically said "yeah I've done nothing so far it's 3 pages into the game lol".
A couple of things I dislike here:

The first is that you're not owning up to what was very obviously a push from you on Neeko. A push is neither inherently a good or a bad thing. But it's very obvious that is what you're doing and now you're pretending it wasn't.

Secondly, pointing out that Charles named you as the pushier one, or didn't name both of you pusy or w/e feels like you're latching onto something. Not sure what the implication is there or why I should care.

And honestly I'd say it's an accurate characterization that you were more pushy than Neeko who asked a cheeky little question to Cal vs you coming in with a small case.

Which way exactly are you reading Neeko?
The progression of Neeko and Chevy on each other respectively seems unusual. In the sense that you don't often see two townies bickering and then seemingly writing each other off so quickly. Feeling more charitable towards Neeko though overall.
Agreeing with Ratchet D1? Scum SoulKiller confirmed. What an elusive specimen.
I'm back.

@DoflaMihawk

Didn't even say hi to your old mafia teacher? How cold.
Who's the unlucky victim
Lost the response I was typing up to this so I'll keep it brief.

Here is where you turned heel on Neeko:



He provided you with a reads list and by your own admission you didn't have an impression on anyone he stated but you awarded him town points for supplying it.

It feels touch and go and low effort, and it makes it harder for me to buy the explanation you were trying to figure him out rather than just trying to go for what you perceived as low hanging fruit. Because your interest in him shrunk almost immediately and then you went straight after Charlie for what I see as a fairly contrived reason as well.

As for Charlie, tbd, but I didn't find any issue with what he said, and I'll have an answer for that by the end of today or I'm doing something seriously wrong, because he's usually not a hard read. No offense Charles.

I still have it.
I must have got roleblocked.
If you have it, either your target or you were probabily jailkept, and that may be another town protection

I like being queen! :catsure:


Not really i haven't been keeping tabs on others
I am still going slowly 🐌 but If i have to pick someone sus, ratchet comes to my mind. I just find myself not agreeing with him
Please give me details here
He oughta know that at the very best he'll be confirmed non-Lannister which probably doesn't mean all too much especially if you consider the purples hostile.
I see some speculations about purples, Chevy's role helps us to figure anything?
Very helpful townie attitude 🙄


Oh wow. I don't think purples are pro town still i find myself relating with kweh
You shouldn't criticize me when you don't go and check yourself.
Mafia is a game of teamwork, but you take this teamwork wrong, you want me to do the work while you just wait?

Do you imply Kweh is purple? How do you know?
I'll prolly answer this once im on computer

u urself so far pending between lean town and null, i have to check ur reasoning for placed votes then i might give a more clear answer
Ok, i will wait for your answer
Imagine Purple was 'win with town' until they are whittled down to a certain number, at which point they become a small second mafia faction.

Don't think Grammaton would do that as it'd be unnecessary RNG that would punish town for getting rid of non-towns and I don't see him liking that. But it would be an interesting mechanic.
this isn't bastard though?
I'm sorry but no
I thought I would be more active but things came up and, well, I wasn't
I am sorry you can't give me any reason to town read you :(
 
Checking Ultra's entrance, posting it for reading it on pc (phone posting is hard)


If you have it, either your target or you were probabily jailkept, and that may be another town protection


Please give me details here

I see some speculations about purples, Chevy's role helps us to figure anything?

You shouldn't criticize me when you don't go and check yourself.
Mafia is a game of teamwork, but you take this teamwork wrong, you want me to do the work while you just wait?

Do you imply Kweh is purple? How do you know?

Ok, i will wait for your answer

this isn't bastard though?

I am sorry you can't give me any reason to town read you :(
Ultra gets bad points from me cuz made counterwagon.
He also didn't say much of the red members
 

Pot Goblin

Conejo Blanco
Checking Ultra's entrance, posting it for reading it on pc (phone posting is hard)


If you have it, either your target or you were probabily jailkept, and that may be another town protection


Please give me details here

I see some speculations about purples, Chevy's role helps us to figure anything?

You shouldn't criticize me when you don't go and check yourself.
Mafia is a game of teamwork, but you take this teamwork wrong, you want me to do the work while you just wait?

Do you imply Kweh is purple? How do you know?

Ok, i will wait for your answer

this isn't bastard though?

I am sorry you can't give me any reason to town read you :(
About purple @SoulKiller I gave my case on them here.
Reread the WU for Grey Worm, there's a line about Dany getting angry about her companion's death. Flavorwise the reason she turns evil in the show is that her friends died, most of her dragons died, and she lost her claim to the throne because of Jon Snow.
I went into more detail here.





Less harmless than red since they have no communication with each other. And read back again on Grey Worm's WU and compare it to a red. Think of why the wincon would be unclear compared to how Red has the classic "Get the voting majority" wincon. So it's an unclear wincon with a character that has a trigger point where she turns evil. That's where I get the implication it goes both ways.

Yes, we should always be cautious when it comes to non-town factions. I'm just saying that we need to tread lightly with it and not jump the gun on them yet.
:handsup:
 

Kagu Nyan

✨✨✨Hibernation mode on 🎵 ✨✨✨
I can’t live like this where I’m seen scummy no matter what I do. I also can’t make wallies to justify myself so be it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top