General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Honestly after the last chapter, saying Yamato won’t join and 🥕 chances are better is plain delusional. The way Yamato looked at Luffy, how she is there to stop the fight to continue and isn’t with Momo at the Captial. Shows where she belongs. With the Strawhats.
Carrot isn’t even in the chapter although Nekomamushi was, and she is with him. Yet she wasn’t shown. That’s screams unimportant character and right there.
I guess Carrot stans haven’t had enough copium yet.
Carrot isn’t even in the chapter although Nekomamushi was, and she is with him. Yet she wasn’t shown. That’s screams unimportant character and right there.
I guess Carrot stans haven’t had enough copium yet.
B
Honestly after the last chapter, saying Yamato won’t join and 🥕 chances are better is plain delusional. The way Yamato looked at Luffy, how she is there to stop the fight to continue and isn’t with Momo at the Captial. Shows where she belongs. With the Strawhats.
Carrot isn’t even in the chapter although Nekomamushi was, and she is with him. Yet she wasn’t shown. That’s screams unimportant character and right there.
I guess Carrot stans haven’t had enough copium yet.
Carrot isn’t even in the chapter although Nekomamushi was, and she is with him. Yet she wasn’t shown. That’s screams unimportant character and right there.
I guess Carrot stans haven’t had enough copium yet.
The reason why so much time was spent on Carrot in WCI was so that she could be a fun character for the crew to bounce off of in place of all the other Strawhats. She was a placeholder character, and she faded from relevance once the rest of the crew popped back in
You're overcomplicating things dude
To be fair she just called Momo 'Our General' so take that as you will
You're overcomplicating things dude
Post automatically merged:
Honestly after the last chapter, saying Yamato won’t join and 🥕 chances are better is plain delusional. The way Yamato looked at Luffy, how she is there to stop the fight to continue and isn’t with Momo at the Captial. Shows where she belongs. With the Strawhats.
Carrot isn’t even in the chapter although Nekomamushi was, and she is with him. Yet she wasn’t shown. That’s screams unimportant character and right there.
I guess Carrot stans haven’t had enough copium yet.
Carrot isn’t even in the chapter although Nekomamushi was, and she is with him. Yet she wasn’t shown. That’s screams unimportant character and right there.
I guess Carrot stans haven’t had enough copium yet.
It's not a theory, it's a theme, it's Oda writing Yamato AS a parent for Momo to enhance the theme of the parent/child relationship in the arc. Nothing complicated.. That's called Milking mate. Sigh..
From everything we have seen from their relationship, if you can't figure that out, I guess there is no helping you.
Yeah it's not about Pedro, again you are completely missreading the character arc of Carrot, it's about the danger of the sea . And the trauma won't heal wether she hugs neko or not, it's not healed mate.
Yes there is. Her own characterisation and development inertia. If you still don't understand what it is, go read that page: Here
In short, carrot has been characterized as someone loving the sea and getting out of her environment by herself to experience what she loves, so to come back, she will need a major force or she will do it AGAIN and AGAIN and AGAIN and AGAIN. Just coming back wouldn't make ANY SENCE on a narrative basis. It's a narrative NECESSITY mate, nothing you can do about it.
Wrong, it's not. If that was the case, Oda wouldv pointed that out while defeating perospero, he did not.
Again, The arc of Carrot is about her OWN journey and the appreciation of HERSELF, it's not about the trauma.
That's because you have a very poor creativity. There is a LOT of storyline that Oda could told us about Carrot. So... Wrong again.
Proving her self worth, and enjoying the wonders of the world.
Here you go, you have here a better reason than Yamato.
Its irrelevant, you are still reasonning like a simple fan, the backstory is not relevant in the case of Carrot.
And it changed her life forever, so trust me that she will keep doing that.
Technically, Carrot was not free, the mink are hunted down just like the fishmen. Zu is therefore the Mink's prison at least symbolically.
Fallacious, her reasons comes later.
Too bad it was following a subversion dialogue. You still don't understand what it is ? Ahhh.. too bad..
The same mangaka that made the whole fanbase think the Minks had no idea where Raizo was. Or the same mangaka that shocked almost everyone by introducing time travel. Or the same mangakeconnected too story lines Laboon and Brook with an intervalle of 200 chapters or connected the Smile fruit with the smile of people... and hundreds more revelations and trickeries...
But yeah "One Piece isn't that deep"
.... until it is.
Ignorance is conforting, I get that. But sometime, it's actually better to face our own bias.
Well that's the point.
Yamato who was stuck on that little island most probably don't care about your maps. She was stuck on a skull forced to watch her father be a bully. So yeah.. Wano would be freedom to her.
I agree, that why I think Yamato will be the only retainer of Momo and the 9 red scabbard will become Daymo
No one said that
A fun character doesn't need to be on a post on the Sunny, A fun character doesn't need to have an entire chapter dedicated to them, a fun character doesn't need to be characterized like a strawhat WITH the strawhats. A fun character is like Chimney, it usually stays on the side, but it doesn't become major in One Piece. Being just a fun character doesn't explain all the mythos and treatment Carrot had, only something narratively stronger can. The placeholder hypothesis doesn't make sence easier, having less strawhat make the story more efficient, not the opposite, so adding a difficulty for no reason doesn't make ANY sence.
From everything we have seen from their relationship, if you can't figure that out, I guess there is no helping you.
Yeah it's not about Pedro, again you are completely missreading the character arc of Carrot, it's about the danger of the sea . And the trauma won't heal wether she hugs neko or not, it's not healed mate.
Yes there is. Her own characterisation and development inertia. If you still don't understand what it is, go read that page: Here
In short, carrot has been characterized as someone loving the sea and getting out of her environment by herself to experience what she loves, so to come back, she will need a major force or she will do it AGAIN and AGAIN and AGAIN and AGAIN. Just coming back wouldn't make ANY SENCE on a narrative basis. It's a narrative NECESSITY mate, nothing you can do about it.
Wrong, it's not. If that was the case, Oda wouldv pointed that out while defeating perospero, he did not.
Again, The arc of Carrot is about her OWN journey and the appreciation of HERSELF, it's not about the trauma.
That's because you have a very poor creativity. There is a LOT of storyline that Oda could told us about Carrot. So... Wrong again.
Proving her self worth, and enjoying the wonders of the world.
Here you go, you have here a better reason than Yamato.
Its irrelevant, you are still reasonning like a simple fan, the backstory is not relevant in the case of Carrot.
And it changed her life forever, so trust me that she will keep doing that.
Technically, Carrot was not free, the mink are hunted down just like the fishmen. Zu is therefore the Mink's prison at least symbolically.
Fallacious, her reasons comes later.
Too bad it was following a subversion dialogue. You still don't understand what it is ? Ahhh.. too bad..
The same mangaka that made the whole fanbase think the Minks had no idea where Raizo was. Or the same mangaka that shocked almost everyone by introducing time travel. Or the same mangakeconnected too story lines Laboon and Brook with an intervalle of 200 chapters or connected the Smile fruit with the smile of people... and hundreds more revelations and trickeries...
But yeah "One Piece isn't that deep"
.... until it is.
Ignorance is conforting, I get that. But sometime, it's actually better to face our own bias.
Well that's the point.
Yamato who was stuck on that little island most probably don't care about your maps. She was stuck on a skull forced to watch her father be a bully. So yeah.. Wano would be freedom to her.
I agree, that why I think Yamato will be the only retainer of Momo and the 9 red scabbard will become Daymo
No one said that
A fun character doesn't need to be on a post on the Sunny, A fun character doesn't need to have an entire chapter dedicated to them, a fun character doesn't need to be characterized like a strawhat WITH the strawhats. A fun character is like Chimney, it usually stays on the side, but it doesn't become major in One Piece. Being just a fun character doesn't explain all the mythos and treatment Carrot had, only something narratively stronger can. The placeholder hypothesis doesn't make sence easier, having less strawhat make the story more efficient, not the opposite, so adding a difficulty for no reason doesn't make ANY sence.
Characters like Chopper can have gags with OTHER character of the crew, having Carrot here is not a necessity. The gags on the beginning off whole cake are with Luffy, not Carrot.
There is NO NEED for a place holder, it doesn't make sence on a narrative basis. A character must serve a strong purpose or it has no reason to be here. Carrot is an anomaly on that front.
There is NO NEED for a place holder, it doesn't make sence on a narrative basis. A character must serve a strong purpose or it has no reason to be here. Carrot is an anomaly on that front.
- Status