Questions & Mysteries Why do you just assume Sanji defeated Page One?

Is the Anime Reliable?

  • Total voters
    116
Zenos7

Zenos7

‎
#161
#161
Chrono said:
If Sanji didnt dispose of P1 then im sorry but I cant see him being this...."normal" the next chapter.




Sanji would be nervous of what P1 would do and Law would be sweating bullets since Sanji didnt take him out.

If Drake took out P1 for Sanji and Sanji saw this. It would make no sense for them to then again fight in the Yasu funeral.

The only logical conclusion is Sanji defeated or badly injured P1. As theirs no way that Sanji and Law would be so neutral if that never happened. Nor would Drake and Sanji be enemies if Drake took him out.
Click to expand...
sanji wouldnt know about drakes motivations in any way though.
 
Zenos7

Zenos7

‎
#162
#162
Chrono said:
Either way its way more powerful than the concasse he did on Luffy.
Click to expand...
not necessarily, because as you pointed out in your thread (iirc), concasse adds alot of momentum because of the spin. Height + spin creates alot of force with concasse, if sanji performed another attack (not very likely though IMO), it might not be as strong as the concasse he performed on luffy.
 
Kejon

Kejon

‎
#163
#163
Zenos7 said:
No thanks, the anime is messy garbage and absolutely irrelevant when it comes to discussing the canon manga.
Click to expand...
You're trying way too hard. The anime is canon too. Oda tells them what to add that he couldn't show in the manga. The anime knew Kyoshiro is Denjiro and has shown us the conlusion of the Page One vs. Sanji fight. Sanji ran away.
 
Chrono

Chrono

‎
#167
#167
Zenos7 said:
sanji wouldnt know about drakes motivations in any way though.
Click to expand...
If Drake took out P1. Then Sanji would have no reason to fight him later. Drake sneak attacked Sanji and tried to kill him. It makes no sense for Drake to do this if hes working with Sanji and took out P1.

Drake couldnt have possibily taken out P1 without Sanji seeing it. Because if Sanji didnt see P1 down, then he and Law wouldnt be so "normal" the next chapter. If he did see P1 taken out by Drake, then they would have no reason to fighr later.

Theres literal no other possibility other than Sanji being the cause of P1's dissaparence.
 
Chrono

Chrono

‎
#168
#168
Zenos7 said:
not necessarily, because as you pointed out in your thread (iirc), concasse adds alot of momentum because of the spin. Height + spin creates alot of force with concasse, if sanji performed another attack (not very likely though IMO), it might not be as strong as the concasse he performed on luffy.
Click to expand...
But Sanji has the boosters which increase his momentum. He doesnt need to spin anymore anyways.
 
Zenos7

Zenos7

‎
#169
#169
Chrono said:
If Drake took out P1. Then Sanji would have no reason to fight him later. Drake sneak attacked Sanji and tried to kill him. It makes no sense for Drake to do this if hes working with Sanji and took out P1.

Drake couldnt have possibily taken out P1 without Sanji seeing it. Because if Sanji didnt see P1 down, then he and Law wouldnt be so "normal" the next chapter. If he did see P1 taken out by Drake, then they would have no reason to fighr later.

Theres literal no other possibility other than Sanji being the cause of P1's dissaparence.
Click to expand...
i didnt say that drake "worked with sanji" though.
 
J

Jo_Ndule

#170
#170
"Drake defeats p1" in Sanji presence
But drake still goes attacking sanji lol Sanji would talk to others about drake actions if it was true
Sanji will spill the beans if Drake tried stopping him.
If citizens saw Drake actions then Drake has to silent those citizens too.

P1 is irrelevant, hypetool for RS sanji.
He can comeback at fire festival or whatever but he's just a punching bag for Sanji.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Kejon

Kejon

‎
#171
#171
Zenos7 said:
Any positive evidence for the claim that oda tells them what to add in the anime?

I'll wait.
Click to expand...
Of course he tells them what to add, isn't it obvious? The anime can't just simply add nonsense to the story, it actually has to make sense. Also, as I have mentioned already, the anime knew Kyoshiro is Denjiro.
 
Zenos7

Zenos7

‎
#173
#173
Chrono said:
But Sanji has the boosters which increase his momentum. He doesnt need to spin anymore anyways.
Click to expand...
Good point :cheers:

Kejon said:
Of course he tells them what to add, isn't it obvious? The anime can't just simply add nonsense to the story, it actually has to make sense. Also, as I have mentioned already, the anime knew Kyoshiro is Denjiro.
Click to expand...
So im taking this as you not having any evidence for your claim?!
 
kurwa

kurwa

‎
#177
#177
Kejon said:
Of course he tells them what to add, isn't it obvious? The anime can't just simply add nonsense to the story, it actually has to make sense. Also, as I have mentioned already, the anime knew Kyoshiro is Denjiro.
Click to expand...
I can literally prove it to you that they don't care about canon by showing you multiple pages missing in this episodes, done in wrong order or even changed.

That alone proves they don't adapt manga 1:1 and then add filler
they add filer instead of canon
 
Kejon

Kejon

‎
#178
#178
Hurley Pirates said:
So he wouldnt get seen by Drake and Hawkins.. I thought that was implied lol

Yall can all argue all yall want, I saw Sanji whoop Page 1's ass on panel and in anime. Didnt see him KO him which woulda been nice but PG1 still got his ass whopped lol
Click to expand...
Page One stood up like nothing happened lol. He is just a tank, Sanji was more annoying than dangerous.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top