Status
Not open for further replies.
in the nicest possible way, do you think I’m unaware of potential risks? I’ve been playing a pretty long time now I’ll just point out
And in an even nicer way, I'll ask If you are aware of the risk why take them? Noone has to announce themselves before they send in a kill.

I was hoping to have stupid pointless conversations about it, was a massive success
Ah so you announcing the gun was pointless good to know. Can't really see how that would be helpful in any way, but hey you've been at this much longer ^.^
 
And in an even nicer way, I'll ask If you are aware of the risk why take them? Noone has to announce themselves before they send in a kill.



Ah so you announcing the gun was pointless good to know. Can't really see how that would be helpful in any way, but hey you've been at this much longer ^.^
I hope you got more out of this conversation than I did
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
im not insulting you, I’m saying your logic is bad, which it is. If you are incapable of separating yourself from that, that’s a you issue.
"The term "stupid" is, on some level, invective. You also haven't actually established that said logic is bad, you've simply dismissed it. I can understand not wanting to get into a drawn-out argument with a player you know isn't Town, but then you can simply disengage, it does not and should not stop me from playing."​
Im perfectly happy for scum to know who I am and what I can do, because they can’t do anything about it. Therefore drawing hostile actions is a net positive, and if they now target someone else, we’ll that’s a win to me too as it thins PoE for me.
"I think this is fairly short-sighted, as the idea that you'd be an ummoveable wall in the way of scum is difficult to believe. I can attribute this to posturing, to make scum think twice about targetting you, but then we come to another issue. That being the example you set. Let's say, for the sake of argument, that you are correct, and you have no reason to fear scum knowing your character. For starters, just because you can reveal and flaunt something, doesn't mean that you should. And more importantly, you set a poor example and risk other players following in said example, and they may not have said assurances that you do. This, of course, wouldn't be entirely on you, but then it begs the question - why? This is the issue with bluster like this - nothing I've said here is something that Scum haven't thought about themselves, and generally-speaking unless you're looking for a quick exit from this game, you're going to have your work cut out for you in playing this angle correctly."​
Besides, no one gives an iota what you think is optimal or not, stick to collecting mcmuffins. Before you reply, just remember only one of us is privy to my role sheet, and it isn’t you.
"Your "gotcha" is neither as funny nor witty as you may think it is. It's a game I signed up to play, you don't really get to police how I play it. You can disagree with what I say, and voice said disagreements, but telling me to shut up and stop posting because you think you speak for everyone is, at the very least, an unpleasant trait. You are correct - I cannot speak for your role. Well, it's possible that I've received it by way of investigation, but let's leave that aside for now. That means I can only work under knowledge I have access to, which is what I am doing. If it turns out that in this specific way, with this specific role, this angle happened to be optimal, then that's great. But you understand, I cannot just assume players are infallible, nor can I ignore behaviour that I feel warrants mention. That's how any level of deduction works."​
 

Peroroncino

🅷🅰🅻🅰 🅼🅰🅳🆁🅸🅳
There are 8 mafia members and 4 indies, right? There are 32 people in the game. You're acting as if only scum was here. In my opinion you should just say it. Maybe Ask Fuji if you can and if it's TC related, but thats it
fuji didnt say i couldnt reveal it so fuck it, it says i have been promoted to 2nd in command of the town core.
 
So I've only read the first 113 post so far (because I fell asleep on my laptop, and only just woke because I kicked a cereal bowl off the bed XD), but these are my reads on that.

@MangoSenpai strikes me as some sort of Jester role.

I go back and forth on @Ekkologix. Initially I thought he was town, I disagree with @Ratchet that his entrance into the game was scummy, but then his statements at post #93 about some boy v girl game he had to finish, which came out of the blue in the convo looked rather odd and #97 where he's role fishing from Ratchet also gave me the slight impression that he's worried about it, and who would be worried about it? Killers. And who are likely to be killers? Scum. However, I say go back and forth because I also thought his post at #96 and #106 looked especially townie.

I think @Dr_Professor83 is town

I thought Ratchet was indie and he later said as much

@Yo Tan Wa strike me as scum according to my notes, but I didn't write down why so imma iso then after I catch up and come back with an explanation.

@Kagurashii gave me scummy vibes because their entrance at #104 and the subsequent post at #110 look a little tooooooooooooo fluffy, but idk this poster and idk if it's just their personality.

@Ultra is town. ._. Don't fight me on this. Granted I haven't played with him in forever, but this is his town meta if I ever saw it.
 

"The term "stupid" is, on some level, invective. You also haven't actually established that said logic is bad, you've simply dismissed it. I can understand not wanting to get into a drawn-out argument with a player you know isn't Town, but then you can simply disengage, it does not and should not stop me from playing."​

"I think this is fairly short-sighted, as the idea that you'd be an ummoveable wall in the way of scum is difficult to believe. I can attribute this to posturing, to make scum think twice about targetting you, but then we come to another issue. That being the example you set. Let's say, for the sake of argument, that you are correct, and you have no reason to fear scum knowing your character. For starters, just because you can reveal and flaunt something, doesn't mean that you should. And more importantly, you set a poor example and risk other players following in said example, and they may not have said assurances that you do. This, of course, wouldn't be entirely on you, but then it begs the question - why? This is the issue with bluster like this - nothing I've said here is something that Scum haven't thought about themselves, and generally-speaking unless you're looking for a quick exit from this game, you're going to have your work cut out for you in playing this angle correctly."​

"Your "gotcha" is neither as funny nor witty as you may think it is. It's a game I signed up to play, you don't really get to police how I play it. You can disagree with what I say, and voice said disagreements, but telling me to shut up and stop posting because you think you speak for everyone is, at the very least, an unpleasant trait. You are correct - I cannot speak for your role. Well, it's possible that I've received it by way of investigation, but let's leave that aside for now. That means I can only work under knowledge I have access to, which is what I am doing. If it turns out that in this specific way, with this specific role, this angle happened to be optimal, then that's great. But you understand, I cannot just assume players are infallible, nor can I ignore behaviour that I feel warrants mention. That's how any level of deduction works."​
And similarly, you don’t get to police how I play either. Setting an example for other players isn’t even remotely a concern for me, and me telling you to stick to collecting McMuffins is a reference to the fact that your goals and my goals do not align, much as they don’t between you and any other player on the game, except probably Blue who you will likely mutually collude with outside the intention of your roles, which you’ve already effectively confirmed you will do.

if you want to interpret actual attacks from my posts, that’s on you, but there isn’t any element of that from my perspective.

My intention is very clear, I’m doing things that will make the game easier for me in the long run. If I’m dead because of it, we’ll that’s a risk I’m ok with taking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top