Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1052 Spoilers Discussion

[dirtyLarry]

Also drawing a fanservice gag bath scene just after that reveal, in the same chapter
Am I the only one finding the tone extremely jarring?

You are 100% correct, but gotta be honest: After all that bs writing recently I don't complain about some Yamato melons, even if it's inappropriate ...

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Yh it’s jarring because he thinks adding a light hearted gag moment before things get serious again adds something to the story but the tone has been such a mess the whole arc it doesn’t do anything

It reminds me of the tone that keeps switching during Kaido fight. One chapter Luffy is having fun with his buddy, another one he wants to smash s his teeth in

 

[Ar1sE1998]

Oh crap i got a Katakuri tag
Can any mod derank me or delete half of my posts so people won't know i have no life

My tag is better than yours
Mine have AdvCoC

 

[BangOO🍅]

@zzShinichi @Hanzo hattori @MonsterKaido @Jailer Q & A

 

[mly90]

Also drawing a fanservice gag bath scene just after that reveal, in the same chapter
Am I the only one finding the tone extremely jarring?

Oda's editors let him down they greenlit everything he does

 

[theonlydoffymingo]

i hope yamato will be in film red

 

[Sentinel]

Oh crap i got a Katakuri tag
Can any mod derank me or delete half of my posts so people won't know i have no life

No Kata slander.

 

[dirtyLarry]

It reminds me of the tone that keeps switching during Kaido fight. One chapter Luffy is having fun with his buddy, another one he wants to smash s his teeth in

That was another thing that threw me off: Luffy wasn't even REALLY serious while fighting Kaido.

It felt like a friendly between two rivals that respect each other, not like a deathmatch to actually liberate an entire country from slavery.

Kaido and Luffy were literally grinning and complementing each other for half the fight.

Compare that to all the other major fights in the past, where Luffy went dead serious and had that death stare on.

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

People always excuse Oda fake out claiming killing off a character just for "shock value" does not make a story good.
Well, this is exactly what he did with Izo and Ashura. No emotion, no impact. Just shock value

 

[mly90]

No Kata slander.

Kata's tag will be the reason many users will rather become vip

 

[Sentinel]

Kata's tag will be the reason many users will rather become vip

@HAJIKING take him to your dungeon please!

 

[OnePiss]

People always excuse Oda fake out claiming killing off a character just for "shock value" does not make a story good.
Well, this is exactly what he did with Izo and Ashura. No emotion, no impact. Just shock value

I saw some people saying these deaths means Oda has beaten the No killing anyone allegations. You just have to laugh at this point Lmfao. It’s so obvious that he still doesn’t why do these Oda Sexuals need to lie

 

[Gorosei Informer]

Yasuie didn't get a funeral either did he? Kanjuro disposed of his body too?

This scene is so fucked up...

Since Yasuie did apparently eat the Smile fruit then, he was smiling and laughing regardless?

I would have preferred to if he was faking it to give everyone hope even in his final moments, like how Luffy put a fake smile to Nami and co as Katakuri was thrashing him.

 

[Sentinel]

People always excuse Oda fake out claiming killing off a character just for "shock value" does not make a story good.
Well, this is exactly what he did with Izo and Ashura. No emotion, no impact. Just shock value

Some people used to tell "It's not bad that Oda off screened Jack vs Inu, Perospero vs Nekomamushi, OP isn't just a manga about battles anyway", now what's their excuse this time when Oda off screened Izo's and Ashura's death like that? That's not battle related, yet Oda decided to skip this important part of the plot. Izo and Ashura were important side characters throughout Wano, they're part of the Scabbards.

 

[Doggo]

I'm also slowly approaching that tag

I still got ways to go.

 

[Twin Milf]

Some people used to tell "It's not bad that Oda off screened Jack vs Inu, Perospero vs Nekomamushi, OP isn't just a manga about battles anyway", now what's their excuse this time when Oda off screened Izo's and Ashura's death like that? That's not battle related, yet Oda decided to skip this important part of the plot. Izo and Ashura were important side characters throughout Wano, they're part of the Scabbards.

Why do you keep saying he offscreened their deaths when we literally saw what happened to both them lol

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

I remember people saying Kinemon can't die because we would miss a beautiful reunion between him and Tsuru.
Turn out that 90% chance their reunion happened off screen considering a week has passed

 

[Sentinel]

I saw some people saying these deaths means Oda has beaten the No killing anyone allegations. You just have to laugh at this point Lmfao. It’s so obvious that he still doesn’t why do these Oda Sexuals need to lie

They are beyond help.

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Why do you keep saying he offscreened their deaths when we literally saw what happened to both them lol

A yes, Izo took a finger gun in a generic panel. Totally look like he took a killing blown and wasn't just knocked out like 99% of the characters in the series

 

[Sentinel]

Why do you keep saying he offscreened their deaths when we literally saw what happened to both them lol

Compare their deaths to Pedro's and you know what I mean. We saw how they got injured - and that's how they most likely died - but we didn't actually see the focus of them "dying" on panel. There's a huge difference.