[FNZ] Salem of Lies Throne of lies: The battle for the Throne

[Reborn]

This is a good question, but I believe I discussed this with Ekko earlier in the Day. I will be surprised if his answer differs from then.

I noticed that you and ekko had this discussion but I don't think ekko clearly addressed this


I will once again look into his posts

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

I very patently did, unless you can tell me the chances of success that come from asking a player who has clearly read the Observer role about details that can be gleaned from... reading the observer role. And you probably should care, because you're one of the next players up to claim.

I literally just explained to you that even if a person reads a role it is possible to make a mistake, hence why I asked. Nah, I don't really care whether you care for it or not. Regarding the claiming, we'll see.

 

[Emil]

actually read the roles again

melkors claim doesnt explain why conq action would fail on me

 

[Ratchet]

I literally just explained to you that even if a person reads a role it is possible to make a mistake, hence why I asked. Nah, I don't really care whether you care for it or not. Regarding the claiming, we'll see.

We will, yes. What angle are we pursuing next, Light?

 

[Emil]

I noticed that you and ekko had this discussion but I don't think ekko clearly addressed this


I will once again look into his posts

its there
a bit lowkey
but thats intentional

why r u so after it bon bon

 

[Ratchet]

I'm not going to continue the "why did you ask this" discourse, because it ultimately comes down to whether one assumes incompetence or not. As I explained to Reborn earlier, I strive for perfection, and that intrinsically requires me to assume each and every player in the game is competent. It's not always the case, or even often, but there you go.

 

[Emil]

@ConquistadoR can u whisper me what u did or tried to do that failed?

 

[Ratchet]

@ConquistadoR can u whisper me what u did or tried to do that failed?

Why are we dealing with this in whispers? I'm sure I don't need to demonstrate the key flaw in that approach, do I?

 

[Reborn]

From the sounds of it he's hostile, so may as well be Scum. Why did you think Indie in particular?

i dont think he is mafia

if hes hostile why did he claim indie rn out of the blue. or claim indie to whoever messaged him

Apathy, or win con too hard, mayhaps. Why do you think he's not Mafia? Note that your argument that he was Indie came before his claim. What did you use to get that read prior?

i dont think hes mafia.

not thread related

Ekko where you actually addressed it?


All you said is not thread related at the end.



First I doubt any result will clearly distinguish between unseen/cult or indie.

Even if you did get such result then you would be more confident about lanji being indie and calling him out

But you weren't which is clear from these posts from yours

lanji could be an indie

well at least my read on lanji was right

 

[Emil]

Why are we dealing with this in whispers? I'm sure I don't need to demonstrate the key flaw in that approach, do I?

why not
he said he town read me so cant be harmful
ill be able to decide if it needs to be mass claimed or not

melkors whisper doesnt add up with conq action failing on me. there is another interference happening and id like to hear what conq has to say first

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

We will, yes. What angle are we pursuing next, Light?

My vote in on Rottkins at the moment.

 

[Emil]

Ekko where you actually addressed it?


All you said is not thread related at the end.



First I doubt any result will clearly distinguish between unseen/cult or indie.

Even if you did get such result then you would be more confident about lanji being indie and calling him out

But you weren't which is clear from these posts from yours

are u playing dumb reborn

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

actually read the roles again

melkors claim doesnt explain why conq action would fail on me

What did Melkor claim?

 

[Ratchet]

Ekko where you actually addressed it?


All you said is not thread related at the end.



First I doubt any result will clearly distinguish between unseen/cult or indie.

Even if you did get such result then you would be more confident about lanji being indie and calling him out

But you weren't which is clear from these posts from yours

He claims he has mechanical information to suggest Lanji is not Mafia.

 

[Reborn]

are u playing dumb reborn

Nvm


I got it

 

[Emil]

What did Melkor claim?

i dont think he wants to reveal it

 

[Emil]

He claims he has mechanical information to suggest Lanji is not Mafia.

shud wait for him to figure it out himself

 

[Ratchet]

shud wait for him to figure it out himself

Pointless.

 

[Ratchet]

i dont think he wants to reveal it

You're making it impossible to co-operate, just fyi.

 

[Reborn]

He claims he has mechanical information to suggest Lanji is not Mafia.

Ya I got that

Had some other reason to ask him that question