Questions & Mysteries WTF is Yamato?

Is Yamato a man or a woman?

  • Man

    Votes: 15 11.8%
  • Woman

    Votes: 112 88.2%

  • Total voters
    127
Either Oda is transphobic and although I don't like the man I don't think he is, or she just inspires to Oden but does not have gender disphoria :cheers:

I pick the latter in all honesty
Or he wanted to make character like yamato and people are way to mixed up with woke/western gender bs that can't get pass something that basically is just a aspect of her character for oda.
 
Is this really something we really need multiple threads about this is just fucking dumb, yamato idolised oden so much she wanted to be the same gender that's all.
Ya, her main focus is to be Oden. Not a man or a woman, a specific man - Oden. Really gender has nothing to do with it, she’s not even aware of that nor cares lol

In a lot of ways she’s a dumbass like Luffy :milaugh:
 

Doggo

Welcome to the House of Hope
Why do we have such discussion in our modern world?

Yamato identifies as a man, so Yamato is a man. Where is the issue?
I've tried.
But Yamato's case just seems like a coping mechanism and childish fantasy she uses to deal with the trauma she had to endure.

Kiku's case doesn't feel, at all, similar to Yamato's.

The things she idolizes about Oden have nothing to do with the fact oden had a dick or a vagina. He was free, adventuring type, "badass", etc.
She doesn't need a cock or "be a man" to achieve any of that.
Maybe Oda's intent really is portraying Yamato as a trans man. But man, he does an amazing job at overcomplicating it then.
 

Pantheos

Heavy Metal
I've tried.
But Yamato's case just seems like a coping mechanism and childish fantasy she uses to deal with the trauma she had to endure.

Kiku's case doesn't feel, at all, similar to Yamato's.

The things she idolizes about Oden have nothing to do with the fact oden had a dick or a vagina. He was free, adventuring type, "badass", etc.
She doesn't need a cock or "be a man" to achieve any of that.
Maybe Oda's intent really is portraying Yamato as a trans man. But man, he does an amazing job at overcomplicating it then.
What exactly makes it complicated? Its not like Yamato relies on anything female at all, except for the body appearance, which Yamato doesnt seem to care about. And nobody else, except of the perverts, doesnt care too.
So where is the issue at just accepting Yamato being a man, since Yamato identifies as a man?
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Yamato - "Kozuki Oden was a man, right? So I became a man, too.”


Her identification as a man has nothing to do with gender but what and how Oden was.


Let's suppose oden was a woman then we would have seen Yamato saying "I became a woman".

Weird but Oda through her acts never intended to demonstrate that Yamato identifies herself as man but as Oden through and through. Oda intended to give picture of the degree of Yamato obsession in becoming like Oden.


Don't know why people even mixing these up to call yamato as a man when Oda himself in 2021 said "Yamato is a female" and her intro got changed from "Kaido's son" to "Kaido's daughter"


She is a female with full on obsession with Oden
 

Doggo

Welcome to the House of Hope
What exactly makes it complicated? Its not like Yamato relies on anything female at all, except for the body appearance, which Yamato doesnt seem to care about. And nobody else, except of the perverts, doesnt care too.
So where is the issue at just accepting Yamato being a man, since Yamato identifies as a man?
Kiku's vivre card at least had the care to write her gender as "female" (but man at heart).
Yamato's just say "female". Her epithet is "Oni princess", not "prince".
It's not a matter of just "body".
Yamato's playing "make believe" pretending she is someone else.
Even her last sentence on chapter 1056 is indicative of not being a case of transgender.
"I wanna live LIKE Kozuki Oden".

She wants to be like the guy, not "be a guy" herself.
 

Sir Tuna Sandwich II

SII - Sakazuki Incinerate Imu
Ya, her main focus is to be Oden. Not a man or a woman, a specific man - Oden. Really gender has nothing to do with it, she’s not even aware of that nor cares lol

In a lot of ways she’s a dumbass like Luffy :milaugh:
TAC alt nice try Fluffy has self-respect he won't try to steal someone name he'll forge his own legacy
Post automatically merged:

What exactly makes it complicated? Its not like Yamato relies on anything female at all, except for the body appearance, which Yamato doesnt seem to care about. And nobody else, except of the perverts, doesnt care too.
So where is the issue at just accepting Yamato being a man, since Yamato identifies as a man?
Men don't hide stuff in their boobs
 
Top