Break Week This Nonsensical Yonko Bounty Cope needs to stop
- Thread starter ShishioIsBack
- Start date
Blackbeard
Bounty Given: 2,247,600,000
1. Gained Might New Followers through his assault on impel down 2 years ago (aka crew means nothing)
2. Expanding his territory to fill the void of whitebeard (aka Territory means nothing)
Relevant bonus (not mentioned directly in panels discussing bounties)
- Was on whitebeards crew
- Beat WB remnants led by Marco
- Has 2 Devil fruits which is unique to only him
Ain't it pretty easy to identify what bounties actually mean combat abilities and threat to the government like marine hunting.
Bounty Given: 2,247,600,000
1. Gained Might New Followers through his assault on impel down 2 years ago (aka crew means nothing)
2. Expanding his territory to fill the void of whitebeard (aka Territory means nothing)
Relevant bonus (not mentioned directly in panels discussing bounties)
- Was on whitebeards crew
- Beat WB remnants led by Marco
- Has 2 Devil fruits which is unique to only him
Ain't it pretty easy to identify what bounties actually mean combat abilities and threat to the government like marine hunting.
Now, why do you think BB has half as much bounty as Shanks?
Ahhh yes ace definitely wasnt beaten by blackbeard and sent to impel down
Blackbeard Killed Thatch, i will give you whitebeard but they 100% did the most damage to whitebeard
Beat Bonney and her crew (this is the only somewhat fodder thing)
Blackbeard Pirates made the revos flee
Blackbeard Killed Thatch, i will give you whitebeard but they 100% did the most damage to whitebeard
Beat Bonney and her crew (this is the only somewhat fodder thing)
Blackbeard Pirates made the revos flee
And BB will probably get a raise regarding all the recent stuff soonish, I reckon.
You didn't answer question, though.
Ace YC1 
How isnt he + his novels shows the ace vs oldbeard feats to be closer then previously thought (ace novel is canon)
How tho Izou the 16th commander = tobiroppo
and yes the whitebeard pirates commanders are ranked by strength (Marco > Ace > Jozu > Vista) so we can assume thatch > vista
Lmao Kid and Law arent in the yonko realm and they have 3bil each
Clashes with Base Yamato on equal footing and draws Jinbe on land
WB commanders aren't ranked by strength as explicitly told by Oda in SBS Vol. 59
and yes the whitebeard pirates commanders are ranked by strength (Marco > Ace > Jozu > Vista) so we can assume thatch > vista
And that's why I said context matters.
Luffy, Law, Kidd all got same amount as an measure for defeating BM + Kaido collectively. However the fuck marines concluded that- we haven't seen them discuss the bounties of these three like others yet.
If you ignore context, nothing matters of course. Robin is so high even though she's not close to Sanji. Buggy is so high even though he's fodder. Etc.
Oda explicitly putting Mihawk at 3.6b for achieving nothing fantastic of sorts (like captain trio) nor being a leader and nor a Yonko on top of only merits explained being his strength and combat power in the same chapter where he says he doesn't give a fuck about becoming Emperor. If you think that isn't narratively Yonko level, nothing is.
WB commanders aren't ranked by strength as explicitly told by Oda in SBS Vol. 59
and yes the whitebeard pirates commanders are ranked by strength (Marco > Ace > Jozu > Vista) so we can assume thatch > vista
And that's why I said context matters.
Luffy, Law, Kidd all got same amount as an measure for defeating BM + Kaido collectively. However the fuck marines concluded that- we haven't seen them discuss the bounties of these three like others yet.
If you ignore context, nothing matters of course. Robin is so high even though she's not close to Sanji. Buggy is so high even though he's fodder. Etc.
Oda explicitly putting Mihawk at 3.6b for achieving nothing fantastic of sorts (like captain trio) nor being a leader and nor a Yonko on top of only merits explained being his strength and combat power in the same chapter where he says he doesn't give a fuck about becoming Emperor. If you think that isn't narratively Yonko level, nothing is.
"as for Buggy the Bombastic Clown, considering his formidable pedigree and the fact THAT HE GOT THESE TWO TO YIELD TO HIS AUTHORITY"
See the CAPSLOCK part?
It means the bounties are post Cross Guild formation. It also means that Mihawk's bounty is his bounty as a member of Cross Guild. Remember, being in a Yonko Crew can increase your bounty by default.
It's not his strength alone.
Now, if you wanna argue that "being in Cross Guild" is maybe responsible for the 90M, while the 3.5B remaining is purely for his strength, etc, well, good luck with that.
Blackbeard
Bounty Given: 2,247,600,000
1. Gained Might New Followers through his assault on impel down 2 years ago (aka crew means nothing)
2. Expanding his territory to fill the void of whitebeard (aka Territory means nothing)
Bonus (not mentioned directly in panels discussing bounties)
- Was on whitebeards crew
- Captured Ace
- Killed Thatch and Whitebeard
- Beat WB remnants led by Marco
- Beat Bonney and her crew
- Attacked Revolutionary Army (revos fled)
- Has 2 Devil fruits which is unique to only him
Ain't it pretty easy to identify what bounties actually mean combat abilities and threat to the government like marine hunting.
Bounty Given: 2,247,600,000
1. Gained Might New Followers through his assault on impel down 2 years ago (aka crew means nothing)
2. Expanding his territory to fill the void of whitebeard (aka Territory means nothing)
Bonus (not mentioned directly in panels discussing bounties)
- Was on whitebeards crew
- Captured Ace
- Killed Thatch and Whitebeard
- Beat WB remnants led by Marco
- Beat Bonney and her crew
- Attacked Revolutionary Army (revos fled)
- Has 2 Devil fruits which is unique to only him
Ain't it pretty easy to identify what bounties actually mean combat abilities and threat to the government like marine hunting.
2. Captured Ace with Crew
3.1. Killing Thatch, Marines would rather thank BB than increase his bounty
3.2. Kill-stealing WB*
4. Beat Marco-led WB Remnants with Crew
5. Beat Bonney and her crew with BB's Crew
6. Attacked Revolutionary Army Base with Crew
7. Has 2 of the most OP DF still given lower bounty than being WSS
You're countering yourself.
All you listed are mostly BB doing them with his Crew, meaning he wasn't given bounty as high as Shanks because his crew at the time wasn't as strong as Shanks' crew.
Also, that would backfire on you.
All that "combat abilities" and threat you're saying but only given 2.2B.
While Mihawk WSS alone = 3.6B.
Only thing is Marco > rest. Ace > Jozu > Vista is all your head-canon. SBS
And of course, the context matters for Mihawk's bounty. I admit he got inflation from Marine hunting. But the point of fact remains that he's someone in Yonko zone and only 400m behind Shanks despite not being leader of anything and having no crew under him. On top of that, Brannew only talked about his combat merits first and foremost.
Also being the only non-leader to ever surpass the bounty of not only its leader, but also a leader who is Yonko and stated to stand shoulder to shoulder with Shanks.
I'm looking a fuck-ton at the context of it. You're the one ignoring it just because it's not negative lol
"as for Buggy the Bombastic Clown, considering his formidable pedigree and the fact THAT HE GOT THESE TWO TO YIELD TO HIS AUTHORITY"
See the CAPSLOCK part?
It means the bounties are post Cross Guild formation. It also means that Mihawk's bounty is his bounty as a member of Cross Guild. Remember, being in a Yonko Crew can increase your bounty by default.
It's not his strength alone.
Now, if you wanna argue that "being in Cross Guild" is maybe responsible for the 90M, while the 3.5B remaining is purely for his strength, etc, well, good luck with that.
Almost no one reasonable is arguing that Mihawk's bounty is by strength alone. Everyone agrees he has his own inflation.
People are just arguing that it'd definitely have crossed 4b and such if he was the leader instead. And that Yonkos would definitely be a good bit lower, too, if they had no empire or crews to lead and were just part of it instead.
And of course, the context matters for Mihawk's bounty. I admit he got inflation from Marine hunting. But the point of fact remains that he's someone in Yonko zone and only 400m behind Shanks despite not being leader of anything and having no crew under him. On top of that, Brannew only talked about his combat merits first and foremost.
Also being the only non-leader to ever surpass the bounty of not only its leader, but also a leader who is Yonko and stated to stand shoulder to shoulder with Shanks.
I'm looking a fuck-ton at the context of it. You're the one ignoring it just because it's not negative lol
"as for Buggy the Bombastic Clown, considering his formidable pedigree and the fact THAT HE GOT THESE TWO TO YIELD TO HIS AUTHORITY"
See the CAPSLOCK part?
It means the bounties are post Cross Guild formation. It also means that Mihawk's bounty is his bounty as a member of Cross Guild. Remember, being in a Yonko Crew can increase your bounty by default.
It's not his strength alone.
Now, if you wanna argue that "being in Cross Guild" is maybe responsible for the 90M, while the 3.5B remaining is purely for his strength, etc, well, good luck with that.
People are just arguing that it'd definitely have crossed 4b and such if he was the leader instead. And that Yonkos would definitely be a good bit lower, too, if they had no empire or crews to lead and were just part of it instead.
This is pure fax
"as for Buggy the Bombastic Clown, considering his formidable pedigree and the fact THAT HE GOT THESE TWO TO YIELD TO HIS AUTHORITY"
See the CAPSLOCK part?
It means the bounties are post Cross Guild formation. It also means that Mihawk's bounty is his bounty as a member of Cross Guild. Remember, being in a Yonko Crew can increase your bounty by default.
It's not his strength alone.
Now, if you wanna argue that "being in Cross Guild" is maybe responsible for the 90M, while the 3.5B remaining is purely for his strength, etc, well, good luck with that.
That doesn't make sense
Cross Guild is only hyped because of mihawk
Buggy has 3 billion because of mihawk
And he is STILL LOWER THAN MIHAWK
Mihawk can't boost himself
Post automatically merged:
"as for Buggy the Bombastic Clown, considering his formidable pedigree and the fact THAT HE GOT THESE TWO TO YIELD TO HIS AUTHORITY"
See the CAPSLOCK part?
It means the bounties are post Cross Guild formation. It also means that Mihawk's bounty is his bounty as a member of Cross Guild. Remember, being in a Yonko Crew can increase your bounty by default.
It's not his strength alone.
Now, if you wanna argue that "being in Cross Guild" is maybe responsible for the 90M, while the 3.5B remaining is purely for his strength, etc, well, good luck with that.
Cross Guild is only hyped because of mihawk
Buggy has 3 billion because of mihawk
And he is STILL LOWER THAN MIHAWK
Mihawk can't boost himself
