General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[MonochromeYoru]

and even when we are presented the different factions of the Minks/straw hats/Samurai alliance she is represented with the straw hats

Keep spreading the good word and spitting facts brozer. The barreling day is getting closer and closer.

 

[evnsater]

Thata how I feel about most Wano conclusions
[automerge]1662152486[/automerge]

The difference is that the SHs are already that, SHs, they already had their own arcs and its somewhat ok for Oda to sideline them for 1 arc since there are others to come, but to sideline a character that is supposed to join right after it? That doesnt make sense imo, especially when Carrot lacks a LOT of characterization and development and Oda found it better to create a filler character like Yamato instead of giving Carrot all of that panel time
[automerge]1662152681[/automerge]

I get what you are saying, I'm just pointing out how this conclusion being lack luster isnt evidence that there is more to come, since a lot of stuff in Wano was like that, and how Carrot becoming Duchess is similar to Momo becoming Shogun in a lot of ways so its very possible that, in Oda's mind, that makes sense as a conclusion

at least everyone has a smile, now compare it to Carrot

WCI is a setup arc for Carrot. Not a resolution.
Carrot developpement -
Essentially Carrot has had quite a bit of subtle development since she first appeared on the Sunny. It often gets ignored but it is there. When we first see Carrot, she's naive and boisterous. She believes Pirating is an adventure and seemingly doesn't care about the consequences. Since then her mentor has died, she has been forced to face the reality that the life of a Pirate is serious and that she needs to grow up and accept that it comes with harsh realities.

 

[IIskandar1997]

and even when we are presented the different factions of the Minks/straw hats/Samurai alliance she is represented with the straw hats

 

[evnsater]

 

[Random_Kurozumi]

Wasn't Wanda there too?

 

[IIskandar1997]

at least everyone has a smile, now compare it to Carrot

WCI is a setup arc for Carrot. Not a resolution.
Carrot developpement -
Essentially Carrot has had quite a bit of subtle development since she first appeared on the Sunny. It often gets ignored but it is there. When we first see Carrot, she's naive and boisterous. She believes Pirating is an adventure and seemingly doesn't care about the consequences. Since then her mentor has died, she has been forced to face the reality that the life of a Pirate is serious and that she needs to grow up and accept that it comes with harsh realities.

Carrot at the beggining of WCI

Carrot a few hours after Pedro's death

I really cant see this development Carrot fans talk so much, she didnt change at all as far as see

 

[Little Cahokia]

Yeah this is why I think Carrot, Yamato (probably/most likely in Elbaf) and Vivi (Idk tbh) are the last members.

 

[evnsater]

Wasn't Wanda there too?

nah

 

[IIskandar1997]

Wasn't Wanda there too?

She was but that doesnt count because agenda

 

[Le Battre]

I don't remember seeing Wanda

 

[Little Cahokia]

Carrot at the beggining of WCI

Carrot a few hours after Pedro's death

I really cant see this development Carrot fans talk so much, she didnt change at all as far as see

I think their point is for scenes or moments that should just be for the Strawhats why is Carrot grouped with them like she is apart of the crew? I think this is point that's the point that is getting lost here.

 

[evnsater]

Carrot at the beggining of WCI

Carrot a few hours after Pedro's death

I really cant see this development Carrot fans talk so much, she didnt change at all as far as see

you are bad the first time we see her why she goes on the sunny? because she thinks it's an adventure and does not care about the consequences read chapter 823

 

[IIskandar1997]

I don't remember seeing Wanda

nah

 

[Little Cahokia]

I kinda addressed this...

 

[IIskandar1997]

you are bad the first time we see her why she goes on the sunny? because she thinks it's an adventure and does not care about the consequences read chapter 823

And how did that change?

she still treats dangerous situations as an adventure

 

[evnsater]

And how did that change?

she still treats dangerous situations as an adventure

 

[IIskandar1997]

How is crying over Pedro a change from seeing the sea as a wonderland? I just showed you how she still sees it the same way

 

[Random_Kurozumi]

I think their point is for scenes or moments that should just be for the Strawhats why is Carrot grouped with them like she is apart of the crew? I think this is point that's the point that is getting lost here.

But Carrot disappeared right before the big strawhat double spread inside Onigashima....

 

[evnsater]

How is crying over Pedro a change from seeing the sea as a wonderland? I just showed you how she still sees it the same way

athis why WCI was a set up arc for Carrot and not a resolution because her journey is not finished yet

 

[Little Cahokia]

But Carrot disappeared right before the big strawhat double spread inside Onigashima....

Yeah, why she would apart of it? She's not apart of the crew and we didn't iconic posing scene with Jinbei as an offical Strawhat at the time. (You can include Fishman but like I said Jinbei didn't join yet.)