I'm not expecting you to have much of a read, no (though I thought his engagement with the thread was shallow enough to warrent a genuine scum read). At he end of the day the only way we can play this is by playing the information game, this may all be valid but, again, surely you can see how your intervention could be perceived that way. I do not have much to work with X other than there is probably at least one scum between you and Charlie. If you don't want to claim, I cannot force you, but your abilities should be directed in either proving yourself town or condemning him.