[FNZ] Super Role Madness Waifu Wars: Requiem of Eternity
- Thread starter Mashiro Blue
- Start date
- Tags get those waifus miku best girl miku>nino nino>miku no love for itsuki no waifu no laifu noi is the only waifu for me shalltear ftw witches are best
- Status
.
So I can't turn around and say "I'd like to give strikes for this behaviour" even if it is, in my view, in the same tier of behaviour that I would seek strikes against. So the question becomes "how can I prevent this from being allowed again". It's a unique case because you rarely see it get co-signed off, but the best I have currently is
*Limit the scope of super role madness, such as the removal of wishes
*Make it a rule that the spirit of a role must be followed beyond just the letter
*Remove ambiguity with Indies, i.e. discard the concept of pro-town indies and anti-town indies
The problem with 2 is it becomes very vague and relies on the hosts to arbitrate which isn't likely to go very well, 1 seems fair but ultimately puts a cap on what can be included in games which I don't want to do, and 3 while sounding good to me requires clear guidelines on what is or isn't an Indie and again runs the risk of over-policing what people can put in games.
See this mess? There is no good answer. But I can't just trust players to play the games without any of this extra shit, so then what. It would be so much easier if people could just play their roles as intended, instead of always trying to find a cheap edge to play spoiler.
*Limit the scope of super role madness, such as the removal of wishes
*Make it a rule that the spirit of a role must be followed beyond just the letter
*Remove ambiguity with Indies, i.e. discard the concept of pro-town indies and anti-town indies
The problem with 2 is it becomes very vague and relies on the hosts to arbitrate which isn't likely to go very well, 1 seems fair but ultimately puts a cap on what can be included in games which I don't want to do, and 3 while sounding good to me requires clear guidelines on what is or isn't an Indie and again runs the risk of over-policing what people can put in games.
See this mess? There is no good answer. But I can't just trust players to play the games without any of this extra shit, so then what. It would be so much easier if people could just play their roles as intended, instead of always trying to find a cheap edge to play spoiler.
Okay, fine, let's say it isn't gamethrowing in its purest form
But it is gamethrowing ethically
and selfishly unkind
It's inconsiderate of players who wanted to win the game strategically without bending rules or finding loopholes to rely on, while also not trolling with your abioities for laughs and your own amusement (that affect either factions, just not you)
That may not be your problem, you can decide to take it on, but I think that's the gripe
I don't care how you played, I don't feel bitter, I just want to explain why some might feel bitter
But it is gamethrowing ethically
and selfishly unkind
It's inconsiderate of players who wanted to win the game strategically without bending rules or finding loopholes to rely on, while also not trolling with your abioities for laughs and your own amusement (that affect either factions, just not you)
That may not be your problem, you can decide to take it on, but I think that's the gripe
I don't care how you played, I don't feel bitter, I just want to explain why some might feel bitter
.
It isn't just Blue here. Blue is responsible in that he gave it the OK, but there is already an issue with a player seeing their role and trying to find a way to change it, to negatively affect the game, for the prupose of trolling. Case in point, he used his role to kill a player going against the spirit of his role entirely, all so he could enable something he had already discussed. I'm starting to think the only option is to police it out of these games as apparently you can't trust players to just play.
. Next time I hope we can play again once you‘re less busy.
There was but I got lazy xD
I put it Town with an alternate wincon cause no way I was going to take out the other indies.
And Libra didn't make it because it was too many indies.
The only one that I could potetially taken out was the Serial Killer I think.
Kanade and Maka goes in a pair and Chtolly was a must have.
I put it Town with an alternate wincon cause no way I was going to take out the other indies.
And Libra didn't make it because it was too many indies.
The only one that I could potetially taken out was the Serial Killer I think.
Kanade and Maka goes in a pair and Chtolly was a must have.
- Status