We trust Rottkins, right?
My hangup is actually this ability. I mean, I guess this is SRM, but it seems weird to have an ability where the mod provides you targetless info. I've seen wagon analyzing abilities and that makes sense, but these names thrown out there at random seems almost a little too convenient to be true.
If it is true, I wouldn't make the assumption that the other two names besides the killer are town, but I can see where T-Pein is coming from in at least thinking mod provided information would not include an entire list of scum, or would tend to be proportional (and this would result in 1/3 scum here too). This assumes of course that the host just doesn't throw in two names at random after throwing in the killer, which I would assume by default, but these all *just happen* to be players with dubious claims.