[FNZ] Role Madness Valentine's Mafia Game: Be My Valentine

[Charlie]

There's 2 confirmed people who aren't dead, and one has to be between the couple

couldn't it be one of chef and old lady?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

i mean, end of the epitaph kinda implies Beatrice's involvement

For the 9th Twilight, after the 8 we are trying to solve

 

[DarkestKnightofSpoilers]

vote count
AM 2 votes
pein 1 vote

Player List:

1- @Pot Goblin
2- @Psylocke
3- @T-Pein™
4- @Ultra
5- @Alwaysmind
6- @Dr_Professor83
7- @Apollo
8- @kavotino
9- @Peroroncino
10- @Flower
11- @Fujishiro
12- @Charlie
13- @Gambit
14- @Kiku
15- @AL sama
16- @Juliet
17- @RippedCal
18- @Indigo
19- @hime
20- @DoflaMihawk
21- @xenos5
22- @Pew
23- @Yo Tan Wa
24- @Reborn
25- @DarkestKnightofSpoilers​

Does everybody have to vote a lynch now?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

couldn't it be one of chef and old lady?

It could if the Epitah Poem thing isn’t accurate.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Does everybody have to vote a lynch now?

Before the day ends.

You can not vote, but that’s not advised.

 

[Charlie]

Does everybody have to vote a lynch now?

you can, but don't have to

It could if the Epitah Poem thing isn’t accurate.

i mean, of course it isn't

it mentions 6 people dying instead of 5

 

[Dr_Professor83]

it mentions 6 people dying instead of 5

Ultra already pointed out that Kinzo could count as one of the 6 sacrifices.

 

[Charlie]

Ultra already pointed out that Kinzo could count as one of the 6 sacrifices.

oh that's fair point

still, if we we're to follow epitaph completely, 2 people should die on the second twilight

when we look at old maid's and chef's death - gourge the stomach and kill makes sense for chef, but why is old maid reffered to as "chest"? she doesn't even wear family symbol on her chest

 

[Ultra]

couldn't it be one of chef and old lady?

Present an explanation for T2 being a locked room and both of them being dead based on available evidence. I literally can't. In T1/T5/T6 it's at least hypothetically possible they're all dead.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

still, if we we're to follow epitaph completely, 2 people should die on the second twilight

Being torn apart doesn’t mean both died. If one killed the other, that’s “torn apart”

when we look at old maid's and chef's death - gourge the stomach and kill makes sense for chef, but why is old maid reffered to as "chest"? she doesn't even wear family symbol on her chest

No idea why she’d be the chest lol.

 

[York]

Vote Lynch Dr_Professor83

I don't know enough about everybody's playstyle to really trust anyone yet, or to know what your brands of "playing scummy" are like. So I'm just going to do what I think is the safest vote. Best case scenario, lying scum dies. Worst case scenario, we lose a "pro-town" player who isn't even that pro town.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Present an explanation for T2 being a locked room and both of them being dead based on available evidence. I literally can't. In T1/T5/T6 it's at least hypothetically possible they're all dead.

There is no other way for them to have been killed in the locked room. Only way for one to not be a culprit faking death, is if the door wasn’t really locked.

I think based on us knowing there are fake deaths, their spot in the poem not confirming their deaths, and Shannon “unlocking the door” that it’s a pretty safe bet one is involved.

 

[Charlie]

Being torn apart doesn’t mean both died. If one killed the other, that’s “torn apart”

oooooooh

wait

not torn in pieces

one of them dying and 2nd person living without other, aka separated

now it makes way more sense

 

[Charlie]

given that Natsuhi is barely a character and expaining anything in regards to her would be impossible, i think it's more plausible that Krauss lives

 

[Dr_Professor83]

given that Natsuhi is barely a character and expaining anything in regards to her would be impossible, i think it's more plausible that Krauss lives

So here’s a question on Krauss and Natsuhi lol, why did they kill their daughter Jessica at the end if one is involved?

 

[Charlie]

So here’s a question on Krauss and Natsuhi lol, why did they kill their daughter Jessica at the end if one is involved?

i don't think they would, if anything, person who survived massacre #1 killed her

 

[Dr_Professor83]

i don't think they would, if anything, person who survived massacre #1 killed her

I guess if we assume they aren’t all working together lol.

Like, if they were, I get why they would kill the Doctor if he’s in on it (to silence him). But not sure why kill your daughter lol.

 

[Charlie]

i'd say Krauss and Natsuhi couldn't kill other one since epitaph says "those who remain shall tear them apart"

 

[Charlie]

I guess if we assume they aren’t all working together lol.

Like, if they were, I get why they would kill the Doctor if he’s in on it (to silence him). But not sure why kill your daughter lol.

i'm under assumption doctor only checked if head buttler is dead, he believes that children wouldn't be mistanken, but he didn't check it himself

Nanjo: No one is going to mistakenly confirm a death, even those other than myself.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

i'd say Krauss and Natsuhi couldn't kill other one since epitaph says "those who remain shall tear them apart"

I mean if one of them killed the other they can be included in “them” and “those that remain”.

Bigger thing, is do you think the room would not really be locked?