Okay so this will and can absolutely change because I dont remember alors of the interactions before Ratchet flipped but I'd go for the inactives like
Pot, Tea, Apollo (he's picking up the pace these past few pages or I'm an asshole and he's just not been noticable enough for me)
Under hypothetical scenarios like if there's one more Mafia feller power wolfing or multiple, then we're kinda fucked - in this limited and unrealistic scenario it'd be you and Charlie as primary PoE, or Kiku and Charlie
the latter is less plausible because it's really based on meta lol
apollo is town, charlie is town, and kiku likely town
the mafia/cult is in tpein, bill, pot, and MAYBE reborn rej
bill claimed batman just earlier. dont know what to make of it. i thought he was bane from the kangaroo court ability
i have a result on tpein. he is robin (tim drake) confirmed mafia
tpein could also be cult at the same time, as is common in aries games mafia players get culted. rej and reborn would be my other cult candidates. low chance it being kiku but i dont have an explanation for her tracker result failing on X's fake claim