Manga Discussion Manga/Anime Hot Takes

Is One Piece as good as people make it out to be?

  • Total voters
    34
  • Poll closed .
Light D Lamperouge

Light D Lamperouge

𝕴𝖓 π•Ώπ–π–Žπ–˜ 𝖂𝖔𝖗𝖑𝖉 π•Ίπ–“π–‘π–ž 𝕴 𝖆𝖒 π•Άπ–Žπ–“π–Œ
β€Ž
#1
#1
So as the title says use this thread to share your hot takes about any manga or anime.





First poll's results:

Second poll's results








Copying this taglist from some other threads
@Adam 🍎 @AkainuTheGrimReaper @Arondight @Artorias @ArturCantSpeakJapanese @AverageNamiEnjoyer @Awayeah @B Rabbit @BaboonMihawk @BakiDou @balajiram99 @Balen @Baluzi @BangOOπŸ… @BarbosaXIII @Beerbottle @bennbeckman @Bepo @Bil02 @Blackbeard [ @Cherry Hilk @Chessaddict @Chrono @Cinera @CoC: Color of Clowns @comrade @ConquistadoR @Courier @Cream filled donut7 @Cross_Marian @Crush @Cruxroux @Cutty Jewboy @Cyrus the Cactus @D.Querna @Da evil Who @Daikenki @Dark Admiral @Dark Hound @DarkestKnightofSpoilers @DarkWitch @Date @Debanv @Den_Den_Mushi @Desolate Smaug @Dettles @dirtyLarry @dizzy2341 @djiayebee @DKI @Doggo @Don DaSlayer @Don Diego @DonWick @Draco @Dr_Professor83 @duckman @Ekkologix @Electricmastro @Enma @EtenBoby @Eustass @Franosuke @FaradaySloth @Fleet Admiral Lee Hung @Fleet Leader Fenaker @FloriGlori @Flower @Flynn @Fn Lucci @Fuckthis3 @Fujishiro @gamaran @Gambit @Ganja userr @garciajulieen @Garp the Fist @Garps tekkai @GeneralP123 @Gensui Sazid @Geo @God Buggy @God_Aizen @Gol D. Roger @Gon’s Missing Arm @GrandmasterChef Zonji @Greenbeard @H3llion @HA001 OF THE RAIN @Hades @HAJI @Halyup @Hanners220 @Hanzo hattori @Hedfi @Herasux @Hereforthesalt @HeroesNZ @Hiragaro @hlo69300 @Hurley Pirates @Iaarm @Ice devil slayer @IceWitch @Ichiro Miyata @ImmaIvanoM @Irregular @Ishin @Jackteo @Jaguark101 @Jailer @januarysdaughter @JazzMazz @Jiihad @JJtheman @Johnny B. Decent @Julius @Just a member @JyThony @K!NG HARA$H!MA @Kagurashii @Kai. Do @KaiHiei @Kejon @kenedyfake @KenshiraSonata @Kenshiro11 @Kerkovian @Kiiro @Kiku @Killer#777 @King4nakama @King7 @KINGKONGGUN15 @Kiwipom @kom5 @KonyaruIchi @Koro @kratosΕ› @krogothwolf @Kromage911 @Krusher1357 @Kucing Pencuri @kumae @Kuro Ashi @Kurozumi D. Trussop @Kurozumi mugiwara44 @Kurozumi Seven7 @Kurozumi Wiwi @Kurozumi Giggio @kurwa @Kyou @LANJI CUCKSMOKE @Law-sama @LayerZ @Lifeismeh @Light D Lamperouge @Lindltaylor @Lion of Olympus @Lizzy @LolonoisZolo @Longleg Larry @Lor D. Coast @Lord_Braggy @Luffy is the mc @m0nst3Rx USER=368]@mad monk[/USER] @Maggi @Malick the last Light @MangoSenpai @Marimo_420 @MarineHQ @Markorus @Mashiro Blue @MasterD @matt245 @Meeyori @Melvin @Midnight Delight @Mighty Action X @milluki @Milou @Missy @mly90 @mmd @Momoheechulkabe9000 @Monarch @Monkey D Theories @MonsterKaido @MonsterZoro @Mr. Anderson @Mr. Reloaded @mrtsrdr @mugiwalaw @NAMELESS @Nana @Natalija @Necrohol @Nekomamushi @Nibel @Nidai_Kitetsu @nik87 @NikaInParis @NotRanga @NotTommy @nRandle @Oblivion @OnePieceFanGirl @OnePiss @Parker @park_min young @Patryipe @PaulOO @Peenix @Peppercore @Peroroncino @pg13 @Playa4321 @Plex @PuckTheGreat @QQH @qwe @R A I T E I I I @Raiden7 @Ravagerblade @RayanOO @Reborn @Reddot4 @Redhair Le Fishe @ReggieZoldyck21 @Rej @Rivaille @Rottkins @Rukusho @Sade @SakazOuki @Sakazuki-Singh @Sallucion @SDfear @Senfret @Seth @ShadyOjiro @Shanks @SHIHI @ShinichiMugi @ShishioIsBack @Shishi @sidestreetboy @silverfire @Sir Yasheen @SmokedOut @spawn @Thabeast @The White Crane @TheAncientCenturion @TheKnightOfTheSea @thodoris5321 @Tobra @Toph @Topi Jerami @Weeman @Welkin @Yelan @yj @Yo Tan Wa @yorosenpai @Yoru @ZenZu @Zolo @Zoroe @zorojurou @ZoroSlaysDragonTuna @zzShinichi @FloriGlori @Leo @DizzyBrows @uyuu @Ravagerblade @Topi Jerami @Akai2 @EtenBoby @PirateKingDrew @Marimo_420 @Seth @Kucing Pencuri @Dark Hound @Arara @Yukihime @Zoro @zorojurou @Luffy bin Dragon @Senfret @sidestreetboy @PerfectHie @Don DaSlayer @RobertoTheOharaSurvivor @Nibel @Yelan @ConquistadoR @LANJI CUCKSMOKE @SHIHI @Yo Tan Wa @Robin swan @Jorden625 @Monkey D Theories @The White Crane @U c 4 up da idly @Astolfo @MUUGEN @Lax @Queek Hea D Taker @Alpha @ShimonoaZoro971 @mugiwalaw @Konstantis @gamaran @Blackknife @zorojurou @Real94 @Kiwipom @sidestreetboy @hayze moya @djiayebee @Wh1p @Dr_Professor83 @DoctorIndigo @Gladwing0 @Alpha @Adam-san @MonochromeYoru @Zoroe @TheKnightOfTheSea @Shadowlord123 @Seth @Butters @Dark Admiral @notAfanboy @Rottkins @PaulOO @NikaInParis @BangOOπŸ… @NAMELESS @Lhulu @TheAncientCenturion
@YhwachTheMustache
 
Last edited:
Jaguark101

Jaguark101

"I'm not feeling particularly magnanimous today"
β€Žβ€Ž
#8
#8
Fairy tail is not as bad as alot of people claim.

Naruto should have wrapped up after the pain arc. Do a little rewrite and remove tobi/madara altogether and have Sasuke vs. Naruto right after 5 kage summit.

"Heart" page in Bleach is brilliant.

Skypeia/Jaya captures the spirit of One Piece best and is easily a top 5 arc in the series.

I like that Ichigo's Bankai got broken by Yhwach immediately
 
C

Cruxroux

#11
#11
JayKitetsu said:
I think the Shounen genre is a dying breed. Every trope has been done before (inner demon, fighting demons, power of friendship, grandiose goal for the MC, etc ) and most mangakas seem to take major inspirations and themes from other works to the point where it comes off as a cheap copy.
Click to expand...
I mean shouene literally means for kids
And
inner demon, fighting demons, power of friendship, grandiose goal for the MC, etc
Fits perfectly.
It's the seinen mangas deals with adult stuff.
 
JayKitetsu

JayKitetsu

β€Ž
#12
#12
Cruxroux said:
I mean shouene literally means for kids
And
inner demon, fighting demons, power of friendship, grandiose goal for the MC, etc
Fits perfectly.
It's the seinen mangas deals with adult stuff.
Click to expand...
True, kids probably don't really care as much; but when you grow up with certain series and want to check out others within the genre it's just the same concepts with different characters.

And a lot of Shounen tackle adult topics β€” albeit, not as in-depth as Seinen β€” like the CA arc from HxH and FMI from One Piece
 
Sir Yasheen

Sir Yasheen

β€Ž
#17
#17
1. Fairy tail has better characters and makes you care about these characters more than most typical shonen

2. Ichigo not having a big goal is why he’s a more relatable character and is the best protagonist of the big 3

3. Demon Slayer and AoT have two of the worst endings in manga. Yes worse than the 4th great ninja war.

4. The popularity of Marineford and Ennies Lobby is why One Piece is so bad now a days.

5. Isekai have become the most prominent genre in anime
 
NAMELESS

NAMELESS

β€Ž
#18
#18
Sir Yasheen said:
1. Fairy tail has better characters and makes you care about these characters more than most typical shonen

2. Ichigo not having a big goal is why he’s a more relatable character and is the best protagonist of the big 3

3. Demon Slayer and AoT have two of the worst endings in manga. Yes worse than the 4th great ninja war.

4. The popularity of Marineford and Ennies Lobby is why One Piece is so bad now a days.

5. Isekai have become the most prominent genre in anime
Click to expand...
Ichigo not being a brain dead retard makes him more relatable too.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top