[FNZ] Role Madness Jujutsu Kaisen Mafia - Shibuya Incident [Game Ended = Mafia + Traitor + Neutral Indie Won!]

[York]

Where were you rereading tho?

You rereading is alarming to me lol. I want to see the receipts

Just rereading today's posts. Both mentions were from today

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Just rereading today's posts. Both mentions were from today

Quote them lol

 

[Orwellian]

Kiku that unvote came pretty rapid, its a little shady.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I’m too busy rn to check lol

 

[Dr_Professor83]

My main POE is Kiku, Cal, Midnight, and Nika.
What's yours?

Ratchet + Michelle + those

Why is Ratchet not in yours?

 

[York]

Kiku that unvote came pretty rapid, its a little shady.

I learn new information and I adjust. It would be stupid NOT to unvote in this situation.

None. He appears in blue Town colour in my role.

Choso was town
Gojo is also Town Colour in my role but I am wondering how possible it is for a Pro Town indie to exist

@Dr_Professor83

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Anyway I probably took your post wrong @Orwellian , I’m having a bad time irl and am also really kicking myself that some of its seeped into this game and I’m letting everyone down bc we’re losing

 

[Orwellian]

Ratchet + Michelle + those

Why is Ratchet not in yours?

Ratchet would be dependent on one of those I mentioned flipping town potentially. I know Magic/Neeko was suspicious of him but selfishly gonna equate it to Magic not having a good legacy read, more so interested in why you have Michelle there instead of Midnight. So you solidly have everyone else mentioned as likely town?

Where do you stand on converting vs just eliminating Sukuna?

 

[Orwellian]

Anyway I probably took your post wrong @Orwellian , I’m having a bad time irl and am also really kicking myself that some of its seeped into this game and I’m letting everyone down bc we’re losing

Don't worry about it at the end of the day:

- a) this is just a game
- b) I had a pretty shit day at work today too so I can understand

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Ratchet would be dependent on one of those I mentioned flipping town potentially. I know Magic/Neeko was suspicious of him but selfishly gonna equate it to Magic not having a good legacy read, more so interested in why you have Michelle there instead of Midnight. So you solidly have everyone else mentioned as likely town?

Where do you stand on converting vs just eliminating Sukuna?

Solidly? I have few solid Town left

I think Michelle has equity with Ratchet which is why they’re in POE. I’ve mentioned Midnight in POE constantly today too. I just said we have the same POE + those 2

 

[Orwellian]

I learn new information and I adjust. It would be stupid NOT to unvote in this situation.



@Dr_Professor83

That is potentially true but it still shady in this situation with where the stakes are. Liberally jumping the gun with votes can be dangerous, that's my advice.

Solidly? I have few solid Town left

I think Michelle has equity with Ratchet which is why they’re in POE. I’ve mentioned Midnight in POE constantly today too. I just said we have the same POE + those 2

Can you walk me through your case with Michelle = Ratchet in equity? Specifically Michelle. Also my bad, like you sometimes I speed read a little too fast.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Can you walk me through your case with Michelle = Ratchet in equity? Specifically Michelle. Also my bad, like you sometimes I speed read a little too fast.

It’s not a lot. But yesterday when people were scum reading Ratchet Michelle was saying that Ratchet shouldn’t be scum bc Ratchet told her to duel Broki. Seems like too much credit to give Ratchet there when he was one of many tho which Michelle didn’t seem to account for.

Then we have 4 town assassins flipping already (Ultra, AM, Conq, Tweet) so I see potential for Michelle to be scum assassin.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Like Michelle asked the thread who to duel. And every person who answered said Broki, bc she was the only acceptable answer.

I can’t give anyone credit for that.

 

[York]

The main thing keeping me from suspecting Michelle is her dueling Broki, on the same day as the lynch fixing

Scum team using some of their limited resources to... do a scum vs scum duel and switch the lynch from a townie to a townie? At the same time? Those mindgames have to be next level

 

[York]

The main thing keeping me from suspecting Michelle is her dueling Broki, on the same day as the lynch fixing

Scum team using some of their limited resources to... do a scum vs scum duel and switch the lynch from a townie to a townie? At the same time? Those mindgames have to be next level

Like, I know Broki wasn't her choice, but you think she'd just keep quiet if she was scum

 

[Orwellian]

It’s not a lot. But yesterday when people were scum reading Ratchet Michelle was saying that Ratchet shouldn’t be scum bc Ratchet told her to duel Broki. Seems like too much credit to give Ratchet there when he was one of many tho which Michelle didn’t seem to account for.

Then we have 4 town assassins flipping already (Ultra, AM, Conq, Tweet) so I see potential for Michelle to be scum assassin.

Here's my issue.
Michelle had no reason as scum to waste a duel to bus a teammate like Broki in that situation. It doesn't really logically pan out and puts her in squarely back in the kill zone with the public attention that draws. I don't know how much experience Michelle has in mafia games but publicly asking who she should duel seems more like a novice play then anything else unless you want to argue she was being coached though I don't know who would be able to pull that off.

Also what if none of the assassins are scum?

The game is basically in a quasi multi-ball set up:

town (sorcerers or whatever their called) vs mafia (cursed spirits) vs hostile indie (sukuna)

Granted this is an Ekko game so crazy shit is bound to be in there to make things balanced, I can see where your coming from on this but I'm not 100% sold on it.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

The main thing keeping me from suspecting Michelle is her dueling Broki, on the same day as the lynch fixing

Scum team using some of their limited resources to... do a scum vs scum duel and switch the lynch from a townie to a townie? At the same time? Those mindgames have to be next level

Michelle really didn’t have much choice bc the duel was claimed the day before and we were asking for it to be used that day. What’s she’s gonna do? Say “no I’m not doing it”? Would have been a horrific look when Broki flipped scum. So I consider the usage neutral.

As for using the execute too. The execute usage was a weird head game way you look at it. It worked tho.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Like, I know Broki wasn't her choice, but you think she'd just keep quiet if she was scum

I believe she was tagged and asked to use it

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I guess she could have gone afk the entire day but also not great lol

 

[Orwellian]

Think about it:

- if Michelle is scum and then you have both the duel result and another potential lynch of another scum member then day 2 pans out with the scum team losing 2 players at the end of everything

- then again if Michelle is being coached and is new at mafia and she was being coached it could also logically deflect from attention on another mafia lynch

So I'm 50/50 on this