General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
Bonney having access to partial Nika basically disqualifies her in my eyes (still mad about that). But that would be pre-G5 Oda when he pretended that Devil Fruits were consistent. I guess the 12 year old child can join, and we'll have Sanji simping over her the entire time.
To me it would have made more sense that she joins the revolutionaries like her dad, and supports the Straw Hats as a revolutionary ally. Especially if Kuma doesn't die or is revived somehow, as we wouldn't have both her and a Warlord joining in the same arc. I also imagine she'd much rather spend time with her father.
But we in Dream Fruit piece now and I no longer expect Oda to have any restraint or any consistency. If you think 10 dudes is still a hard number after the Nika fruit and Bonney's "altered future where she gets the Nika fruit", you gotta be very selective about when Oda cares about his stories consistency.
To me it would have made more sense that she joins the revolutionaries like her dad, and supports the Straw Hats as a revolutionary ally. Especially if Kuma doesn't die or is revived somehow, as we wouldn't have both her and a Warlord joining in the same arc. I also imagine she'd much rather spend time with her father.
But we in Dream Fruit piece now and I no longer expect Oda to have any restraint or any consistency. If you think 10 dudes is still a hard number after the Nika fruit and Bonney's "altered future where she gets the Nika fruit", you gotta be very selective about when Oda cares about his stories consistency.
That doesn't guarantee you a prominent position within a Yonko crew. Just look at Hawkins, who was a Headliner, just like all those Smile guys whose names we already forgot. Or Bege, who was a combatant, just like Bobbin, etc.. Nothing special. And it's still a fact that she's 12, just no one knows it.
I'd be willing to put Ussop, Chopper, Nami and most SH in the aprentice position, outside of say Brook or Jimbei, because most of them never were pirates, Bonney is not that either, she's in the former captain camp.
Some people here imagine the SHs to always be great at their roles so the position of aprentice will always be bizarre to them
[automerge]1703287279[/automerge]
What does she have to learn as an aprentice when she's already one of the most famous pirate captains or at least pirates in the world.
I mean what am i saying Oda is a fraud, so sure she can be an aprentice.
Some people here imagine the SHs to always be great at their roles so the position of aprentice will always be bizarre to them
[automerge]1703287279[/automerge]
What does she have to learn as an aprentice when she's already one of the most famous pirate captains or at least pirates in the world.
I mean what am i saying Oda is a fraud, so sure she can be an aprentice.
I'd be willing to put Ussop, Chopper, Nami and most SH in the aprentice position, outside of say Brook or Jimbei, because most of them never were pirates, Bonney is not that either, she's in the former captain camp.
Some people here imagine the SHs to always be great at their roles so the position of aprentice will always be bizarre to them
[automerge]1703287279[/automerge]
What does she have to learn as an aprentice when she's already one of the most famous pirate captains or at least pirates in the world.
I mean what am i saying Oda is a fraud, so sure she can be an aprentice.
Some people here imagine the SHs to always be great at their roles so the position of aprentice will always be bizarre to them
[automerge]1703287279[/automerge]
What does she have to learn as an aprentice when she's already one of the most famous pirate captains or at least pirates in the world.
I mean what am i saying Oda is a fraud, so sure she can be an aprentice.
people saying apprentice is there own opinion
I think Bonney will be the next SH.
For the past few yrs we’ve seen 3 fan favorite characters that ODA seemed to write as if they were the next SH member.
Carrot - Great transformation
Tama - A child
Yamato - Great Power
if you think about it, Bonney represents them all. It seems like Oda was already giving hints who the next SH member will be from few yrs back.
But still. I wont complain if we will have Vivi, Yamato and Bonney joining.
For the past few yrs we’ve seen 3 fan favorite characters that ODA seemed to write as if they were the next SH member.
Carrot - Great transformation
Tama - A child
Yamato - Great Power
if you think about it, Bonney represents them all. It seems like Oda was already giving hints who the next SH member will be from few yrs back.
But still. I wont complain if we will have Vivi, Yamato and Bonney joining.
Since Bonney is 12, and can join the crew, Luffy would basically be dealing with a child. That’s if Bonney reveals to them that she is 12. I doubt everyone in the crew would be okay with her joining without someone to take care of her when/if she tells them her real age. This is like if kid Momonosuke just joined by himself without Kinemon.
I feel like people tend to forget that Bonney is one of the most infamous pirate captains in the world. The supernovas are a huge deal, and one of them joining Luffy is front page global news in the One Piece world. Bonney is not underqualified, not too young, not too weak. She's not going to be a damn apprentice. Even vice captain is more suitable for her than apprentice.