[FNZ] Salem of Lies Return of the Throne (Unofficial)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I started my vote against Zara because earlier in the day, he said that there isnt much stuff to base anything on so he doesnt have a clear read:



I gave him pointers as to what to look for as there has been a confirmed conversion of BD.

After 5 hours I ask again:

He doesn't see my message, fair enough. I ask again. He gives the reads which to me are very simplistic, giving me the idea he is being passive. He did not provide quotes or deeper explanation. Not a good look so I vote.

The reason why I unvoted is because I think he might be telling the truth about being BD.





He is being reckless, not afraid to die, as a hunter would.

I believe my vote could be used on someone else.

Now that I explained everything, @LANJI CUCKSMOKE why did you latch onto me, and not onto queen, who unvoted way earlier. Why are you not responding to my suspicion of queen with the unvoting and the whispering? Why ignore her? Are you deflecting onto me? Perhaps to protect her?
@Reborn @Flower @AL sama @Kiwipom what are your thoughts?
queen and kiwi insisted it was unique
so I countered with the clarification from drago
I have no problem with unvoting
what I have a problem with is why you unvoted when you sussed queen for doing the exact same thing.
:goatasure: .

seems like you both unvoted for the exact same reason you trust his claim and I dont.
am not sure what you mean about the whispering argument, its only between you and flowa so whatever you told her should be safe unless flowa is converted.
 
Queen Whom you sus?
good question
I sus krogo for his lack of activity but I don't really feel like starting a case against someone who still didn't post today, I will wait for him to appear
zara may be kinda sus because hunter is not unique, I don't really want to lynch him but he is the only one who will get enough votes to be lynched today and myslynch may be better than no lynch in d2
 

AL sama

Red Haired
I started my vote against Zara because earlier in the day, he said that there isnt much stuff to base anything on so he doesnt have a clear read:



I gave him pointers as to what to look for as there has been a confirmed conversion of BD.

After 5 hours I ask again:

He doesn't see my message, fair enough. I ask again. He gives the reads which to me are very simplistic, giving me the idea he is being passive. He did not provide quotes or deeper explanation. Not a good look so I vote.

The reason why I unvoted is because I think he might be telling the truth about being BD.





He is being reckless, not afraid to die, as a hunter would.

I believe my vote could be used on someone else.

Now that I explained everything, @LANJI CUCKSMOKE why did you latch onto me, and not onto queen, who unvoted way earlier. Why are you not responding to my suspicion of queen with the unvoting and the whispering? Why ignore her? Are you deflecting onto me? Perhaps to protect her?
@Reborn @Flower @AL sama @Kiwipom what are your thoughts?
I'll get to this when I wake up
Post automatically merged:

her tone changed

she is more invested

she is scum hunting and game solving

these aspects were lacking last day
 

Kiwipom

Ghost Princess
good question
I sus krogo for his lack of activity but I don't really feel like starting a case against someone who still didn't post today, I will wait for him to appear
zara may be kinda sus because hunter is not unique, I don't really want to lynch him but he is the only one who will get enough votes to be lynched today and myslynch may be better than no lynch in d2
Tbh I’m down with lynching someone else instead of Zara. Rereading, his progression to claiming seems organic. I’m still concerned about the BD/Black dragon thing but overall, I would prefer the rb route to check (but I’m also not a fan of plans)

If we could lynch someone else, who would you want gone?
 
Tbh I’m down with lynching someone else instead of Zara. Rereading, his progression to claiming seems organic. I’m still concerned about the BD/Black dragon thing but overall, I would prefer the rb route to check (but I’m also not a fan of plans)

If we could lynch someone else, who would you want gone?
besides krogo and zara? probably marimo, he is not helping, but I don't really sus him though, lynching him would be the same as lynching zara
I really need to hear what krogo has to say
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
This audience have few people my hands are itching to Lynch......

And, fun part is I can troll them here and they can simply watch me do so helplessly:gokulaugh:


@Melontonin and @Queen what you guys arguing for?
Here she is indifferent in me wanting to whisper to Al. Why not try to tell me that whispering flower is a better idea like Zara or Flower did? Never said Al Sama is confirmed townie, had a hunch he is good.
You may only send 1 whisper per day. You can only receive 2 whispers per day.
do what you think it's best, if you have al sama as confirmed townie...
Here I say I am going to whisper to Flower:
I just reread the rules, and answered in the other forum as a mistake lmao

Yeah I will whisper my role to flower instead
Not a minute later:
Why say that when I just said I am going to whisper to flower? Later I mention how she only warns me and not Sera OR Kiwi, who was the first to mention Whispers.

Then I call her out:
@Queen if you don't mind me asking, what made you go on the mastermind wiki rn
Who was the first to mention Whispering this DP?
idk
probably you
Fast, inacurate response. Unlike how I have seen Queen act all game, who takes her time and is analytical.

she was talking about whispering HER role though
Bizarre, why say this? This is exactly the subject we are talking about: whispering roles...

and that's the end of that. Until everyone questions Zara.
She immediately unvotes him as soon as he is claiming Hunter. Why? I assumed she was afraid of him shooting a voter, which might be her because I assumed she did not know only the last will be shot. Maybe she unvould be because she wants to be on his good side. She said it's because he is a unique role and unconvertible. I think it's too fast.

This summarizes the whispering. Why me and not the others?


I already explained why this makes you suspicious. The timing. The fact that I was not the first nor the second to mention whispering. Why not warn the others? Did the fact that other roles that could read whispers really click into your head when I first mentioned it? After I whisper no one can whisper to Flower anymore, and Flower has a lot of townies trust.


This is why I am suspicious.
This was her response.

I decided to search "whispers unseen" on the wiki when you decided to whisper your role to the guy who was the main sus yesterday instead of the confirmed townie for some reason

And now I end this here, that's is one looong message lmao
Post automatically merged:

why did you unvote
if you sus queen
for the exact same thing.
Post automatically merged:


whats the mechanic about whispers
its only between you and flowa
right?
so the only issue is is flowa is converted.
I don't understand what you mean by mechanic?
 
Here she is indifferent in me wanting to whisper to Al. Why not try to tell me that whispering flower is a better idea like Zara or Flower did? Never said Al Sama is confirmed townie, had a hunch he is good.


Here I say I am going to whisper to Flower:


Not a minute later:


Why say that when I just said I am going to whisper to flower? Later I mention how she only warns me and not Sera OR Kiwi, who was the first to mention Whispers.

Then I call her out:




Fast, inacurate response. Unlike how I have seen Queen act all game, who takes her time and is analytical.




Bizarre, why say this? This is exactly the subject we are talking about: whispering roles...

and that's the end of that. Until everyone questions Zara.
She immediately unvotes him as soon as he is claiming Hunter. Why? I assumed she was afraid of him shooting a voter, which might be her because I assumed she did not know only the last will be shot. Maybe she unvould be because she wants to be on his good side. She said it's because he is a unique role and unconvertible. I think it's too fast.

This summarizes the whispering. Why me and not the others?



This was her response.




And now I end this here, that's is one looong message lmao
scum can read the whispers?


bruh
so fucking dumb this whole thing is.
 
Here she is indifferent in me wanting to whisper to Al. Why not try to tell me that whispering flower is a better idea like Zara or Flower did? Never said Al Sama is confirmed townie, had a hunch he is good.


Here I say I am going to whisper to Flower:


Not a minute later:


Why say that when I just said I am going to whisper to flower? Later I mention how she only warns me and not Sera OR Kiwi, who was the first to mention Whispers.

Then I call her out:




Fast, inacurate response. Unlike how I have seen Queen act all game, who takes her time and is analytical.




Bizarre, why say this? This is exactly the subject we are talking about: whispering roles...

and that's the end of that. Until everyone questions Zara.
She immediately unvotes him as soon as he is claiming Hunter. Why? I assumed she was afraid of him shooting a voter, which might be her because I assumed she did not know only the last will be shot. Maybe she unvould be because she wants to be on his good side. She said it's because he is a unique role and unconvertible. I think it's too fast.

This summarizes the whispering. Why me and not the others?



This was her response.




And now I end this here, that's is one looong message lmao
you forgot to mention kiwi talked about whispering roles like 10 hours before this incident
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
@Melontonin
my quote is here on my question
I do not sus her for the exact same thing.

Zara for lack of responsiveness, quoting, digging
Queen for questionable time on wiki reading.

If you mean I unvoted Zara and I am critiquing Queen unvoting for Zara while I did the same, note I did it much slower than she did. Do you not notice her timing as suspect?

It really seems like you are coming to her defense. You are staying neutral about her but pushing me. Why?
 

Kiwipom

Ghost Princess
and that's the end of that. Until everyone questions Zara.
She immediately unvotes him as soon as he is claiming Hunter. Why? I assumed she was afraid of him shooting a voter, which might be her because I assumed she did not know only the last will be shot. Maybe she unvould be because she wants to be on his good side. She said it's because he is a unique role and unconvertible. I think it's too fast.
That's not true, Queen knew right away that Zara was hunter when he made that post, she said it here:
are you claiming hunter?
So she must of known that it was the last person who voted that gets killed.

Her reason for unvoting is here:
hunter is a unique class according to the wiki
unvote
She thought hunter was a unique class. And it is logical of her to unvote because for a scum to claim a unique class, it's a very risky move and will be outed right the moment someone counterclaimed.


When she found out that hunter wasn't a unique class, she casted the vote back.

But Mel, I really like this post. You're moving up my town list. Imo, Mel vs Queen is just town vs town.
 
flower doesnt have to convert for them to know your roles
since everyone knows when you whispered, at this point , that ability could already be in play .
Post automatically merged:

Yup, did not know cause this is my first mafia game ever
bruh .
I misunderstood.


why didnt any of yall call this shit out
when folks were asking for whispers.
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
queen and kiwi insisted it was unique
so I countered with the clarification from drago
I have no problem with unvoting
what I have a problem with is why you unvoted when you sussed queen for doing the exact same thing.
:goatasure: .

seems like you both unvoted for the exact same reason you trust his claim and I dont.
am not sure what you mean about the whispering argument, its only between you and flowa so whatever you told her should be safe unless flowa is converted.
I got a summary about the whispering thing now, you are free to check it out :)
 

Kiwipom

Ghost Princess
flower doesnt have to convert for them to know your roles
since everyone knows when you whispered, at this point , that ability could already be in play .
Post automatically merged:


bruh .
I misunderstood.


why didnt any of yall call this shit out
when folks were asking for whispers.
the problem with ToL is none of us cared enough to study the game and the abilities down to a T

So I'm guessing that no one noticed that scums could read whispers until Queen pointed out.


Just like how, FYI, if someone is roleblocked 3 times, they become roleblock immune.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top