I know, so I think it cancels itself out. If Kizaru and Luffy holding back led to Kizaru outlasting Luffy, I'm slightly favouring Kizaru extreme diff when both are going all out, whereas prior to egghead I was favouring Luffy extreme diff.
Luffy needed ACoC and G5 just to guarantee the stalemate, otherwise without WSG he was definitely losing to Kizaru. (Even then Kizaru would have won in a 1v1)
Basically I rate Kizaru a bit higher than I did prior to this arc powerlevel wise, I'm disappointed in him being Px Zaru, but at the same time I can be rational and understand he was not going all out like the story has been shoving in our faces all arc. I don't need to act like this was Kizaru going all out to write off his strength like Nidai does, but even if this was him going all out, it still comfortably places him above atleast Big Mom featwise.