Speculations Smoothie is a traitor working for Blackbeard
- Thread starter Monkey D Theories
- Start date
Well, here's the panel of Kid talking about it (chapter #928):
There's another translation that says that the mentioned SC hurt one of his men and he repaid the favor, but I never saw a translation that suggested an amicable affair. He did injure one of BM's Sweet Commanders, whatever the reason.
Even if you consider that he might've staged the entire thing, this simply isn't how Kid acts. He didn't care about Caesar's weapons, he didn't back down against Kaido, even after being betrayed by his allies, he went head-on against Shanks, even after losing an arm in the first battle... Kid is reckless, I doubt he would make a deal for a poneglyph rubbing, especially considering that he can't read them (the only way of knowing that it was the real poneglyph is if you made the copy yourself).
There's another translation that says that the mentioned SC hurt one of his men and he repaid the favor, but I never saw a translation that suggested an amicable affair. He did injure one of BM's Sweet Commanders, whatever the reason.
Even if you consider that he might've staged the entire thing, this simply isn't how Kid acts. He didn't care about Caesar's weapons, he didn't back down against Kaido, even after being betrayed by his allies, he went head-on against Shanks, even after losing an arm in the first battle... Kid is reckless, I doubt he would make a deal for a poneglyph rubbing, especially considering that he can't read them (the only way of knowing that it was the real poneglyph is if you made the copy yourself).
Well, here's the panel of Kid talking about it (chapter #928):
There's another translation that says that the mentioned SC hurt one of his men and he repaid the favor, but I never saw a translation that suggested an amicable affair. He did injure one of BM's Sweet Commanders, whatever the reason.
Even if you consider that he might've staged the entire thing, this simply isn't how Kid acts. He didn't care about Caesar's weapons, he didn't back down against Kaido, even after being betrayed by his allies, he went head-on against Shanks, even after losing an arm in the first battle... Kid is reckless, I doubt he would make a deal for a poneglyph rubbing, especially considering that he can't read them (the only way of knowing that it was the real poneglyph is if you made the copy yourself).
There's another translation that says that the mentioned SC hurt one of his men and he repaid the favor, but I never saw a translation that suggested an amicable affair. He did injure one of BM's Sweet Commanders, whatever the reason.
Even if you consider that he might've staged the entire thing, this simply isn't how Kid acts. He didn't care about Caesar's weapons, he didn't back down against Kaido, even after being betrayed by his allies, he went head-on against Shanks, even after losing an arm in the first battle... Kid is reckless, I doubt he would make a deal for a poneglyph rubbing, especially considering that he can't read them (the only way of knowing that it was the real poneglyph is if you made the copy yourself).
Post automatically merged:
Look at the dialogue between Law and Kid/Killer in 1056 when Law gives them the rubbing of Kaido’s poneglyph
Kid says they took a rubbing off BM’s general
Post automatically merged:
That would suggest the SC had a rubbing, meaning they might have been a traitor
I know you love to make some really dumb theories, but come on, you know damn well Smoothie isn't a traitor and is just a useless commander.
There was never a fucking traitor you buffoon, don't know why it's hard for you to accept that Kid just simply got a copy of the Poneglyph and then left.
You're also acting like Smoothie was at Whole Cake Island during that time, she might not have even been in Totto Land when Kid arrived.
The only traitor in Big Mom's crew was Bege, none of her children are traitors and none of them are secretly working for Blackbeard.
This is such a fucking dumb theory.
There was never a fucking traitor you buffoon, don't know why it's hard for you to accept that Kid just simply got a copy of the Poneglyph and then left.
You're also acting like Smoothie was at Whole Cake Island during that time, she might not have even been in Totto Land when Kid arrived.
The only traitor in Big Mom's crew was Bege, none of her children are traitors and none of them are secretly working for Blackbeard.
This is such a fucking dumb theory.
