Role Madness Harry Potter: A World Of Wizardry Game Thread

[Ratchet]

Caught up. I like Dest for town so far, am generally in agreement with where his head is at. Also like Michelle for town. Emil can go into Town leans, Flower as well. Not sure what to make of Charlie exactly. Very, very focused on talking about flavour, and the location thing was a bit weird, but not something I can't reconcile coming from him as town if that makes sense. YTW already mentioned I have as town. Including myself that makes 6 town, not a bad start!

Think I'm happy to throw my vote behind a Yoho wagon. Mostly in support of Flower's push, but something just isn't quite giving right for me with him so far.

I'm going to say it now before it inevitably comes up, but my presence will be hit and miss. I'll keep up as best I can, but please don't expect me to be here beyond bursts across the day.

Vote: Yoho

 

[Charlie]

Vote No Lynch

now that's something

we have like 60 hours (?) left

what's the point of this vote?

 

[Ratchet]

Kinda forgot about Luka, need to see more. He's a tricky player who lives within WIFOM.

 

[The Orca]

now that's something

we have like 60 hours (?) left

what's the point of this vote?

Majority lynch, no way a 16 person lynch isn't what scum want

 

[York]

You know, Orca makes a salient point. Lynching someone at this point would actually be less efficient because then we would have less people to search. If you value optimizing the Horcrux search so much then the safest option would be to abstain. If we truly desire to find the horcruxes as quickly as possible we should avoid as many deaths as we can.


/S

 

[Charlie]

@Ratchet

what's your take on location thing btw?

how would you rather organize it and wdyt of people who took a side in discussion

 

[Flower]

Kinda forgot about Luka, need to see more. He's a tricky player who lives within WIFOM.

Think he's probably scum. In his most recent scum game he was in quite a bit of danger because he pushed me and I snapped back. I feel like he's playing into doing the complete opposite here to prevent that.

 

[Charlie]

Majority lynch, no way a 16 person lynch isn't what scum want

it's not majority this phase

Only today will have the option for a majority lynch, however if the 72 hours run their course then it will be plurality.

so someone will be lynched regardless

 

[Flower]

it's not majority this phase



so someone will be lynched regardless

It is majority this phase, too.

 

[The Orca]

it's not majority this phase



so someone will be lynched regardless

Well that's better

 

[Destroya]

Actually Ratchet said I'm only active as scum

I completely misread that then. I feel in my experience its been the opposite. But again, it's just something small to start with.

 

[Flower]

You know, Orca makes a salient point. Lynching someone at this point would actually be less efficient because then we would have less people to search. If you value optimizing the Horcrux search so much then the safest option would be to abstain. If we truly desire to find the horcruxes as quickly as possible we should avoid as many deaths as we can.


/S

Tfw I didn't see the spoilers and wanted to push you cuz of that post lmfao.

 

[Destroya]

Yeah

Why?

 

[Destroya]

Vote No Lynch

wtf y?

 

[Luka]

Sideeye.gif

No! The correct response is "Yes Luka, I will carry you!!!"

 

[Luka]

Vote: Yoho

 

[Yoho]

🧐 Why we voting Yoho again?

 

[Destroya]

Problems with the "everyone shares where they're going" method

1. as Luka mentioned, there is the possibility that abilities exist that punish people for telegraphing where they're going to go that night
2. Scum can just lie about where they went. If I'm scum, I can just say "yeah sure I'll go to the Potions Classroom" and then if I make it to endgame without getting sussed, no one else will have checked the locations I claimed to have checked

Who cares if wolves lie? We want to make sure town doesn't visit the same spots; wolves can go wherever the fuck they want at night. The hard truth is that if we don't destroy the Horcruxes, Voldemort doesn't die. If we don't search for them, we definitely can't destroy them.

 

[Destroya]

You know, Orca makes a salient point. Lynching someone at this point would actually be less efficient because then we would have less people to search. If you value optimizing the Horcrux search so much then the safest option would be to abstain. If we truly desire to find the horcruxes as quickly as possible we should avoid as many deaths as we can.


/S

Except you said you don't want to search??

 

[Destroya]

Like wtf? You say let's not lunch anyone and you also don't want to coordinate the search of the Horcruxes, so pray tell how do we go about all of this? Pure rando luck?