Character Discussion Who should have joined the crew?

Favorite failed candidates?


  • Total voters
    36
#1
Among the candidates that looked like they had chance to join the crew but ended up did not, who did you wish the most?

- Monet
The most popular candidate during Punk Hazard arc.
Snow logia.
Possible role: Astronomer.

- Mera Mera Rebecca
Most popular candidate during Dressrosa arc
Fire logia
Already had long flashback and lost her mom in the flashback, the usual next nakama style
Possible role: Gladiator (?)

Carrot
Favorite candidate by One Piece kids in Zou and WCI arc
Bunny
Possible role: Lookout Novice

Pedro of The Treetop
Favorite candidate by One Piece men in Zou and WCI arc
Jaguar
Stronger and better design than Carrot
Possible role: Real Lookout

Pudding
Another kinda popular candidate in WCI arc
Possible role: Secondary Cook

Yamato
Most popular candidate during Onigashima arc / Wano act 3
Possible role: Cosplayer

Or anyone else?

My pick would be Pedro. Very good design, best designed half man half animal in the series. Likeable personality. No bullshit, he attacked Baron Tamago in the middle of his transformation instead of the usual dumb way of manga character doing nothing until the enemy finishes his transformation.
Has potential to kick Jinbe out of Monster Trio (electro vs fishman). Unrevealed Sulong. I would write Big Mom restoring his 50 years of lifespan when she got KO-ed. Had little quirk of staying in the highest place and quickly resorted to violence when he captured Pudding, just like each Straw Hats have their own little quirk. He would made his debut in Zou, became trial member in WCI, and officially joined in end of Wano arc, together with Jinbe.

Second choice would be Rebecca, but don't make her as total fodder like she actually is. She could stall Doflamingo with her new power of Mera Mera just like when Yamato stalled Kaido in Rooftop, until Luffy came and save the day. With her gladiator fighting style, she would be more melee oriented compared to Nami and Robin's long range techniques. She would joined at end of Dressrosa arc, and became part of Luffy's group in WCI to get her fleshed out more.

@RayanOO @Berry Rich @BattalGazi @garciajulieen @JoNdule @Sentinel @Buusatan94 @Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier @Logiko @TheAncientCenturion @Kizaruber Eats @Mr. Reloaded @Kurozumi Wiwi @Yoho etc.
 
#7
Coolest mf in town

woudl have been a dope SH


Post automatically merged:

Had great relationships with Sanji and with Brook in WCI

Also met Roger etc when he was young

perfect candidate
Best designed among entire minkmen / fishmen / merfolk
Also better designed than Franky and Brook, both pre TS or post TS
Had quirk - ✅️
Lost someone in the past (Zippo) - ✅️
Had dream related to Dawn of the world - ✅️
Would fill a role as Lookout - ✅️
Kinda unique fighting style: electro, once in a month Sulong, can fly using his tail like helicopter

Carrot but I guess Oda replaced her with Bonney :josad:
Why? If you want a younger sibling figure in the crew there is always Chopper
Post automatically merged:


His moment to "shine" = shine in explosion literally :josad:
 

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
#12
Best designed among entire minkmen / fishmen / merfolk
Also better designed than Franky and Brook, both pre TS or post TS
Had quirk - ✅️
Lost someone in the past (Zippo) - ✅️
Had dream related to Dawn of the world - ✅️
Would fill a role as Lookout - ✅️
Kinda unique fighting style: electro, once in a month Sulong, can fly using his tail like helicopter


Why? If you want a younger sibling figure in the crew there is always Chopper
Post automatically merged:


His moment to "shine" = shine in explosion literally :josad:
Yeah Pedro was the best by far

And his quirk moments weren’t forced like I feel it is forced with Jimbe. Pedro is serious but he is not boring like Jimbo.

Would be a perfect straw hats

 
#13
Among the candidates that looked like they had chance to join the crew but ended up did not, who did you wish the most?

- Monet
The most popular candidate during Punk Hazard arc.
Snow logia.
Possible role: Astronomer.

- Mera Mera Rebecca
Most popular candidate during Dressrosa arc
Fire logia
Already had long flashback and lost her mom in the flashback, the usual next nakama style
Possible role: Gladiator (?)

Carrot
Favorite candidate by One Piece kids in Zou and WCI arc
Bunny
Possible role: Lookout Novice

Pedro of The Treetop
Favorite candidate by One Piece men in Zou and WCI arc
Jaguar
Stronger and better design than Carrot
Possible role: Real Lookout

Pudding
Another kinda popular candidate in WCI arc
Possible role: Secondary Cook

Yamato
Most popular candidate during Onigashima arc / Wano act 3
Possible role: Cosplayer

Or anyone else?

My pick would be Pedro. Very good design, best designed half man half animal in the series. Likeable personality. No bullshit, he attacked Baron Tamago in the middle of his transformation instead of the usual dumb way of manga character doing nothing until the enemy finishes his transformation.
Has potential to kick Jinbe out of Monster Trio (electro vs fishman). Unrevealed Sulong. I would write Big Mom restoring his 50 years of lifespan when she got KO-ed. Had little quirk of staying in the highest place and quickly resorted to violence when he captured Pudding, just like each Straw Hats have their own little quirk. He would made his debut in Zou, became trial member in WCI, and officially joined in end of Wano arc, together with Jinbe.

Second choice would be Rebecca, but don't make her as total fodder like she actually is. She could stall Doflamingo with her new power of Mera Mera just like when Yamato stalled Kaido in Rooftop, until Luffy came and save the day. With her gladiator fighting style, she would be more melee oriented compared to Nami and Robin's long range techniques. She would joined at end of Dressrosa arc, and became part of Luffy's group in WCI to get her fleshed out more.

@RayanOO @Berry Rich @BattalGazi @garciajulieen @JoNdule @Sentinel @Buusatan94 @Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier @Logiko @TheAncientCenturion @Kizaruber Eats @Mr. Reloaded @Kurozumi Wiwi @Yoho etc.
Well...

:kayneshrug:
 
#14
Yeah Pedro was the best by far

And his quirk moments weren’t forced like I feel it is forced with Jimbe. Pedro is serious but he is not boring like Jimbo.

Would be a perfect straw hats

What is Jinbe's quirk again? Naming the operation?
I forget if he ever does it again after that 1 time in Fishman Island..
Jinbe is not boring tho, he is 1 of less annoying of the Straw Hats if they were real characters

Imagine living with Luffy the dumbass that ate all your food, Sanji the dangerous pervert with nosebleed or Usopp that can't stop yapping about his lies although everyone but Luffy and Chopper knows he is lying.
Jinbe is more tolerable
 
#20
Imo rebecca was the best addition with her abilities.

SH's would save so much time if she was around because half of the SH are running in the BG either lost or not knowing where others are or looking for something.
 
Top