Character Discussion Who should have joined the crew?
- Thread starter Topi Jerami
- Start date
Best designed among entire minkmen / fishmen / merfolk
Also better designed than Franky and Brook, both pre TS or post TS
Had quirk - ✅️
Lost someone in the past (Zippo) - ✅️
Had dream related to Dawn of the world - ✅️
Would fill a role as Lookout - ✅️
Kinda unique fighting style: electro, once in a month Sulong, can fly using his tail like helicopter
Why? If you want a younger sibling figure in the crew there is always Chopper
[automerge]1733477859[/automerge]
His moment to "shine" = shine in explosion literally
Also better designed than Franky and Brook, both pre TS or post TS
Had quirk - ✅️
Lost someone in the past (Zippo) - ✅️
Had dream related to Dawn of the world - ✅️
Would fill a role as Lookout - ✅️
Kinda unique fighting style: electro, once in a month Sulong, can fly using his tail like helicopter
Why? If you want a younger sibling figure in the crew there is always Chopper
[automerge]1733477859[/automerge]
His moment to "shine" = shine in explosion literally
Yamato as a character became pointless when she didn’t join. I’d rather have her than Brook, Jinbe or Chopper.
Caesar Clown was someone I rooted for as a future nakama in Tottoland arc. He had a fun and new dynamic with some of the core crew members, whereas Brook/jinbe barely have any on screen chemistry.
Caesar Clown was someone I rooted for as a future nakama in Tottoland arc. He had a fun and new dynamic with some of the core crew members, whereas Brook/jinbe barely have any on screen chemistry.
I gotta go with my Girl the Little homie Rebecca her with the Mera Mera would of been dangerous
First of all, I would like to praise the well disguised jabs at several characters. 
Second, while Pedro has his qualities as a no-BS badass, he is way too similar to Lucci, design-wise.
I wouldn't have minded if any of the Monet, Carrot and Yamato joined.
Not overpowered logia among Strawhats would be nice.
Speed-based mink ain't bad at all but in a way too similar to Chopper, combat-wise.
Cosplayer has great potential for gags.
However, I would trade all 3 of them for Wyper.
A badass like that with unique combat style would have been a feast for the eyes in each fight.
Second, while Pedro has his qualities as a no-BS badass, he is way too similar to Lucci, design-wise.
I wouldn't have minded if any of the Monet, Carrot and Yamato joined.
Not overpowered logia among Strawhats would be nice.
Speed-based mink ain't bad at all but in a way too similar to Chopper, combat-wise.
Cosplayer has great potential for gags.
However, I would trade all 3 of them for Wyper.
A badass like that with unique combat style would have been a feast for the eyes in each fight.
The Yeti Cool brothers
If you look at the Yeti cool brother Rock he has a face that resembles Shanks he could be his brother which means he's a celestial dragon/half yeti he could bring lots of amazing things to the sh crew it's also possible he has conqueror's haki it's sad that Oda will probably never explore it tho
If you look at the Yeti cool brother Rock he has a face that resembles Shanks he could be his brother which means he's a celestial dragon/half yeti he could bring lots of amazing things to the sh crew it's also possible he has conqueror's haki it's sad that Oda will probably never explore it tho
- Pedro
- Wyper
- Monet
- Kyros
- Gaimon
I am holding on to the possibility of Pedro returning.
- No corpse
- Unseen Sulong form
- Fits Ship Guard position
- Has a bounty
- Interactions with multiple crewmates
- Could be eyepatch character
Last edited: