Chapter Discussion One Piece Chapter 1139 : “The Mountain Eater”

[Julius]

Official shueisha mangaplus spanish

Ese hombre estaba a la par con silvers Rayleigh

Es una estrella legendaria que estaba a la par con Roger y Rayleigh!!


Official French shueisha mangaplus version

De meme que le vice captaine silvers Rayleigh

C'etait une figure legendaire de la piraterie, au même titre que Roger et Rayleigh

Portuguese translation says "on par with" btw

 

[HA001]

he clapped Ace ass fairly
It was implied that him scarring Shanks the first time was fair and he didn't caught Shanks off guard

He's was a lot stronger than ace.

 

[kekaro]

Tbh, neither old or new translation change anything


Roger > Ray > Gaban will always remain a thing

Luffy > Zoro > sanji will always remain a thing.


For me, last chapter only showed that the gap between them won't be that big by the EoS but that doesn't mean crew dynamics would change

Thats not agenda way @Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier made you soft

 

[Reborn]

Official shueisha mangaplus spanish

Ese hombre estaba a la par con silvers Rayleigh

Es una estrella legendaria que estaba a la par con Roger y Rayleigh!!


Official French shueisha mangaplus version

De meme que le vice captaine silvers Rayleigh

C'etait une figure legendaire de la piraterie, au même titre que Roger et Rayleigh

It says Gaban is a legendary figure like Ray and Roger

 

[[No Name]]

Portuguese translation says "on par with" btw

Yep that's just like the Number 2-3 situation, where the English suggested it was talking about X-Dra instead of Sanji while other languages were right.

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

Now, let's tag the clown circus of this forum:
@Elder Lee Hung @MarineHQ @Tyki_Mikk @Sir Yasheen @Kurozumi Wiwi @DarkWitch @NAMELESS @kekaro etc etc...

Oh I see the point you’re trying to make lmfao.

This is the Viz:

 

[Garp the Fist]

Comparing a silver medalist crew to the pirate king crew

Power scaling brain rot if you think comparing different crews structures means comparing different crews strength.

 

[Pringles]

Official shueisha mangaplus spanish

Ese hombre estaba a la par con silvers Rayleigh

Es una estrella legendaria que estaba a la par con Roger y Rayleigh!!


Official French shueisha mangaplus version

De meme que le vice captaine silvers Rayleigh

C'etait une figure legendaire de la piraterie, au même titre que Roger et Rayleigh

I speak both languages and this is literally the same meaning like the English chapter.

 

[kekaro]

Jumped them

So did the SHs many opponents like as recently as in egghead
I dont disagree with you they can pull some shit against RHP but that they always stack unfair advantages is just cope

That law situation is actually a crazy risk, they could even brought 2 others members at minimum who were free

 

[Roo]

When did that happen?

Literally that second panel is Kaido being condescending to Luffy, Oda even drew him looking down on Luffy

It does not matter because he is far more credible than the hopes & wishes of fans, being a Yonko, a pirate at the top of the food chain & among the 4 closest to the One Piece for decades.

The Yonko, more specifically Kaido and Big Mom are failures. You are being mistaken when you take their words for gospel. No matter how strong they are, their words mean shit because they couldn't achieve their potential

And it's not like he doesn't know about DF Awakenings either, in fact he's the most knowledgeable one regarding it.

It doesn't matter if he knows, its the fact that he lacks it.

Kaido's argument only falls apart when you bring up an example of how a non-CoC user with DF Awakening ended up surpassing the Yonko & Admirals to rule the seas. There are zero characters like that.

The cope that there is no difference between a CoC user & a non-CoC user ended long ago in Wano when CoC started being weaponized.
It definitely matters, ESPECIALLY at the top tier level where the CoC users can weaponize it.

Again, from a thematic standpoint DREAMPOWER will never be surpassed by willpower in a story about DREAMS. People need to take off the powerscaling glasses and view it from a literal standpoint.

Kaido is not a good guy, authors almost never speak through villains. In fact most of the times villains are supposed to be unreliable narrators.

Yeah no else commented about something else

If you can point out who else made a comment then go ahead

 

[SakazOuki]

Rayleigh > Gaban
Gaban doesn’t have to be as strong as the two to be part of the main group
He was much closer to them than the 4th strong guy
There’s really nothing that says they are dead equal in strength, not this chapter nor 1000 chapters of canon
Standing shoulder to shoulder, King Roger, his strong right arm and firstmate, partner since day one Rayleigh, and his left arm and brain, Gaban

 

[[No Name]]

It's the end Gaban haters. See you in next weeks when you will leeach off gaban feats just like you do with that fraudolent Mihawk.

 

[Albino 👑]

Yeah i remember when King and Queen was grouped with kaido together, blud is trying to gaslight us reading @Albino 👑 piece

They are the same way Marco and jozu are also paired up with emperorbeard

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Same as we knew:
The three were on the same level but Roger > Rayleigh > Gaban; with all of them >> Oden.

 

[zenox]

Why it less hype if you just demonstrated he talks about him with shanks in the same sentence?

hmm? what is less hype ?

 

[kekaro]

If you can point out who else made a comment then go ahead

Maybe im unclear
What im saying they were 2 haki abilities were shown that chapter, and only one got commented

 

[Punishhh]

I speak both languages and this is literally the same meaning like the English chapter.

No it's not lmao, Spanish version is just like TCB same with Portugues

 

[U c 4 up da idly]

Power scaling brain rot if you think comparing different crews structures means comparing different crews strength.

Your post about strength comparing calamities dynamic to the pirate king crew? It's a fact that Kaido is head and shoulders above his commanders just like the big mom pirates while this is not the case for the Roger pirates as shown in the chapter.

 

[L57]

Same as we knew:
The three were on the same level but Roger > Rayleigh > Gaban; with all of them >> Oden.

Oden was also stated to stand shoulder with roger wb

 

[[No Name]]

No it's not lmao, Spanish version is just like TCB same with Portugues

Yeah spanish states Gaban is on par with Rayleigh.