Melotonin : her whole posts didn't have much in it : the only post that was vaguely useful was this one :
Except that her 20 posts here have barely nothing valuable. Not a good look.
Light : except the beginning of the games he made only 4 posts and those ones were to defend himself againts Fuji fluffing charge.
So we don't have much to judge him.
Queen : hadn't said anything except the beginning of the game, so we cannot judge her.
Same for Flower.
Same for Ali.
Trismegistus : not a lot of posts but 1 that might be interesting :
This one, she barely caught up with the thread but she was already answering people question and gave the reads she had. Good look in my book.
Neutral watcher : the fact that he was trying to play seriously since the beginning can be a good thing but I don't want to put too much thought into that. Early fluff is not bad at all and early seriousness is not a town credibity too.
This was obviously a joke, and you were a bit too defensive.
Once again I don't think the early fluff and the one who called it out can give us town read.
Now your first reads :
I think Melon post was weird I don't think this post and this is her only post that meant something cleared her.
TAC Light and Zara saying stop to fluff is not a holy thing.
Why do you think Reborn is weird ?
I don't like how you portrayed yourself has an easy or weak target...
and you saying that you have weak powers is not good too.
Don't a fan of this first read.
then again the victim card : why do you think you will die tonight ?
Don't think so. If you are a real townie go back to you old meta please.
Again...
Now your full read : nothing bad from those read it is still the beginning of the game so okay to have average reads and don't be sure.
The point that is interesting is about Poison. Her first vote againts you was clearly a joke. But I need to check Poison posts too.
All in all something is a bit off here.
Now we are getting into players that talked much more :
Yo Tan Wa : he begins his game by a color list but he became serious after that so no problem for me.
After he caugh up to the thread he gave his reads : good points : his read of NW is good for me, he saw something special and called it and asked NW to explain. The rest was okayish but to be fair we don't have a lot of material.
Reborn not ending the early fluff is not really a bad point for him, it's not his job and he had maybe other things to do. And this is a 48h day phase so we can have 1h of early fluff.
Then you came up with your second full reads.
I agree that usual play or usual things are easy way sometimes to get yourself out of suss and lurk but here i think TAC and Light comments about Queen were genuine. I don't think this is some buddying or protecting of Queen it would be too obvious. She is not town cleared at all but her early inactivity is not suss for now.
After that you kept focusing on NW, and I think it's okay you had some doubts about his gameplay so it's fair to focus on him.
The moment you put some votes even weird ones people have rights to call you out for them.
Good to know ^^. With that claim I think you can understand why people can call you out for inconsistencies.
All in all seems pretty town to me. Especially his behaviour with Neutral.
