Character Discussion Top 5 worst written characters

[GeneralP123]

People are now calling things we see in the manga itself headcanon, we've lost the plot badly lately.

I guess it's hard to make a conclusion based on pictures and dialogue, you have to be spoon fed otherwise it will be called out as "unexplained"

 

[[No Name]]

1. Ace

 

[Roo]

I guess it's hard to make a conclusion based on pictures and dialogue, you have to be spoon fed otherwise it will be called out as "unexplained"

“Spoon fed”

Mfer literally got something wrong because he made an assumption and here you are talking about spoon feeding. Clearly the images and dialogue don’t give enough

 

[Rurushu]

1. Oden
2. Garp
3. Yamato
4. Kaido
5. Sabo

 

[Sir Yasheen]

1. Oden
2. Garp
3. Yamato
4. Kaido
5. Sabo

Garps not badly written. He’s just an ass

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Garps not badly written. He’s just an ass

Outside of hitting young ASL trio he did nothing wrong

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Outside of hitting young ASL trio he did nothing wrong

By ass I mean selfish. He understands the evil of the CDs and chooses to work to strengthen their influence so long as he personally doesn’t have to do the CDs bidding. The God Valley incident is the perfect example, Garp knew what was going on and he didn’t give a shit until his personal rival showed up.

That’s more what I mean. Garps not a bad person, he’s just selfish with his justice. Hence it’s literal term “my justice.”

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

By ass I mean selfish. He understands the evil of the CDs and chooses to work to strengthen their influence so long as he personally doesn’t have to do the CDs bidding. The God Valley incident is the perfect example, Garp knew what was going on and he didn’t give a shit until his personal rival showed up.

That’s more what I mean. Garps not a bad person, he’s just selfish with his justice. Hence it’s literal term “my justice.”

Isn't the God Valley incident proving my point? He heard Rocks was about to maul the CDs and just went "Fuck around and find out lmao", he only cared when he heard he had a chance to beat Roger there.
I don't think he protects the CDs, at least not willingly.
[automerge]1750774650[/automerge]

“Spoon fed”

Mfer literally got something wrong because he made an assumption and here you are talking about spoon feeding. Clearly the images and dialogue don’t give enough

I feel that you don't get told that you're wrong enough and that leads to these types of arguments

 

[GeneralP123]

“Spoon fed”

Mfer literally got something wrong because he made an assumption and here you are talking about spoon feeding. Clearly the images and dialogue don’t give enough

Maybe not to you, they give more than enough to 99.999% of the other readers tho

 

[Roo]

Maybe not to you, they give more than enough to 99.999% of the other readers tho

Funny you say that, most people here think he sucks and I actually asked a Kaido fan if I was being too harsh and they agreed with me lol

if anything I’d say we are in the 99% and you guys lives in headcanon land.
[automerge]1750775045[/automerge]

I feel that you don't get told that you're wrong enough and that leads to these types of arguments

When I have people whose opinion I respect agreeing with me? No. I don’t take yours seriously

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Funny you say that, most people here think he sucks and I actually asked a Kaido fan if I was being too harsh and they agreed with me lol

if anything I’d say we are in the 99% and you guys lives in headcanon land.

He said "of the other readers" which implies he meant the readers in general and not just the people here
I think a fair amount of this fandom likes Kaido despite his flaws

 

[Roo]

He said "of the other readers" which implies he meant the readers in general and not just the people here
I think a fair amount of this fandom likes Kaido despite his flaws

Kaido doesn’t even crack the top 50 in the popularity poll and he gets constantly shitted on by the YouTube community. Where exactly is this super majority? Apparently Chinese readers also hate wano lmao

 

[GeneralP123]

Funny you say that, most people here think he sucks and I actually asked a Kaido fan if I was being too harsh and they agreed with me lol

if anything I’d say we are in the 99% and you guys lives in headcanon land.
[automerge]1750775045[/automerge]

When I have people whose opinion I respect agreeing with me? No. I don’t take yours seriously

Well worstgen is a unique forum, it's a One Piece forum and yet it's members on average hate One Piece more than any other manga, but worstgen members aren't even 0.001% of all One Piece fans.

Kaido had a short backstory, that doesn't mean it didn't explain anything, in fact it very precisely showed why Kaido values strength and power above anything else, you act like the only way to understand Kaido as a character is if you have 50 pages of the narrator talking about Kaido.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Kaido doesn’t even crack the top 50 in the popularity poll and he gets constantly shitted on by the YouTube community. Where exactly is this super majority? Apparently Chinese readers also hate wano lmao

Popularity polls differentiate a lot depending on the arc
Loki is probably top 10 or 5 on them right now
Not that he doesn't deserve it since he's a great character but you get my point

 

[Roo]

Well worstgen is a unique forum, it's a One Piece forum and yet it's members on average hate One Piece more than any other manga, but worstgen members aren't even 0.001% of all One Piece fans.

Kaido had a short backstory, that doesn't mean it didn't explain anything, in fact it very precisely showed why Kaido values strength and power above anything else, you act like the only way to understand Kaido as a character is if you have 50 pages of the narrator talking about Kaido.

My guy, is not only Worstgen. he’s not popular, YouTubers hate him and apparently he’s also not liked in the east either.

you can’t appeal to this mythical majority and show 0 proof. If anything I have more evidence that he’s mid

Popularity polls differentiate a lot depending on the arc
Loki is probably top 10 or 5 on them right now
Not that he doesn't deserve it since he's a great character but you get my point

The popularity poll was during Wano?

 

[DarkWitch]

Funny you say that, most people here think he sucks and I actually asked a Kaido fan if I was being too harsh and they agreed with me lol

if anything I’d say we are in the 99% and you guys lives in headcanon land.
[automerge]1750775045[/automerge]

When I have people whose opinion I respect agreeing with me? No. I don’t take yours seriously

I can understand trying to defend Kaido in terms of power level arguments, but when it comes to actual character writing and being a good villain, that is a whole different story.

I've seen some heavily defend Kaido when it comes to power level, but at the same time still acknowledge how badly written Kaido was.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

My guy, is not only Worstgen. he’s not popular, YouTubers hate him and apparently he’s also not liked in the east either.

you can’t appeal to this mythical majority and show 0 proof. If anything I have more evidence that he’s mid



The popularity poll was during Wano?

If it was and it really didn't show Kaido then that's very strange lol

 

[GeneralP123]

Popularity polls differentiate a lot depending on the arc
Loki is probably top 10 or 5 on them right now
Not that he doesn't deserve it since he's a great character but you get my point

Unfortunately good guys even generic and uninteresting will on average beat villains in popularity polls, Carrot being in the top 8 is a prime example why polls shouldn't be taken seriously

 

[Roo]

I can understand trying to defend Kaido in terms of power level arguments, but when it comes to actual character writing and being a good villain, that is a whole different story.

I've seen some heavily defend Kaido when it comes to power level, but at the same time still acknowledge how badly written Kaido was.

Dudes here are literally making up headcanon and then calling us crazy for expecting more. “Spoon feeding” LMAO

Like do yourselves a favor and read Doffy’s backstory. Not even include Law, just the portion that’s dedicated to him. It’s only like 5 pages long but it tells us a lot about him
[automerge]1750775711[/automerge]

If it was and it really didn't show Kaido then that's very strange lol

It’s almost as if he’s trash and not memorable outside of battle scenes

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Kaido and Big Mom were not well written villains. Hell they genuinely didn’t even feel like they were planned based on how disappointing both were.

The best written yonko are buggy and Blackbeard. Those two have still been some of odas best work and I’m sure shanks still also be up there once oda gives him more focus. Just knowing shanks is living a life he didn’t want is interesting so hopefully Oda expands more on that.