General & Others Was WCI one of the best arcs of One Piece?

[Light D Lamperouge]

Due to the "discussion" I had with @True God Moe , I decided to make this thread. Moe believes that WCI was one of the best overall arcs in One Piece

Nah, actually many see it one of best arc in not just NW, but overall.

So what do you guys think? Is it one of the best arcs of One Piece? Like is it in the top 5 arcs of One Piece?

Share your thoughts and vote in the poll as well.


Some tags:
@True God Moe @nik87 @Cyrus the Cactus @Topi Jerami @TheAncientCenturion @HA001 @ZoroGang @KiriNigiri @Admiral Lee Hung @stormylife @Zowo @Chrono @Kuroshika @Sentinel @Owl Ki @Dark Hound @Jiihad @Yo Tan Wa @Reborn @Sade @playa4321 @Bogard @King7 @Arara @ShishioIsBack @ShadyOjiro @Rivaille @Bakura @BossYimz etc. etc..

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

Might be a controversial opinion, but I think WCI had a lot of awesome parts like LvK, Jinbe, the Big Mom Pirates etc

But also had a lot of complete shit like everything with Sanji and the Vinesmokes.

I just think WCI is a mixed arc. As much awesome stuff as there is complete crap.

 

[nik87]

It is one of the worst arcs, if there was no Katakuri, it would have been a disaster. :sanok:

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Please don't be too toxic about the arc guys. Doing this preemptively before the Sanji flame war, the Katakuri fanboy train, or the Big Mom upplay/downplay takes effect.

To be brief, didn't like most of it. The overall landscape and fantastic environment was too much ,like Thriller Bark. Didn't find Linlin as compelling, but we did get Capone, Reiju, Gastino and Perospero out of the arc. All cool characters. I'd say it's not a miserable arc, one I'll reread someday, but not the highlight of Post-TS for me.

Top 5 arcs? Def not.

1. Baroque Works
2. Arlong Park
3. Skypeia
4. Ennis Lobby / Water-7
5. Dressrosa

Tottoland doesn't come close.

 

[ZoroGang]

Whole cake island was pretty bad bro . Literally been following one piece weekly since I was 15 but I stopped during whole cake came back at wano and re read wci but it’s still boring with a few highlights here and there.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

You should tag @Den_Den_Mushi, I know he probably has a thought or two on Tottoland.

It is one of the worst arcs, if there was no Katakuri, it would have been a disaster. :sanok:

Katakuri helped make the arc a disaster.

 

[HA001]

Trash bar baeju.
Had meme chasing fucking cake all arc
Flampe
Countless stupid decisions.
Kata falling in love

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

It is one of the worst arcs, if there was no Katakuri, it would have been a disaster. :sanok:

Whole cake island was pretty bad bro . Literally been following one piece weekly since I was 15 but I stopped during whole cake came back at wano and re read wci but it’s still boring with a few highlights here and there.

Please don't be too toxic about the arc guys. Doing this preemptively before the Sanji flame war, the Katakuri fanboy train, or the Big Mom upplay/downplay takes effect.

To be brief, didn't like most of it. The overall landscape and fantastic environment was too much ,like Thriller Bark. Didn't find Linlin as compelling, but we did get Capone, Reiju, Gastino and Perospero out of the arc. All cool characters. I'd say it's not a miserable arc, one I'll reread someday, but not the highlight of Post-TS for me.

Top 5 arcs? Def not.

1. Baroque Works
2. Arlong Park
3. Skypeia
4. Ennis Lobby / Water-7
5. Dressrosa

Tottoland doesn't come close.

Vote in the poll as well.

Thank you.



I am not the one pushing the poll is always correct, but since Moe says the majority thinks it is, I have to ask you to vote in the poll.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Vote in the poll as well.

Thank you.



I am not the one pushing the poll is always correct, but since Moe says the majority thinks it is, I have to ask you to vote in the poll.

Can we get some extra options like "Top 5" or "Bottom 5" or even just "Average" alongside those presented?

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Can we get some extra options like "Top 5" or "Bottom 5" or even just "Average" alongside those presented?

I would not do it since the discussion is if it is one of the best overall arcs. A clear answer like yes or no should be sufficient.

But if you feel that the poll needs it, I guess you can add it.

 

[Beerbottle]

No.. It wasn't, not even close. Sorry

 

[Zenos7]

Due to the "discussion" I had with @True God Moe , I decided to make this thread. Moe believes that WCI was one of the best overall arcs in One Piece



So what do you guys think? Is it one of the best arcs of One Piece? Like is it in the top 5 arcs of One Piece?

Share your thoughts and vote in the poll as well.


Some tags:
@True God Moe @nik87 @Cyrus the Cactus @Topi Jerami @TheAncientCenturion @HA001 @ZoroGang @KiriNigiri @Admiral Lee Hung @stormylife @Zowo @Chrono @Kuroshika @Sentinel @Owl Ki @Dark Hound @Jiihad @Yo Tan Wa @Reborn @Sade @playa4321 @Bogard @King7 @Arara @ShishioIsBack @ShadyOjiro @Rivaille @Bakura @BossYimz etc. etc..

well, not for me. i do have some friends who would agree with moe though, one who even got interested in op again because of wci.

 

[nik87]

You should tag @Den_Den_Mushi, I know he probably has a thought or two on Tottoland.

Katakuri helped make the arc a disaster.

He was the only capable guy in the entire arc, a guy who stole the show from a Yonko and a guy who was a better Luffy in every way.
On the other hand we had BM chase, Puddings mind mess, Vinsmoke failures...
If not Katakuri, what made the arc bearable?

 

[stormylife]

The worst arc . aside from characters , plot was just too shit . still better than udon tho. it is good that udon wasnt an arc

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

well, not for me. i do have some friends who would agree with moe though, one who even got interested in op again because of wci.

I can understand that people like it etc, but objectively speaking it is not one of the best arcs, not even close.

 

[ZoroGang]

Whole cake island was pretty bad bro . Literally been following one piece weekly since I was 15 but I stopped during whole cake came back at wano and re read wci but it’s still boring with a few highlights here and there.

Wish I could write no twice

 

[Beerbottle]

He was the only capable guy in the entire arc, a guy who stole the show from a Yonko and a guy who was a better Luffy in every way.

Katakuri was for the most part, a cool, dependable, competent foe. His motivations for suddenly changing, and dropping part of his obsession with protecting his family, made no sense to me. And marred his character

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

He was the only capable guy in the entire arc, a guy who stole the show from a Yonko and a guy who was a better Luffy in every way.
On the other hand we had BM chase, Puddings mind mess, Vinsmoke failures...
If not Katakuri, what made the arc bearable?

I'd argue Perospero was just as if not more capable. Masterfully subdued the enemies multiple times, took initiative, saved the crew and redirected Big Mom's rampages. Even gave Linlin a candy slug to move. After being suicide bombed, delimbed, and threatened with death if a cake wasn't made soon (an impossible objective that only a master chef like Sanji could accomplish), he remained at Linlin's side.

Perospero is the MVP of the Big Mom pirates, quite frankly.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

I would say NO.

WCI definitely has one of the best starts in One piece and i absolutely love it until the Tamate Baka explosion, everything till the enf of Tea Party was great, it was pure mess after that.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

@Den_Den_Mushi

TAC says you gotta a lot to say, we need more opinions here, so feel free to share yours.