General & Others Which swordsman gave that scar to Whitebeard? It wasn't Fraud Garling confirmed

[Boiroy]

I think while watching Mihawk vs Shanks duel, WB got hurt

 

[milluki]

Roger

 

[Boiroy]

Roger

 

[Orojackson Refugee]

Vista landed a hit on WB. WB then begged Vista to spare him and promised to give a commander position (free salary). Vista decided to postpone WB's life

 

[MonsterKaido]

Roger.

 

[D. Plant]

Used to think it was Garling but now it's Roger.

 

[Paperchampion23]

We literally see Whitebeard with no scars 28 years ago. Why was this ever a theory?

 

[Rumble]

Anyone who ever thought it wasn't Roger shouldn't be allowed to vote in elections or sit on juries.

 

[Luffy is the mc]

We literally see Whitebeard with no scars 28 years ago. Why was this ever a theory?

Because some people convinced themselves that Shanks' father somehow was stronger than the WSM.

 

[Roronoa-sama]

 

[nik87]

The best bet is still Garling.
It is simply logical.
And has nothing to do with power levels.

 

[Shiroyru]

We literally see Whitebeard with no scars 28 years ago. Why was this ever a theory?

I’ve said this like 71929 times, but everyone just ignored this. I guess they just assumed Oda would retcon Oden FB Whitebeard not having his scars.

Could Shamrock have been the one to scar WB?

 

[Shiroyru]

Anyone who ever thought it wasn't Roger shouldn't be allowed to vote in elections or sit on juries.

They had their final fight in the Oden FB, and WB emerged from that battle scar-free, so…

 

[mly90]

It's Mihawk it's why he calls his duels with shanks legendary

 

[Shyneseru]

Nothing’s confirmed Garling might still be looking for his son post Godvalley. Mafey can confirm he's alive and someone kidnapped him.

 

[Wizak08]

Either Oda completely forgot the draw the scars on WB during his last meeting with Roger and thus Roger was the one who did it or it's a member of Shanks family.

 

[Djordje]

Read this dumb cunt

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/for...arling-gave-whitebeard-a-scar-nonsense.73452/

 

[GodofDarkness]

We literally see Whitebeard with no scars 28 years ago. Why was this ever a theory?

People thought Oda would retcon it

 

[JDragon20]

Holy shit Oda has been retconing shit from fucking Wano and you dudes are still bringing up this Enies lobby era theory?

 

[MasterD]

Roger probably