General & Others Unpopular Opinions?

[Finalbeta]

Brook's guitar is ugly.

Mihawk's cooking skills stand above Sanji's

 

[Ravagerblade]

Mihawk's cooking skills stand above Sanji's

 

[januarysdaughter]

I found Katakuri to be overrated and the fight with Luffy was too long.

 

[ranady]

Even without distraction, kizaru would still defeat Marco high diff and aokiji would comfortably beat jozu mid diff

 

[ask-oven]

I found Katakuri to be overrated and the fight with Luffy was too long.

Agreed he's one of my least favorite Charlottes
Also I like his original design better

 

[Khing]

power scaling is useless

 

[ranady]

power scaling is useless

It's not useless for ones who like to discuss about who Vs who and character's power level:cheers:

 

[Dettles]

Fishman Island is the best arc since the timeskip.

 

[Finalbeta]

Fishman Island is the best arc since the timeskip.

This might be not far from reality at all lmao

Expecially when we consider all Strawhats had a fight IIRC

 

[Ravagerblade]

This might be not far from reality at all lmao

Expecially when we consider all Strawhats had a fight IIRC

FI still sucked ass.

 

[Monster Luffy]

Contrary to popular take, WCI and skypiea are one of the best arcs in One Piece

 

[Rekien]

Contrary to popular take, WCI and skypiea are one of the best arcs in One Piece

While i disagree with WCI, in my oppinion its the worst arc by far, i agree on skypea, the comedy there was gold.

 

[Buusatan94]

Neither Carrot or Yamato will join the Straw Hat Pirates.

 

[Steven]

Yamato is annoying and uninteresting

 

[ask-oven]

Yamato is annoying and uninteresting

I said it in earlier posts they're annoying because they only mimic Oden and have none of their original thoughts.
Also they're very boring because they can't make their decisions.

 

[Finalbeta]

FI still sucked ass.

You got the point.~

It was exactly it :)

 

[Finalbeta]

Ryuma is allegedly stronger than Mihawk and even Roger

Oda won't be satisfied with the notion of Zoro surpassing Mihawk and yet have these two standing above him, expecially for how much Zoro admires Ryuma's deeds

 

[Charlotte Horchata]

Many readers will never be able to properly enjoy this series because they desperately want it to be like this:

Even though it is and will always be like this:

 

[dirtyLarry]

Many readers will never be able to properly enjoy this series because they desperately want it to be like this:

Even though it is and will always be like this:

Very well said.

Imho there are two stances that one must accept. After that one can truly enjoy OP.

1) Fun has always been Oda's calling card. It's way more important to him than logic, powerscaling etc. and he writes his manga this way. He just doesn't care much about powerscaling for example. If something is fun (in his mind) and fits the plot, he will write it,no matter if there are certain logic or powerscaling problems.

2) OP is a well written shonen manga. The world building is top notch. It is nothing groundbreaking or even special on terms of storywriting though. There are quite a few shonen that are comfortably better in that department. This doesn't mean OP is bad in the slightest btw, on the contrary: It's still well written, just not what most diehard fans want it to be (a flawless masterpiece).

 

[Dr. Spook]

Rayleigh made Luffy pregnant during the timeskip.

Spoiler: proof