Aight bois let's do this. This is the most free time I've had in weeks and I'm on a Black Clover kick right now lol. I'm going to nitpick your guys lists respectfully of course. Offering some of my own opinions on everything in addition to the minor feedback I gave earlier.
Aight first off,
+Devils in God Tier. Definitely correct. I think the Devils are a tier away from everyone else in power (or at least, the high ranking Devils are. Lower ranking Devils could be beneath the stronger humans and elves).
-That said, Zagred is far too low, that's a trend I've noticed among people. This guy literally required several members of the Clover Kingdom to all gang up on him including 2 literal Wizard King level combattants to actually stop him. Lolopechka speculated that Megicula (who we all at first thought would be the strongest Demon) MIGHT be stronger than Zagred. Which speaks to how powerful Zagred actually is. Putting him 2 entire tiers beneath Megicula is disrespect. I'd put him 1 tier below at max.
-The Dark Triad are ranked on par with Julius which I think is a bit much, I don't think they've quite proven that but I can at least understand the rationale. Regardless, it feels weird to put 1 of the only 2 Wizard Kings we've ever seen "above Wizard King level." Julius very much seems to be the shining example of a Wizard King in the manga and putting him above the standard Wizard King is too much right now, just my humble opinion lol.
-Yami on par with Licht and Lumiere, not yet. Licht and Lumiere are excessively powerful, and while Yami will reach that level eventaully I think, he is not on par with them right now. That's almost like saying Lumiere or Licht 1v1 would stand no chance at defeating Dante as Yami did, when in actuality I think it's Dante and the Dark Triad who have yet to prove themselves quite on Licht's level.
-Asta and Yuno above captain level, no. The Captains are quite underrated on your tier list are very underrated, and I think best case scenario that Yuno and Asta might be above Rill but even that is pushing it. The Captains are all highly experienced monsters and Yuno and Asta are still too young.
-Noelle in high captain, again no. Maybe Vice Captain level, maybe, but I don't see her defeating any Captain 1v1.
-Secre and Vanessa in Captain Tier, again nah, I think their magics are very powerful and hax but they overall lack experience and real fighting prowess.
-Mimosa in Vice Captain, nah. She is more of a healer/support mage and I don't see her as being more powerful in a fight than any Vice Captain (I assume your list is a fighting strength tier list and not an overall usefulness in battle list or something).
Okay so this is @Marimo_420 's list:
We talked a bit about your list before but here is some more feedback:
-I would still put Lucifero and Zagred in a different tier from Lumiere. Licht and Lumiere had to gang up on Zagred to beat him alongside help with other characters including Captain level Knights. Zagred is above them in strength.
-Lumiere and Licht should be equals, that's how they've always been portrayed and if you're going to give the edge to one, it should be Licht who has the benefit of having Elven Mana levels which are greater than Lumiere's.
-Patri and Licht should also not be in the same tier. Licht is very clearly superior to him.
-Dark Elf Patri is stronger than regular Patri
-Vannica should not be beneath Zenon and Dante, sure she can use less Devil magic but I think mana level doesn't always equate to fighting strength. Yami stated multiple times that Nozel has more Mana than him but I don't think many would argue Nozel > Yami.
+Mereoleona is given the respect she deserves. Lol
-I personally think Dorothy is hella overrated from what I've seen people say about her. She's the only captain who's own magic can actually be used against her so long as you actually learn to dream up your own dreams within her dream realm. I would put her as the weakest captain right now to be quite honest.
-Putting Sekke, Noel's brother, and the Nun chick in "Civilian" tier is disrespect lol. These characters are magic knights and civilians have little to no combat ability lol. I get why you ranked them so low but each of these characters should be well stronger than most civilians lol.
-Same as the other list, the Devils are all ranked too low. I think it's clear from everything we know that Megicula, Zagred, and Lucifero appear to be the three strongest beings that we know by name. Zenon's Devil is definitely up there as well and I'm sure there are other Devils close to that power level.
-Fana is ranked too low but she did loose Salamander since she fought on par with the Clover Captains but who knows lol.
+Overall your list is not that objectionable and I largely agree with mostly every ranking you have here lol.
None of your guys' lists are bad by the way haha. Just had some free time and wanted to give my unsolicited opinions lol.
Aight first off,
+Devils in God Tier. Definitely correct. I think the Devils are a tier away from everyone else in power (or at least, the high ranking Devils are. Lower ranking Devils could be beneath the stronger humans and elves).
-That said, Zagred is far too low, that's a trend I've noticed among people. This guy literally required several members of the Clover Kingdom to all gang up on him including 2 literal Wizard King level combattants to actually stop him. Lolopechka speculated that Megicula (who we all at first thought would be the strongest Demon) MIGHT be stronger than Zagred. Which speaks to how powerful Zagred actually is. Putting him 2 entire tiers beneath Megicula is disrespect. I'd put him 1 tier below at max.
-The Dark Triad are ranked on par with Julius which I think is a bit much, I don't think they've quite proven that but I can at least understand the rationale. Regardless, it feels weird to put 1 of the only 2 Wizard Kings we've ever seen "above Wizard King level." Julius very much seems to be the shining example of a Wizard King in the manga and putting him above the standard Wizard King is too much right now, just my humble opinion lol.
-Yami on par with Licht and Lumiere, not yet. Licht and Lumiere are excessively powerful, and while Yami will reach that level eventaully I think, he is not on par with them right now. That's almost like saying Lumiere or Licht 1v1 would stand no chance at defeating Dante as Yami did, when in actuality I think it's Dante and the Dark Triad who have yet to prove themselves quite on Licht's level.
-Asta and Yuno above captain level, no. The Captains are quite underrated on your tier list are very underrated, and I think best case scenario that Yuno and Asta might be above Rill but even that is pushing it. The Captains are all highly experienced monsters and Yuno and Asta are still too young.
-Noelle in high captain, again no. Maybe Vice Captain level, maybe, but I don't see her defeating any Captain 1v1.
-Secre and Vanessa in Captain Tier, again nah, I think their magics are very powerful and hax but they overall lack experience and real fighting prowess.
-Mimosa in Vice Captain, nah. She is more of a healer/support mage and I don't see her as being more powerful in a fight than any Vice Captain (I assume your list is a fighting strength tier list and not an overall usefulness in battle list or something).
Okay so this is @Marimo_420 's list:
We talked a bit about your list before but here is some more feedback:
-I would still put Lucifero and Zagred in a different tier from Lumiere. Licht and Lumiere had to gang up on Zagred to beat him alongside help with other characters including Captain level Knights. Zagred is above them in strength.
-Lumiere and Licht should be equals, that's how they've always been portrayed and if you're going to give the edge to one, it should be Licht who has the benefit of having Elven Mana levels which are greater than Lumiere's.
-Patri and Licht should also not be in the same tier. Licht is very clearly superior to him.
-Dark Elf Patri is stronger than regular Patri
-Vannica should not be beneath Zenon and Dante, sure she can use less Devil magic but I think mana level doesn't always equate to fighting strength. Yami stated multiple times that Nozel has more Mana than him but I don't think many would argue Nozel > Yami.
+Mereoleona is given the respect she deserves. Lol
-I personally think Dorothy is hella overrated from what I've seen people say about her. She's the only captain who's own magic can actually be used against her so long as you actually learn to dream up your own dreams within her dream realm. I would put her as the weakest captain right now to be quite honest.
-Putting Sekke, Noel's brother, and the Nun chick in "Civilian" tier is disrespect lol. These characters are magic knights and civilians have little to no combat ability lol. I get why you ranked them so low but each of these characters should be well stronger than most civilians lol.
-Same as the other list, the Devils are all ranked too low. I think it's clear from everything we know that Megicula, Zagred, and Lucifero appear to be the three strongest beings that we know by name. Zenon's Devil is definitely up there as well and I'm sure there are other Devils close to that power level.
-Fana is ranked too low but she did loose Salamander since she fought on par with the Clover Captains but who knows lol.
+Overall your list is not that objectionable and I largely agree with mostly every ranking you have here lol.
None of your guys' lists are bad by the way haha. Just had some free time and wanted to give my unsolicited opinions lol.
Yooo that's why I said I'm unbiased bro. That's what the tier list would look like if I was writing the story.
I know Yami is not really at that level. I was kidding.
- But did I really put Noelle that high? I would drop her a tier.
- And yes, for me Charmy is a beast. She clapped a elf powered up Rill who was possessed by one of the "10 apostles of Seperiah". Eleves who were hyped up to be vastly stronger than the standard magic Knight captain and memebers which included the likes of the midnight sun.
I can see her be at high captain easily. Beating Charlotte tho? That's doubtful, but she would put up a high/extreme diff fight
I know Yami is not really at that level. I was kidding.
- But did I really put Noelle that high? I would drop her a tier.
- And yes, for me Charmy is a beast. She clapped a elf powered up Rill who was possessed by one of the "10 apostles of Seperiah". Eleves who were hyped up to be vastly stronger than the standard magic Knight captain and memebers which included the likes of the midnight sun.
I can see her be at high captain easily. Beating Charlotte tho? That's doubtful, but she would put up a high/extreme diff fight