[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[hime]

I'm a town desperado who shot Pero. The wording of my ability changes it from a normal desperado where I'd die if my shot fails, I'd only die if I shot someone from my own house. Pero should have died, but he didn't. This how I can confirm his ability to be unkillable.

oh this is interesting.

 

[Chevy]

@Chevy how are u confident that arp is town based on his claim? for u to say this

Are you on drugs?

I said I needed to clarify I'm town, not that I'm sure that Arp is town lmao

 

[Chevy]

The reason why @Ekkologix is that some people here seem dum- play differently to WF/WS style that I and others here are used to. The clarification was required.

 

[Emil]

Are you on drugs?

I said I needed to clarify I'm town, not that I'm sure that Arp is town lmao

why so? wouldnt saying "i am a desperado" be enough?

are u subconsciously worried that u wont be perceived as town?

 

[WakandaForever]

@WakandaForever this is a 32 player game, in comparison to the usual 15ish player games that u play, its possible for 2 townies to have some protections

is ur entire reasoning for suspecting pero the fact that hes tanky?

I missed your last part. The answer is no, ISO my previous 2-3 posts from like 2-3 hours ago, I outlined my stance on Pero and Melkor. Pero is obviously the one on the block but I would have been happy with either direction.

I'm a town desperado who shot Pero. The wording of my ability changes it from a normal desperado where I'd die if my shot fails, I'd only die if I shot someone from my own house. Pero should have died, but he didn't. This how I can confirm his ability to be unkillable.

OK that's interesting. Is daykill-immunity a thing, as opposed to general kill immunity?

 

[Michelle]

this is arps claim

he does not say "I'm a town tracker"

instead says "I'm a tracker"

where exactly do you see people saying "town" before they claim

I am using it when I claim.
Is not a rule/scum tell to use or not use town before the claim

 

[Emil]

there is a difference chevy

like saying "i am a town vig" versus saying "i am a vig"

you wont convince me otherwise. this is a subconscious thing mafia says

 

[Chevy]

why so? wouldnt saying "i am a desperado" be enough?

are u subconsciously worried that u wont be perceived as town?

When someone uses a killing action, they'll always be discussed and debated especially so upon claiming. Why wouldn't I clarify it early?

 

[Emil]

I am using it when I claim.
Is not a rule/scum tell to use or not use town before the claim

it seemed to come from from scum than town in that context

 

[Michelle]

there is a difference chevy

like saying "i am a town vig" versus saying "i am a vig"

you wont convince me otherwise. this is a subconscious thing mafia says

Hello Ekko,
Stop pushing semantics.
Please
Thanks!

 

[Emil]

When someone uses a killing action, they'll always be discussed and debated especially so upon claiming. Why wouldn't I clarify it early?

because u shouldnt need to
if u r town, then u know u r town. the claim itself will verify u, and we will judge if u r town or not from it
none ever says "i am town vig"
what even is that

 

[Tyler Herro]

Nice try
You're scum, i see you claim it

I’m not - it was a joke.

 

[RippedCal]

there is a difference chevy

like saying "i am a town vig" versus saying "i am a vig"

you wont convince me otherwise. this is a subconscious thing mafia says

I'm fine with this being your opinion but it's not totally true

I know personally I often will read over my posts and put in clarifiers like this...as town.

I do it because it's not just a scum thing to want people to think you're town, town wants people to town read them too

 

[Chevy]

@Ekkologix fully embracing the Evans by nitpicking on something. I kind of respect it

 

[Emil]

Hello Ekko,
Stop pushing semantics.
Please
Thanks!

i wouldnt, if i didnt scum read him previously
but hes been one of my scum reads for the longest time. i will nitpick anything he says

 

[WakandaForever]

Are Pero’s and Wakanda’s role related?

I saw wakanda mentioning something about this.

Pero claimed unkillability. I am also immune to the first kill attempt on me. It seems unlikely we'd both have the same ability and both be town - at least in my opinion.

 

[Michelle]

it seemed to come from from scum than town in that context

Desperado is a town role and is probably named as such

 

[Tyler Herro]

I subscribe to Evans being legit. Grammaton/Odo hates cops and frequently has roles in its place that will verify town identity e.g. gunsmith so I can see it in this case

 

[Kagu Nyan]

Are Pero’s and Wakanda’s role related?

I saw wakanda mentioning something about this.

Can anyone answer this? The thread is moving way too fast.

 

[Chevy]

i wouldnt, if i didnt scum read him previously
but hes been one of my scum reads for the longest time. i will nitpick anything he says

Can you present your case as to why you think I'm scum?

You also didn't reply to me from what I saw when you said my explanation about Neeko/Charlie was "much better" then threw me in a scum pile?