Questions & Mysteries Did this chapter confirm that that's not Shanks?

[Blahmigooo]

What if Shanks and Pranks are both clones of Garling...

 

[notAfanboy]

he basically was a villain in film red and the entire events of the movie were his fault. he abandoned uta on an island after wiping out their entire infrastructure and destroying all the buildings and resources in a fight with a demon, stole all of their money and treasure, left the demon-summoning song on the island, and then told the single survivor "teach her to be a good singer" so she could summon the demon again. just because he came in to clean up his own mess later doesnt mean hes a good guy lol. he's never been more of a dick than in film red

Lovely

I cant recall what Shanks did to piss y'all off this much.
[automerge]1735415245[/automerge]

Making shanks a villain doesn't need balls...

That's the kind of "subverting expectations" type retarded twist that gets used in media all the time.

Even tho oda is not gonna make Shanks a villain because he's his fav, it's the correct decision. Villain shanks woulda been retarded writing

Said the same about Gojo and you know how it turned out at the end

 

[Kung-Fu Dugong]

Doesn't Shanks know where Loki is and where the underworld is?

Yeah, it's more than enough to settle it down. Shanks also usually travels using the Red Force (he was never seen using the Gorosei's teleport) and he doesn't seem to have a female crewmate too.

The giants didn't seem to recognize him either despite having the exact same appearance and even sword? Ain't nobody going to ask themselves why there's a dude looking like Shanks (making the distinction due to his scar).

Unless the other half of his face isn't really human. Wait for him to be revealed as a half cyborg.

He's wearing a hood, so the giants might not be seeing his face.

 

[Red Admiral]

I didn't watched the movie tbh. @Red Admiral was shanks written as a villain in film red?

nope
[automerge]1735427992[/automerge]

This lol

Shanks brother > who ever is you want to push his agenda

 

[Urouge D. Rouge]

yeah very likely not shanks but you never know unless you know you know but for now no one know

 

[Kiiro]

Doesn't Shanks know where Loki is and where the underworld is?

With that argument... yeah, you are right.

 

[MUUGEN]

the only people who ever been thi king it was actually Shanks have been lihawk stans

 

[Blazing Lion]

I don't understand how people believe that there is any chance of this guy being Shanks.

 

[vikas]

I don't understand how people believe that there is any chance of this guy being Shanks.

Sengoku followed his order in marineford

 

[Blazing Lion]

Sengoku followed his order in marineford

Hahahaha

 

[Reborn]

It's not shanks

Shanks was already there before he left elbaf. It doesn't make sense why he will appear again

Guards didn't recognise pranks at all

Third, and most importantly, pranks doesn't know where Loki is or how to get to the underworld where loki is.

It's shanks territory so shanks definitely knows inside out of Elbaf

 

[vikas]

Shanks was already there before he left elbaf. It doesn't make sense why he will appear again

He left and Came as Pranks....How convinient that they are never at the same place together

 

[Loki D. Terror]

It's not shanks

Shanks was already there before he left elbaf. It doesn't make sense why he will appear again

Guards didn't recognise pranks at all

Third, and most importantly, pranks doesn't know where Loki is or how to get to the underworld where loki is.

It's shanks territory so shanks definitely knows inside out of Elbaf

Is elbaph shanks's territory confirmed? Don't think this was ever confirmed. Just that they are friendly with shanks.

 

[Reborn]

Is elbaph shanks's territory confirmed? Don't think this was ever confirmed. Just that they are friendly with shanks.

Ally territory so makes sense for Shanks to know the landscape

 

[mmd]

That was a good point.
(Shanks knows where Loki is, but he whistles under his mask out of fear, entertaining himself by pretending not to know.)

 

[BlackLegFring]

Shanks brings evil or having a secret evil twin are both dumb as hell. Terrible that this is what Oda’s writing has fallen to

 

[Moegara]

the only people who ever been thi king it was actually Shanks have been lihawk stans

What's more swordsman underdog to Mihawk fans? Nah, been claiming it's his twin way before Elbaf.

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

l think he is Shanks evil twin , one of the reason I confidently say this because he appeared at end of egghead island arc as silhouette along all the other Yonkos including Shanks .

Also imagine If Shanks pops in and out from his ship why rest of red haired pirate don’t find it fishy ? Also Shanks was in another island punishing Barto there is no way he would appear in magical circle like the Goroseis .

This guy moves in circle . The circle pattern probably needs Imu’s approval as well honestly it makes no sense for Shanks possessing such power and why would Imu risk such power to a pirate ?
[automerge]1735543397[/automerge]

Sengoku followed his order in marineford

I think he respect Shanks and not because his daddy is Figarland .

 

[garciajulieen]

I personally dont like at all this Shanks twin. But seems like its confirmed.

 

[a_fan]

It makes it more convincing to me now when Whitebeard told Shanks that his face made his scar ache. It makes sense when you think how trauma works.

God Knights should be capable of fighting Yonko level based on Garling’s aura in God Valley (despite knowing Roger and Rocks were there) + making the Gorosei sweat, Dragon reference them as a threat and that mystery woman’s feat against Elbaf guards (that power seems broken af).