Le Fishe Thread Doffy vs Fujitora

Who Wins?


  • Total voters
    49
Kata is a brick wall for them since his Future Sight and amazing Armament Haki isn't something they can bullshit their way through, they can't just say "well he beat Smoker high diff!" because they know damn well Kata would beat Smoker far easier than that.

One got neg diffed by Law, the other mid diffed Law.
It's quite simple.

I didn't even know ZenZu is a Law fan, I thought he was just lying about Vergo because he has an unusual love for him despite him being a rather mediocre and bland villain
I dont think anyone actually says Vergo beats Katakuri, only he can beat weaker commanders

Doffy also jumped Law with Fujitora and Trebol, and he was messing with law psychologically. Doffy>Law>Vergo ofc, but the gaps aren't necessarily that significant.
 
I dont think anyone actually says Vergo beats Katakuri, only he can beat weaker commanders

Doffy also jumped Law with Fujitora and Trebol, and he was messing with law psychologically. Doffy>Law>Vergo ofc, but the gaps aren't necessarily that significant.
Weaker Commanders? Like who?
Cracker canonically could beat him with one biscuit soldier and Jack has way better endurance, stamina and strength feats
Post automatically merged:

Nah I'm on record saying Law got lucky Vergo didn't have intel. He thought he could face tank the room.
Haki is as strong as the user most of the time. Vergo would have been affected by any of his hax moves, even if he tried to avoid taking them head on.
 
Base Jack was beating Ashura Doji
So? Ashura is peer to Kinemon, who wanted to slice Jack up, yet pissed his pants at both Pica and Doffy.
Swords are harder to block
Unless you have Vergo's Haki, that turns a Bamboo stick into a Meito.
ACOA is harder to block
Depends entirely on the level of your Haki. This "ACoA" you talking about is just Haki extending out of your body. The Boa sisters ACoA was overpowered by pre Haki Luffy.
It took lots of ACOA sword attacks from a Sulong Duke to take him down
Jack was on first aid from one of Ashura's attacks. On the Roof Top, the Dukes one shotted him. In their rematch, Inu alone one shotted Perospero's peer.

Stop coping, Vergod beats Jack.
 
Weaker Commanders? Like who?
Cracker canonically could beat him with one biscuit soldier and Jack has way better endurance, stamina and strength feats
Post automatically merged:


Haki is as strong as the user most of the time. Vergo would have been affected by any of his hax moves, even if he tried to avoid taking them head on.
in the beast pirates? Anyone weaker than Queen
in the BMP? anyone weaker than Cracker
In the WBP? Anyone weaker than Jozu
Post automatically merged:

At the very least, Vergo doesn't lose to Who's who, someone who even cipher pol and his own subordinates didn't see being a real match to Jimbei
 
So? Ashura is peer to Kinemon, who wanted to slice Jack up, yet pissed his pants at both Pica and Doffy.

Unless you have Vergo's Haki, that turns a Bamboo stick into a Meito.

Depends entirely on the level of your Haki. This "ACoA" you talking about is just Haki extending out of your body. The Boa sisters ACoA was overpowered by pre Haki Luffy.

Jack was on first aid from one of Ashura's attacks. On the Roof Top, the Dukes one shotted him. In their rematch, Inu alone one shotted Perospero's peer.

Stop coping, Vergod beats Jack.
I don't get the bamboo staff argument since we know a weapon has to be strong enough to withstand the user's power being channeled into it
Either it's not a normal staff or Vergo's Haki is so weak that it can't break through a random wood staff he found
in the beast pirates? Anyone weaker than Queen
in the BMP? anyone weaker than Cracker
In the WBP? Anyone weaker than Jozu
Post automatically merged:

At the very least, Vergo doesn't lose to Who's who, someone who even cipher pol and his own subordinates didn't see being a real match to Jimbei
How does he beat Jack?
How does he beat Vista? Vista clashed with god tier Mihawk without losing a step, and yes obviously Mihawk wasn't trying that hard but it's still far more impressive than anything Vergo's done.
And how does he beat WsW? What feats does he have on the level of clashing equally with Jinbe's Haki and physical strength and even piercing his Armament?
 
I don't get the bamboo staff argument since we know a weapon has to be strong enough to withstand the user's power being channeled into it
Either it's not a normal staff or Vergo's Haki is so weak that it can't break through a random wood staff he found

How does he beat Jack?
How does he beat Vista? Vista clashed with god tier Mihawk without losing a step, and yes obviously Mihawk wasn't trying that hard but it's still far more impressive than anything Vergo's done.
And how does he beat WsW? What feats does he have on the level of clashing equally with Jinbe's Haki and physical strength and even piercing his Armament?
His Haki is better than Jack
Vista's rival ran away from Vergos fellow vice admirals like a bitch. Vista also has bad feats in the rest of the war, like against Akainu
Casually breaking Sanjis leg is a better feat then getting mid diffed by Jimbei
 
This is more fair fight in which vergo would dominate :finally:
Considering Zoro >= Sanji has been reestablished through Gaban, we can certainly say Oda purposely saved Zoro from meeting Vergo.

Btw, Luffy isn't saved either. Vergo is an opponent Luffy would definitely need G4 for, even if 1 round is enough.
 
Considering Zoro >= Sanji has been reestablished through Gaban, we can certainly say Oda purposely saved Zoro from meeting Vergo.

Btw, Luffy isn't saved either. Vergo is an opponent Luffy would definitely need G4 for, even if 1 round is enough.
It's possible that Zoro came out of the timeskip significantly stronger than the other two though
 
What feats does Vergo have to indicate he'd require G4 to lose?
He took Sanji's DJ to his face, twice. He easily struggled off Law's Countershock - one of his strongest attacks back then - broke Sanji's fibula with his non hardening leg. Before you say something, that isn't even Vergo's main fighting style, he's best at using his bamboo.

We can say G2 attacks won't do much to Vergo, he'll eat them quite easily. Sanji hits way harder with DJ and you can basically scale it like that: G3 >= Sanji's DJ (depends on the attack) > G2 (maybe bar Red Hawk).

Before Luffy received his next level Haki PUs, base Luffy really was weak af except great durability. Almost all of his enemies easily overpowered him. Heck, Luffy couldn't even best a single biscuit soldier. Katakuri mocked him and copying his strongest moves but stronger. Doflamingo straight up called G2 weak - he wouldn't have this reaction to Vergo's Oni Take.

So again, how do you see Vergo losing to this? Do you not think you're underrating Vergo too much or do you believe he has to be weaker than other opponents because he appeared earlier as a villain? This kind of thinking is flawed in One Piece because what Oda rather focuses at is how the characters are tied and related to the story and world. Vergo wasn't only a VA, he is one of the strongest while being secretly a spy - working for Doflamingo as his right hand man.

Furthermore, Zoro didn't take someone like Pica seriously at all - something which Zoro wouldn't do to Sanji either if he was seriously fighting him. Yet Vergo managed to break Sanji's strongest weapon - his legs. It's clear Vergo isn't an ordinary VA or vet level character. He's above that stuff.

People just need to pay extra attention to the story instead of making up bullshit powerscaling rules like "The next villain is stronger."
Heck, you guys don't like it when it's being used against Kaido and almost all other top tiers being paired against him, so keep the same energy for Doflamingo and especially Vergo because the latter was truly a freaking beast.
 
He took Sanji's DJ to his face, twice. He easily struggled off Law's Countershock - one of his strongest attacks back then - broke Sanji's fibula with his non hardening leg. Before you say something, that isn't even Vergo's main fighting style, he's best at using his bamboo.

We can say G2 attacks won't do much to Vergo, he'll eat them quite easily. Sanji hits way harder with DJ and you can basically scale it like that: G3 >= Sanji's DJ (depends on the attack) > G2 (maybe bar Red Hawk).

Before Luffy received his next level Haki PUs, base Luffy really was weak af except great durability. Almost all of his enemies easily overpowered him. Heck, Luffy couldn't even best a single biscuit soldier. Katakuri mocked him and copying his strongest moves but stronger. Doflamingo straight up called G2 weak - he wouldn't have this reaction to Vergo's Oni Take.

So again, how do you see Vergo losing to this? Do you not think you're underrating Vergo too much or do you believe he has to be weaker than other opponents because he appeared earlier as a villain? This kind of thinking is flawed in One Piece because what Oda rather focuses at is how the characters are tied and related to the story and world. Vergo wasn't only a VA, he is one of the strongest while being secretly a spy - working for Doflamingo as his right hand man.

Furthermore, Zoro didn't take someone like Pica seriously at all - something which Zoro wouldn't do to Sanji either if he was seriously fighting him. Yet Vergo managed to break Sanji's strongest weapon - his legs. It's clear Vergo isn't an ordinary VA or vet level character. He's above that stuff.

People just need to pay extra attention to the story instead of making up bullshit powerscaling rules like "The next villain is stronger."
Heck, you guys don't like it when it's being used against Kaido and almost all other top tiers being paired against him, so keep the same energy for Doflamingo and especially Vergo because the latter was truly a freaking beast.
Jesus, so much unnecessary fluff here. I almost regret asking in the first place.
How does the guy who was sent into a wall by a casual nameless DJ kick, floored by a punch from Smoker, and matched by weakened base Sanji several times tank a G2 or especially G3 punch head on?
Also didn't Doffy still bleed from base Luffy's attacks while guarding with Armament Haki? The G2 thing is more of an anomaly than anything, given that.
Furthermore, Luffy was portrayed on more or less equal footing with Law, with them allying as partners and getting the same bounties after Dressrosa as well as both of them being prominent Supernovas who are captains of their own respective crews.
The only way you can argue Luffy was definitively superior to Law back then is by using Doffy's statement about Luffy having more potential due to already unlocking Conq Haki, but that's not relevant unless he could use ACoC, which he can't.
 
Top