Controversial Explain how Saturn can still get defeated/killed

Status
Not open for further replies.
#21
First of all , Saturn not being beaten totally by Luffy (and bonney) is a bad writing.

Secondly, Saturn won't be a threat anymore
He's ruined forever

And last, This arc should just end
Don't care about his fate on who or what destroys him
 
#22
Like I said, they are linked with Imu, and till that connection is severed, they won't be fully defeated. So whoever gets to face them in 1v1 will most likely beat them back to back only for them to comeback, and it will take Luffy to somehow break that link (by beating up Imu). Only then will the Gorosei get defeated forever
 
#23
First of all , Saturn not being beaten totally by Luffy (and bonney) is a bad writing.

Secondly, Saturn won't be a threat anymore
He's ruined forever

And last, This arc should just end
Don't care about his fate on who or what destroys him
Depends on who does It.
For once that Luffy doesn't do EVERYTHING, are we complaining lol?

But overall I agree that Saturn hasn't any future from now on, and so he should die.
 
Last edited:
#25
It's a series where the author pull shit outta his ass at the last minute. Elders immortality gotta have a weakness, it's all depend if Oda wants to hint to it now.

Every arc you got people believe x antagonist cannot fall because they don't see how. I remember having discussion back in Dressrosa day because Doflamingo was considered too strong to fall against Luffy even though it was literally his base island lmao.


It doesn't seem like Saturn has any future in the story.
>all the threat factor he had in his introduction is basically gone, after getting stalled by Nami & co, he was literally treated as a training tool by Luffy for Bonney to train her punch, the difference of treatment between him and Topman that made Luffy twerk and run is night and day.
>showed us both his hybrid/awakening and full beast form, outside Nasjuro Oda only showed the full beast form of other elders (plan to do it later as they still have a role)
>Devon took his appearance
>Kuma and Bonney, main drama of the arc, got their cathartic pay off, Kuma even got to witness his daughter turn into Nika doing so
>Somehow the only elder left on Egghead and chances of him being as isolated as he is now are extremely low

I do agree that the immortality is a huge issue and this is the sole reason why I'm not 100% in Saturn (that and Straw Hats leaving the island) falling but if it wasn't for that everything is lining up for Egghead to be it for him
 
#26
First of all , Saturn not being beaten totally by Luffy (and bonney) is a bad writing.

Secondly, Saturn won't be a threat anymore
He's ruined forever

And last, This arc should just end
Don't care about his fate on who or what destroys him
As trash as he is, he still has regen. How would they even defeat him?
[automerge]1722594659[/automerge]
But yeah, there should be a narrative purpose behind Saturn alone staying back.

Maybe he can get the robot to work for the WG? He's warrior God is science after all. Bend the robot by completely rewriting his settings.
Would be a cool twist IMO
 

nik87

Kitetsu Wanker
#29
He had to regenerate a lot of damage in Egghead so his regen has to be nearing its limit.
Once limit is hit, killing him is not that hard. The question is only who gets to do it, if he dies.
And I think he should die for Devon's plan to work.
 
#30
First of all , Saturn not being beaten totally by Luffy (and bonney) is a bad writing.

Secondly, Saturn won't be a threat anymore
He's ruined forever

And last, This arc should just end
Don't care about his fate on who or what destroys him
Hahahaha

Why Saturn not beign defeated became bad writening? He is immortal duuh! Yes, he is better then Bugu Mamu and Kaido for sure. I love how deniers chose to deny even plot logic. Saturn is immortal, he wasn't defeated and wasn't even close to see death.
 
#31
I think he can't be killed if he is an extension of Imu, the most likely scenario is that Saturn kills Kizaru due to Kizaru's pathetic performance, the worst TOP TIER that has ever appeared.

However, it's strange how Luffy didn't use a single Acoc attack on Saturn, and yet he was exploding that fraud left and right.
I mentioned that he could be immortal, but I think that's just a trick, he's going to be defeated anyway, Oda making Luffy hold back against all the Gorosei and Kizaru was very explicit and as shown in the recent chapter Adcoc is really the way.
 
#33
Arc isn't over yet, that's why there is a chance Saturn dies or something happens (incident)

Who could kill Saturn?
I honestly don't care,Kizaru maybe but Oda can pull something out of his ass and do it
 
#34
Arc isn't over yet, that's why there is a chance Saturn dies or something happens (incident)

Who could kill Saturn?
I honestly don't care,Kizaru maybe but Oda can pull something out of his ass and do it
Ehhm

I don't think that Saturn will die, but Kuma can create a buble that contained whole pain of his life, which will be enough to immobileze Saturn.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
#36
If Saturn can take Nika and Bonney combo punches and that massive haki blast and is still fine as if no big deal then there is no one on egghead to damage him or beat him....


This becomes more challenging if we factor in that there is connection between elders and imu...

Only possible scenario is that of man with burn scar because we don't know shit about him and his whereabouts.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
#39
As far as the Elders are aware, all of the Vegapunks are dead, except York, they got the Mother Flame stuff, they got the Seraphims back, they stopped the transmission, and the Yonko is leaving.

0 need to chase them.
It's over.
They didn't get one thing
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top