Well to be honest... TAC doesn't look this bad to me, first reason he's to open about his intentions, second, he's not being cautious at all. Again, scum is self-aware and their most important objective is to stay alive. Therefore in the majority of games scum not going to do anything crazy or stupid things because of the fear of getting caught.
While I do not completely clear TAC but there is good chances he's a town but the fact some players taking advantage and voting for him in the moment of his weakness is making it sound like they gave up on doing anything important for the time being.
@tedxtr I know you're a man of reason. If TAC was scum, I think he'd have fed the lynch on the most seemingly suspected player who is in fact Bogard at some point to the general public, and he's not firing back at you either, instead, he's onto his targets even now which has been his unwavering stance for a while, given he's giving his reasons in his own ways. I do think he's genuine, even though i don't necessarily agree with his hasty choices.
First off, what intentions is he opened about? And I doubt that he's not cautious, given this man literally pulled a back-up plan for why he was acting scummy, it was all a plot to get a read on Bogard, and after he does, he votes for someone else. I think you're making this way too black and white in the first paragraph of this and you're basing your read based on how you think a typical mafia would approach a situation. You're describing newb scum.
What crazy thing did TAC do anyway? I don't get that part.
I mean I can't really comment on your second line, it's more of you reading my push as scummy rather than you town reading TAC and scum reading me for pushing a town here, so I'm not sure how you even want me to engage with this other than saying that's generally a bad way of approaching a read.
Third paragraph, again, you are ascribing a general perception of how scum would act, which is not exactly a good metric for evaluating someone. Think of it like this, there's no general personality to a scum player. And here, judging by your description, wouldn't that clear me as town? I haven't focused on Bogard, which you think to be universally scum read, although only 3 people said anything about him, and second, I am on my target and have had an unwavering stance. You can't help but town read me deep down :D
=========
This is my game prediction— I get lynched and am revealed to be town after all, then ya’ll will deride me for being dumb and bad town.
But by the end of the game, when Bogard is revealed to be he Godfather, you’ll all be saying; “Oh wow, I wish we listened to that clever, intelligent, handsome and funny TAC guy earlier. This could’ve been an easy victory.”
How do you know there's a godfather in the setup?
========
This is my game prediction— I get lynched and am revealed to be town after all, then ya’ll will deride me for being dumb and bad town.
But by the end of the game, when Bogard is revealed to be he Godfather, you’ll all be saying; “Oh wow, I wish we listened to that clever, intelligent, handsome and funny TAC guy earlier. This could’ve been an easy victory.”
How do you know there's a godfather in the setup?
=========
Vote Lynch @tedxtr
@Rej
I am placing my vote on him. I don't have much to say on that basis, honestly because he doesn't have much to talk about under his belt, anyways.
Don't really think that's a fair assessment of my play. It's not like I sat on TAC the whole day, I mentioned townreads on Kiwi and Jiihad, some scum read towards Bogard and Dark, and that's 4/10 players, provided that the remainder are mostly low posters that have NAI content.
========
Vote Lynch @tedxtr
@Rej
You tell us instead and I'll give you cookie box
My read on him was that as mafia, he wouldn't have raised awareness to a lurker slot and painting him scummy like that, because he himself is a lurker. So there's a lack of self awareness that is more indicative of town. Because he would obviously not post that as scum if he was also a lurker, he needs to cast doubt on actives or just *be there*
========
Whats town gameplay for you to be honest? Mafia too try act like they're trying to find scum, no they do that the most since that make players appear town. I stated my point clearly that TAC being too open and not cautious at all for scum and scum tend to be self aware and don't do crazy things knowing it can put them in risk.
Why it was? Can you explain to me?
Again, what about my play has marked onto you as "self-aware" lol. I don't really get what your metric is, I've been pushing my scum reads, requested people move their votes, if I'm self-aware, wouldn't I want to be hiding? I don't think you're making a proper evaluation here, if you wanted me to develop on my TCA read, you should've asked, but you're jumping the gun on no basis, I feel like. If you have something that's not clear, ask me to expound on it, why aren't you trying to discern my alignment at all here? Your crux of the case is that I've pushed TCA which you perceived as town.
=========