Is Bleach Better than Kingdom?


  • Total voters
    180
Jojo has the advantage of the Part structure making it so it's basically nine different series with their own characters, settings and endings. Peak concept tbh
I think the appeal is less that anyone can jump in at any time (it’s a very self-referential series) and more that you can choose when to end the adventure at natural break point, and return if you’d like down the line.
 
This is why I never got into Hajime. I strongly suspect it would have great appeal to me, but I am a big believer in endings and leaving the audience wanting more.

That ride seems to never want to stop. Same with Jojo, though that’s easier to follow with the anime being a fun time.



It reads as though you still very much enjoy Kingdom and don’t think it’s actually declined.

They asked me cause I’ve been bitching and complaining for the better part of year straight. :denzimote:
It also helps that JoJo is separated into different stories with their own unique characters that each inherited the torch from the last and got their own endings. Although imo things should've just stopped with Golden Wind since what follows never really measures up to what came before.
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
Haku'Ou Koku just doesn't look that formidable to me and I'm not interested in seeing him put a fight against Shin.


Wait, what? Lmfao?

Weren’t you the one who wanted Shin to beat Hakuokoku??? Lmfao

Join the Yoko Yoko gang before it’s too late. Lol

But nah, Tou is about to end this battle before Shin gets a serious fight. There is zero incentive for either Yoko Yoko or Hakuokoku to come within proximity of Shin.
 
Wait, what? Lmfao?

Weren’t you the one who wanted Shin to beat Hakuokoku??? Lmfao
Yes, and I want it to be complete domination. Ren Pa vs Hakugoat at worst.

Join the Yoko Yoko gang before it’s too late. Lol
I'd rather Tou or Kyou Kai deal with Yoko Yoko.

But nah, Tou is about to end this battle before Shin gets a serious fight. There is zero incentive for either Yoko Yoko or Hakuokoku to come within proximity of Shin.
Quite possible.
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
Yes, and I want it to be complete domination. Ren Pa vs Hakugoat at worst.
Oh yeah that ain’t happening lol. If Shin can’t dominate Rokuomi in simulation, he’s not dominating Hakuokoku in an actual battle. Honestly at Shin’s current level, unless Hakuokoku charges out to fight Shin personally, Shin is needing several days to beat this guy.

I'd rather Tou or Kyou Kai deal with Yoko Yoko.
It’s like I said. Rakuakan’s level as a general is going to be roughly Tou level, best case scenario. In all likelihood he is weaker than Tou overall.

Hakuokoku is even lower than that, as a warrior he may actually be solid but as a general he is even below Rakuakan.

Yoko Yoko is Shin’s only hope for a legit battle this arc. He can be as strong as a warrior as Hara wants him to be, even if as a commander he is weaker than Hakuokoku. As a warrior he is clearly going to be some nutty shit, an opponent only worthy of Shin. I don’t think he’d make an entertaining opponent for Rei or Kai.
 
Oh yeah that ain’t happening lol. If Shin can’t dominate Rokuomi in simulation, he’s not dominating Hakuokoku in an actual battle. Honestly at Shin’s current level, unless Hakuokoku charges out to fight Shin personally, Shin is needing several days to beat this guy.
Do you think Shin has ever struck someone like this in training?

It’s like I said. Rakuakan’s level as a general is going to be roughly Tou level, best case scenario. In all likelihood he is weaker than Tou overall.
I do not share this confidence in the abilities of any general that hasn't been busy busy in the past decade.

Hakuokoku is even lower than that, as a warrior he may actually be solid but as a general he is even below Rakuakan.
I thought he looked reasonably formidable in his debut chapter, figured he'd be somewhere between Ba Tei and Shou Mou in terms of martial ability.

Now, I dunno about you, but he just seems to me like a relative scrub, and I'm not interested in seeing Shin struggle against someone at that level - if that's what it is.

Yoko Yoko is Shin’s only hope for a legit battle this arc. He can be as strong as a warrior as Hara wants him to be, even if as a commander he is weaker than Hakuokoku. As a warrior he is clearly going to be some nutty shit, an opponent only worthy of Shin. I don’t think he’d make an entertaining opponent for Rei or Kai.
Shin has nothing to prove martially.

Yoko Yoko does little for him or the HSU in terms of bouncing back from their back to back Ls with major achievements in the Han campaign. Haku may seem like a scrub to me, but he is nevertheless Han's Second General. That matters a great deal more than any enforcer type adjutant like Yoko Yoko.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't mind if Raku or Hakuowatever end up serving Qin
I don't know if I would mind but I do think Kingdom has been a little naive as of late.

To me, it'd be more interesting if resentment for the casualties and heroes lost to fighting the Qin were made part of the early struggles in integrating the Han army - especially for Shin, who I presume will be getting more experience in commanding massive armies.

They could end up losing to someone like GHM in the future
Fair enough.

I'm curious what's going to happen to the Hand kong
Same thing that happened to Kan Pi Shi. A comfortable prison and a cup of poison.
 
Last edited:

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
Do you think Shin has ever struck someone like this in training?
Doesn’t really matter outside of a 1v1 scenario lol. Which like I said, Shin’s level of weight isn’t amazingly relevant in terms of deciding the outcome of a battle unless he is directly facing an enemy commander. And the odds of Hakuokoku being dumb enough to personally pick a fight with Shin are low. Proper tactics can still counter Shin’s martial ability.

Yoko Yoko does not little for him or the HSU in terms of bouncing back from their back to back Ls with major achievements in the Han campaign. Haku may seem like a scrub to me, but he is nevertheless Han's Second General. That matters a great deal more than any enforcer type adjutant like Yoko Yoko.
Shin wasn’t responsible for either of those defeats. He has nothing to bounce back from lol.
 

TheKnightOfTheSea

𝕷𝖔𝖗𝖉 𝖔𝖋 𝕸𝖔𝖔𝖓'𝖘 𝕾𝖕𝖆𝖜𝖓
Same thing that happened to Kan Pi Shi. A comfortable prison and a cup of poison.
i meant Han King:shame:

i do wonder if Hara will have that shown onpanel

Also, regarding Raku and Moubu's secret bastard...
i do believe there was a revolt in Han a few years after the Zhao conquest. So maybe they'll be left alive, and they'll end up leading it. Maybe that will "worsen" Sei's insanity if Hara goes down that rout,e and make Shin more disillusioned with unification
 
Doesn’t really matter outside of a 1v1 scenario lol. Which like I said, Shin’s level of weight isn’t amazingly relevant in terms of deciding the outcome of a battle unless he is directly facing an enemy commander. And the odds of Hakuokoku being dumb enough to personally pick a fight with Shin are low. Proper tactics can still counter Shin’s martial ability.
A Shin VS Haku'Ou 1v1 is what I'm expecting will happen. If it does, I am rooting for Shin to score an overwhelming victory or to basically beat him into submission.

Shin wasn’t responsible for either of those defeats. He has nothing to bounce back from lol.
Take it up with Shin then, I guess. :kayneshrug:



i meant Han King:shame:

i do wonder if Hara will have that shown onpanel
I understood fine. :suresure:

I've got some ideas on what might happen with the Han king.

Also, regarding Raku and Moubu's secret bastard...
i do believe there was a revolt in Han a few years after the Zhao conquest. So maybe they'll be left alive, and they'll end up leading it. Maybe that will "worsen" Sei's insanity if Hara goes down that rout,e and make Shin more disillusioned with unification
Acknowleding history spoilers:
I'll say this has been on my mind for a minute.
 
Last edited:

TheKnightOfTheSea

𝕷𝖔𝖗𝖉 𝖔𝖋 𝕸𝖔𝖔𝖓'𝖘 𝕾𝖕𝖆𝖜𝖓
A Shin VS Haku'Ou 1v1 is what I'm expecting will happen. If it does, I am rooting for Shin to score an overwhelming victory or to basically beat him into submission.



Take it up with Shin then, I guess. :kayneshrug:





I understood fine. :suresure:

I've got some ideas on what might happen with the Han king.



Acknowleding history spoilers:
I'll say this has been on a mind my mind for a minute.
could you elaborate on what you think may happen? I'm not sure if current Hara would have a guy who's been portrayed as pretty harmless and inept get killed cruelly... but idk.


the kings of Kingdom are a group of characters that I wish Hara elaborated more on outside of Qi and Zhao's kings.

Kouretsu had a pretty formidable presence, wish we saw more of him and Shunshinkun.

Yan's King looks formidable and I expect he'll have an unpleasant ending.

Wei's king got some characterization, he was fanboying over Rinko. I hope we see Chu's young king and the uncle.
 
could you elaborate on what you think may happen? I'm not sure if current Hara would have a guy who's been portrayed as pretty harmless and inept get killed cruelly... but idk.
Going into history spoilers:
The long and short of it is that I expect the Qin to pacify Han rather peacefully at first and deal with rebellion down the line.

I'm not sure if the royal family will continue to rule in the capacity of vassals or a governor will be installed - that may or may not be Tou from the outset - but in any event I anticipate rebels will rise when it appears their moment is at hand. The rebels may be sponsored by Chu and/or Wei, but I expect them to be quickly routed and a Sei that's edging towards breaking bad completely has the former king of Han executed at that point if he's still alive, and to the protest of both Shin and Tou.

the kings of Kingdom are a group of characters that I wish Hara elaborated more on outside of Qi and Zhao's kings.

Kouretsu had a pretty formidable presence, wish we saw more of him and Shunshinkun.

Yan's King looks formidable and I expect he'll have an unpleasant ending.

Wei's king got some characterization, he was fanboying over Rinko. I hope we see Chu's young king and the uncle.
It's really just an unfortunate sympton of a great issue: Hara's bizarre disengagement with worldbuilding.

Granted, the historical records are far from robust, but Kingdom has always been a fictionalised retelling of history, not a 1:1 adaptation. The negative space is there to be used a blank canvas, and Hara has certainly used much of it in the early days of setting up the world of Kingdom, but he's really taken his foot off in the gas in this department.

I've been saying for some time the worldbuilding of Kingdom is extremely wanting, and I believe that has dire consequences in terms of restricting storytelling potential. It's like Hara worked on this immense tapestry for years and then swapped to cheaper materials to be more budget conscience (time). It's not worth it.

We should know who these kings are. We should know what makes the kingdoms different culturally beyond the superficial differences in aesthetics. We know should know a hell of a lot more of the innerworking and views of the other courts. It would only add much needed texture and reasons to give a shit.
 
Top