Questions & Mysteries Gorosei did not receive Shanks

Paperchampion23

Paperchampion23

‎
#48
#48
Okamakama said:
To be honest though, IF it does turn out to be a twin, Oda's done a fucking god-tier bait.
Click to expand...
roronoa_fan said:
Still, it may have been done with the purpose of differentiating
Click to expand...
The issue is the context of the scene then doesnt make sense if thats the case:

- If this is his evil twin brother or clone who works for the government, why is he hiding his identity under a cloak?
- Sengoku and Gorosei both have deferred to Shanks' requests with the saying "because its you". Shanks had his scarring at Marineford. He's given the same "status" with both people.
 
ArturCantSpeakJapanese

ArturCantSpeakJapanese

‎
#49
#49
Paperchampion23 said:
The issue is the context of the scene then doesnt make sense if thats the case:

- If this is his evil twin brother or clone who works for the government, why is he hiding his identity under a cloak?
- Sengoku and Gorosei both have deferred to Shanks' requests with the saying "because its you". Shanks had his scarring at Marineford. He's given the same "status" with both people.
Click to expand...
yeah the biggest reason it wouldnt be a double is that the government higher ups treat shanks the same way in public as they do in the meeting room
 
OnePiss

OnePiss

‎
#51
#51
Paperchampion23 said:
The issue is the context of the scene then doesnt make sense if thats the case:

- If this is his evil twin brother or clone who works for the government, why is he hiding his identity under a cloak?
- Sengoku and Gorosei both have deferred to Shanks' requests with the saying "because its you". Shanks had his scarring at Marineford. He's given the same "status" with both people.
Click to expand...
Also the idea that it’s Shanks brother or evil family member doesn’t actually affect anyone in the story other the Shanks.

This is my biggest issue with it being a Shanks family member. That reveal doesn’t add anything to the story or for the characters
 
Monkey D Theories

Monkey D Theories

‎
#53
#53
It's at least a possibility, honestly.

I mean why would the Gorosei talk to Shanks personally in Mariejois of all places? We know that the WG does deal with the yonko, but they always used CP0 as intermediaries, at least in the case of Kaido and Big Mom.

Yet with Shanks, they supposedly invited him into Mariejois? It doesn't make that much sense. Why would the gorosei trust Shanks, who is a world renowned pirate, not to plunder the holy land?
[automerge]1683821577[/automerge]
either:
  1. Shanks really is a snitch
  2. that's not Shanks
and honestly, it could go either way imo.
 
BlackLegFring

BlackLegFring

‎
#58
#58
Monkey D Theories said:
It's at least a possibility, honestly.

I mean why would the Gorosei talk to Shanks personally in Mariejois of all places? We know that the WG does deal with the yonko, but they always used CP0 as intermediaries, at least in the case of Kaido and Big Mom.

Yet with Shanks, they supposedly invited him into Mariejois? It doesn't make that much sense. Why would the gorosei trust Shanks, who is a world renowned pirate, not to plunder the holy land?
[automerge]1683821577[/automerge]
either:
  1. Shanks really is a snitch
  2. that's not Shanks
and honestly, it could go either way imo.
Click to expand...
Shanks alone can’t hope to plunder Mariejois, especially when an Admiral was already stationed there for the Reverie.
They know he’s not that stupid.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top