I was not so much praising Imu for cheap shoting him as much as saying Imu must have Haki (or at least some very convenient Hak equivalent hax) to harm the Logia user that is Sabo.
And though I generally agree with most of your takes I do not understand how you can be as “harsh” as you are with Imu for his reaction to Joyboy and how this “hard caps” his chances so to speak but praise Blackbeard in the same breath.
Blackbeard, the same man who runs from Old Rayleigh and Akainu. Hell, even if Imu is a devil fruit user and not just a straight up Devil themselves as I suspect? Blackbeards end goal in the setting is becoming whom Imu is. King/Ruler of the World.
And he will then do that with three fruits while Imu managed to pull it off via just one, while also ruling for WAY longer than Teach will ever be able to since he sure as hell ain't winning the Manga.
Like I don’t even get this idea some people have of Blackbeard stealing Imus fruit (which due to their transformation in the throne room would likely be a zoan/mythical zoan to give Teach the “best” of all three fruit categories.
He would never be able to master the fruit in whatever short amount of time post an Imu fight before facing Luffy. Nor would it feel thematically appropriate if Luffy dismantle the WG (now under Blackbeard control somehow?) if Imu, the person in charge of the whole thing, has been supplanted by Blackbeard.
Blackbeard might very well be the strongest Pirate that Luffy faces EOS if he blooms his Haki (especially since we have seen in Egghead how devil fruit reliant Luffy is despite his fans claims to the contrary) but Imu?
Until proven otherwise I still think Imu is gonna end up being the greater scope villain.
Though either way, if you acknowledge Imu is Top 5 material (even if only current and not of all time) I can agree to disagree and respect your opinion since you clearly at least acknowledge Imus prowess to a level far to many are still denying to this day so props on that front.
I don't think such things as Devil exist as in this story all things are manifestations of desire, the evolution of humanity.
Imu can either be a special race, like King or have the ability that is a result of desire, either first timer or manifested in a DF already.
Due to his ability being Zoan-like in Silhouette, it means his source of power is mainly a Devil Fruit. Certainly his haki will also be impressive as Elders have impressive haki as well but there are levels above those hakis and as we know, haki rules supreme.
That has been repeatedly reinforced since the beginning of the story and that is why I don't rank Imu as high as some people do.
Haki aka willpower is the power that conquers/transcends everything and there are 3 confirmed hakimen - Zoro, Mihawk and Shanks.
Zoro and Mihawk are a story for themselves, the very peak that nobody else can approach due to being ultimate representatives of Power.
While Shanks isn't on that level, he has nothing else to show off but his haki which has been displayed as impressive throughout the whole story. For him to stand below Imu who relies mainly on DF ability would be odd to say the least, for Oda's self insert.
And you know that I think that 4 Emperors come after Imu as I don't support the idea that WG war is final.
If you think it is, I understand why you would rank Imu above Emperors. That's probably why we have different opinions on this.
Blackbeard is treated differently than Imu, that's why it is not so weird to forgive him being a hypetool and what not...
However, once his time comes, he will have to prove himself and I don't think he will be inferior to any DF user left in the show at that point especially because one of his characteristics is the DF canceling effect that is a big trouble for those who rely heavily on DFs...