General & Others If Vegapunk is dead, who gets credit for killing him?

[kumae]

For letting VP die he is now going to tell the truth of the world
No wonder why he will become the most dangerous/troublesome of the crew

 

[Chiji_]

The one that finished him off Kizaru, it’s something to be said about Saturn putting him in a dying condition just for Kizaru to literally add insult to injury

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

its saturn
he pretty much said moving him will kill him at that point

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Sanji the vegapunk killer

 

[BlackLegFring]

Who gets the credit for killing WB ?

Majority will say it's the BBP's yet the one who took half his face and punched a hole in his chest was Akainu.

So by this logic Kizaru gets the kill

I have a feeling we’re going to see another classic case of double standards.

Those that say Akainu didn’t kill WB but it was BB will say that it was Saturn and not Kizaru that killed Vegapunk.
An Admiral getting credit would just be anathema to them.

 

[MarineHQ]

I have a feeling we’re going to see another classic case of double standards.

Those that say Akainu didn’t kill WB but it was BB will say that it was Saturn and not Kizaru that killed Vegapunk.
An Admiral getting credit would just be anathema to them.

Exactly

 

[Reborn]

Both Saturn and kiz went after VP in last chapter while Sanji was trying to save him. I see this an indication from oda that VP injuries were still treatable.



Thus, for me, it's kiz who should get the credit coz he finished him off (if vp is dead)

 

[BigAmmi]

Saturn, because Vegapunk couldn't move a muscle and he would have die no matter what in that situation

Kizaru made his death more certain

For Oda i think is a team work

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

And it was never said anywhere that Whitebeard would die from Akainu's attack, unlike Vegapunk and Saturn where we're explicitly told it will kill him

I think it was pretty obvious that Whitebeard wouldn't survive losing half his face, even Oda probably thought he wouldn't have to clarify.

 

[SkySanji]

I think it was pretty obvious that Whitebeard wouldn't survive losing half his face, even Oda probably thought he wouldn't have to clarify.

Obvious to who? You realize people in the real world have survived such injuries? Let alone a fucking superhuman like Whitebeard.

And doesn't change what I said, nowhere was it stated that Whitebeard was going to die from Akainu's attack, whereas the opposite is true for Saturna and Vegapunk.

 

[Malio]

"If you move, I'll bleed out and die..."

*Ranji proceeds to move him, and VP dies*

A failure and a killer, thy name is Ranji

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Obvious to who?

every single op reader except you apparently

the old man with cancer who lost half his face obviously was going to die very soon.

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Doesn't Saturn uses poison? WB was going to die from sickness and heart attack anyways

 

[SkySanji]

every single op reader except you apparently

the old man with cancer who lost half his face obviously was going to die very soon.

Refer to what I said previously, people have survived such injuries in the real world, there are people who only have half a brain.

The same old man with cancer that took an entire sword through his heart and shrugged it off like nothing? That alone is a fatal injury that he shrugged off, he took it and then also went on to take hundreds of other attacks.
[automerge]1708798673[/automerge]

267 sword wounds
152 bullet wounds
46 cannon wounds

That would kill a normal person a thousand times over, but apparently an injury which real world people can survive would've killed Whitebeard

 

[Cyrus]

Kizaru. While its heavily implied Vegapunk may have simply bled out without Kizaru finishing him off, this is One Piece and some plot bullshit probably would have saved him if not for Kizaru.

 

[Juanpiz]

Refer to what I said previously, people have survived such injuries in the real world, there are people who only have half a brain.

The same old man with cancer that took an entire sword through his heart and shrugged it off like nothing? That alone is a fatal injury that he shrugged off, he took it and then also went on to take hundreds of other attacks.
[automerge]1708798673[/automerge]

267 sword wounds
152 bullet wounds
46 cannon wounds

That would kill a normal person a thousand times over, but apparently an injury which real world people can survive would've killed Whitebeard

Still one of the best panels

 

[Etzel Andergast]

If Saturn get the credits for Vegapunk death, then Akainu must get the credits for Whitebeard death

 

[Peroroncino]

Saturn mortally wounded him first

 

[Daves John]

All I am hearing is that no old man is dying in One Piece without multiple people sharing the kill

 

[Yoho]

Vegapunk: don't move me if you move me I'll die!

Sanji: welp better move this guy