Assuming that there is a mastermind
Frankly I think the execution aside it's all been very level 1 and on the nose. This is a problem that has hurt town games on OLF too - we spend so much town hunting a certain type of scum and it's seldom actually the case.
Basically, remember early game, maybe day 1, where i suggested it's like the Waifu game? I'm more or less there.