Versus Battle Minato vs Tobirama

Who wins?

  • Draw or toss up

  • Minato extreme difficulty

  • Minato high difficulty

  • Minato medium difficulty

  • Minato low difficulty

  • Tobirama extreme difficulty

  • Tobirama high difficulty

  • Tobirama medium difficulty

  • Tobirama low difficulty


Results are only viewable after voting.

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#50
Almost everything points at Minato, there really isnt a debate
AP? Rasengan GG
Speed? Minato better
Senjutsu? Minato lol
Minato probably has top 3 highest battle iq as well.
only senju wank can help tobirama
Senjutsu doesn't help against Tobirama, and Minato's terrible at it. Tobirama more than likely has a bigger arsenal than Minato: he has FTG, water jutsu, EDO Tensei, etc. He's no less than Minato in intelligence if not smarter. He has a much bigger chakra pool too. Minato wins but Tobirama can be better based on the scenario. None of Tobirama's arsenal would prove to be effective on Minato besides his speed and FTG and more or less the same goes for the other way around. This is a battle of speeds and teleportation, and Minato has a clear edge over Tobirama.
 
#52
Senjutsu doesn't help against Tobirama, and Minato's terrible at it. Tobirama more than likely has a bigger arsenal than Minato: he has FTG, water jutsu, EDO Tensei, etc. He's no less than Minato in intelligence if not smarter. He has a much bigger chakra pool too. Minato wins but Tobirama can be better based on the scenario. None of Tobirama's arsenal would prove to be effective on Minato besides his speed and FTG and more or less the same goes for the other way around. This is a battle of speeds and teleportation, and Minato has a clear edge over Tobirama.
Senjutsu does help vs tobirama to dodge attacks. Plus for a fast paced fight like this even tho Minato cant keep up senjutsu much, 3-5 minutes is enough

Minato is smarter, bigger talent even.
his arsenal also is very big. I’d say as big as Tobirama cause he studied uzumaki clan
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#54
It’s literally what helped Madara dodge FTG, and it was his first time ever using it lol
You mean against Tobirama? Madara was always stronger than Tobirama even before he gained EMS. That isn't something he could only do with Senjutsu. EMS Madara was fighting Hashiram in CQC on equal footing during the VotE duel.
Post automatically merged:

Senjutsu does help vs tobirama to dodge attacks. Plus for a fast paced fight like this even tho Minato cant keep up senjutsu much, 3-5 minutes is enough

Minato is smarter, bigger talent even.
his arsenal also is very big. I’d say as big as Tobirama cause he studied uzumaki clan
Minato doesn't need Senjutsu to dodge Tobirama. He's already more than fast enough in base. He's both physically faster than Tobirama and has a better teleportation technique. Senjutsu is totally meaningless here. At best, Minato can use it as a one-time thing to end the fight quickly. I'd say even regular basket ball sized Rasengan would do the trick.
 
#55
You mean against Tobirama? Madara was always stronger than Tobirama even before he gained EMS. That isn't something he could only do with Senjutsu. EMS Madara was fighting Hashiram in CQC on equal footing during the VotE duel.
Post automatically merged:

.
Madara called Tobirama the fastest shinobi during his lifetime, even at Madara’s peak as he was alive FTG could hit him if taken off guard

that’s what Sage mode is for , it allows you to perceive attacks without the need to see them, which is exactly what Madara did to dodge Tobirama


 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#56
Madara called Tobirama the fastest shinobi during his lifetime, even at Madara’s peak as he was alive FTG could hit him if taken off guard

that’s what Sage mode is for , it allows you to perceive attacks without the need to see them, which is exactly what Madara did to dodge Tobirama


Tobirama is faster than Madara even in this panel, but that didn't stop him from dodging. So I don't see why we're talking as if those events are mutually exclusive or something. Tobirama was the fastest shinobi when they were alive but Sage Hashirama should be able to dodge him using your own logic. So either Tobirama wasn't the fastest guy around back then, or it's possible that people could react to Tobirama even though they were not as fast as him. Tobirama gets his fastest Shinobi title possibly from having the best Shunshin and Hiraishin, not from having the best striking speed or reflexes. That probably goes to Madara and Hashirama.

Again, Madara was fighting Sage Mode Hashirama and continued to fight him until the latter ran out of the mode, which means Madara can operate at those levels even with EMS, which, in turn, proves he could dodge Tobirama even without Senjutsu. I agree it helped in this panel though—because he was almost blindsided.
 
#57
Tobirama is faster than Madara even in this panel, but that didn't stop him from dodging. So I don't see why we're talking as if those events are mutually exclusive or something. Tobirama was the fastest shinobi when they were alive but Sage Hashirama should be able to dodge him using your own logic. So either Tobirama wasn't the fastest guy around back then, or it's possible that people could react to Tobirama even though they were not as fast as him. Tobirama gets his fastest Shinobi title possibly from having the best Shunshin and Hiraishin, not from having the best striking speed or reflexes. That probably goes to Madara and Hashirama.

Again, Madara was fighting Sage Mode Hashirama and continued to fight him until the latter ran out of the mode, which means Madara could operate at those levels even with EMS, which, in turn, proves he could dodge Tobirama even without Senjutsu. I agree it helped in this panel though—because he was almost blindsided.
I’m not doubting Tobirama could probably land a hit on base Hashirama as well, but it isn’t kinda that obvious that the two never fought? Madara on the other hand was constantly at war with the Senju, him praising(or mocking) Tobirama as the faster means a lot more

And that’s my point with senjutsu. In a battle of STJ, we know it only takes one hit to end the battle. If Minato is capable of dodging every single attack that is a huge deal

edit: also let’s not forget Hashi fought Madara and the Kyubi at the same time lol. That sage mode was probably to even the playing field
 
Last edited:

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#58
I’m not doubting Tobirama could probably land a hit on base Hashirama as well, but it isn’t kinda that obvious that the two never fought? Madara on the other hand was constantly at war with the Senju, him praising(or mocking) Tobirama as the faster means a lot more
Yeah, he probably could get in a hit on base Hashiram in CQC due to superior speed. But the "fastest" title is often more attributed to FTG than the actual physical speed. We do actually know for a fact that Tobirama is faster than Hashirama on foot as well. But landing attacks takes more than just foot speed. You gotta strike faster than your opponent can react. If you refer to Bee vs Minato scene, for whatever it's worth, Bee reacted and pointed a blade at Minato at the same time as Minato appeared behind him. So even if you're faster than your opponents, it's still possible that they can react to your attacks if they're skilled and attentive enough akin to Bee.

And that’s my point with senjutsu. In a battle of STJ, we know it only takes one hit to end the battle. If Minato is capable of dodging every single attack that is a huge deal
It surely helps in increasing Minato's potency, but it comes at the cost of losing a bit of efficiency because it requires him to stay still at least for a bit to gather chakra. Tobirama could sense Senjutsu, and use that time to attack Minato. Minato is fully capable of holding off Tobirama even without Senjutsu, and Tobirama wouldn't need anything more than a big Rasengan to be taken out. Opting for Senjutsu is kinda counter-productive, especially considering Minato's terrible mastery over it.
 
#59
Even though we have the statement that puts Minato directly above Tobirama in speed we can still acknowledge that Minato was impressed by his reaction and attack speed. Tobirama definitely gives Minato a run for his money in speed.

Tobirama was such a genius Shinobi, we've only touched the surface level of the jutsu that he has created and mastered plus the Senju chakra pool.
:pepehands:

Kishi...
 
#60
Minato wouldn't use sage mode in a battle, it didn't even occur to him to use it during the greatest war, he had to be reminded and he could only sustain it for one panel. He didn't even use it when he was killed by kurama. Sage mode is a non-factor in this fight.

Tobirama is the upgraded version of Minato. Give him nine tails chakra before he can stand a chance.
 
Top