General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Monkey D Al]

This and the dream/goal/desire indeed, were the ONLY things that Carrot lacked to be considered a full strawhat. But like I have explained already multiple times before, this is just one of the many parameters of the writing of a strawhat.



Well... arguable. I don't feel baited yet. More like put on standby



Yes and no. In reality, all my reasonning for the first theory (the CarrotForNakama theory) was pointing toward two things : first indeed to carrot joining, but second to Carrot becoming somewhat important in the story later.

That's why I was not surprised to see her be given the title of Zou. The story portrayed her as an important character despite being a secondary character. (remember all the time I said "no Carrot is not irrelevant despite her lack of story screentime?") I would be surprised on the other hand if that was the end of her story.

The Carrot For Nakama is dead, my conclusion was proven wrong. But we are talking here about a second theory based on the hypothesis that Carrot could have an important place in the story related to the notion of the Dawn and that it could or could not impact her status as Queen and her relationship with the strawhats.

My conclusion to the first theory was that passed a certain point in the story, Carrot's chance would be done. But I rationnalized that on the fact that it was what Oda had done everytime in the story. Oda could still prove me wrong, and Carrot could still join the crew because of that relationship with the Dawn and the element of that second theory.

That's why I'm debatting this here.

Yeah I will go back to your comments and find them. When I have more time and my laptop with me. I remember you giving up

 

[Rambles]

Lucci is a psycho murderer with no chance of joining the crew

No he isn't. He is just a weapon used by the government.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

No he isn't. He is just a weapon used by the government.

Glad you finally understand :cheers:

 

[Rambles]

Grandfleet membership is even too generous for him

But we know Oda. He also made Crocodile and Buggy into allies, and Law &Kid, and Bege and Enel will 199% be an ally too when he returns

These characters have done horrible things

That's the spirit! :cheers:

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Lobotomy is always a possibility!?!! Too dark? To soon?

Could you not??

That's a terrible post. Not funny

No he isn't. He is just a weapon used by the government.

He's a psycho murderer that uses his government job as a cover to kill as much as he wants

 

[Rambles]

Glad you finally understand :cheers:

Would youlike to bet? One month of changing your avatar - how is that? I say Lucci is joining and if he isn't than you win.

Post automatically merged: Feb 16, 2023

Could you not??

That's a terrible post. Not funny


He's a psycho murderer that uses his government job as a cover to kill as much as he wants

Nah, his goals are not that obvious and I hope that this arc will bring up what his driving motives are.

 

[Logiko]

MDA, one of his first lines since joining the topic was "Carrot is joining. Those who deny this fact are just toxic." We waged a one man war against the whole thread and another forum saying Carrot is obviously joining according to his story telling knowledge, and that we're all blind pigeons and other political buzzwords for not seeing it. All of that just be to be horriblly wrong. Instead of accepting it, his immediately claimed that his analysis was spot on and Oda must've changed his mind.

You can't help him. No one can

Nah I don't think it was that, the first sentence was something like:

"Carrot will join and anyone denying that is reaching" or something like that, I only started with calling out the toxicity later.

I was indeed wrong. But my reasonning wasn't. and it still stands today to see if a character has the potential to become a strawhat or not in light of the informations we have. I'm sorry if that's not something you understand.

Furthermore I used the word pidgeon only once and mainly aimed at one person's rethoric (without being a direct attack) that was denying storytelling facts while insulting me. I apologized for that directly after the fact.

(Yeah.. I know you love to manipulated the opinion to make me look like an hysteric personn )

---

Theorizing means that we create a reasonning. If the conclusions are wrong, it doesn't mean that the reasonning is wrong, it can also mean that there are gap in the knowledge or observations.

Yeah I will go back to your comments and find them. When I have more time and my laptop with me. I remember you giving up

On the theory in indeed. Even if I think there is still 1 to 5% chance of Carrot joining the crew, I don't feel as it is a viable option now. But the theory reasonning is still viable, this is why I kept the blog alive.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Nah, his goals are not that obvious and I hope that this arc will bring up what his driving motives are

Please not another sad backstory

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Would youlike to bet? One month of changing your avatar - how is that? I say Lucci is joining and if he isn't than you win.

Deal!

 

[Uncle Van]

Lobotomy is always a possibility!?!! Too dark? To soon?

Too soon

 

[ShiShiShi]

Deal!

You’re setting yourself up for another furry avatar.

 

[DarkestKnightofSpoilers]

Lucci for Nakama who came up with that

 

[Rambles]

Please not another sad backstory

With a new crew member Oda is always inserting sad backstories.

Post automatically merged: Feb 16, 2023

Lucci for Nakama who came up with that

Here I am.

 

[Monkey D Al]

On the theory in indeed. Even if I think there is still 1 to 5% chance of Carrot joining the crew, I don't feel as it is a viable option now. But the theory reasonning is still viable, this is why I kept the blog alive.

How is there a chance for a character to join that isn’t in the story for chapters and chapters and there is no sign of her returning for the foreseeable future. By the time she returns the Manga is gonna be in its final chapters. How??

 

[ShiShiShi]

Lucci won't join

There’s always that 0.000001% chance!

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

You’re setting yourself up for another furry avatar.

I may not have any faith in Oda after the way he ended Wano, but I know he's not crazy enough to have Rob fucking Lucci join the crew after everything he's done.

 

[Monkey D Al]

Too soon

Okay warning taken

 

[Rambles]

Deal!

Thank you. I will just add you to my growing list. It is a pleasure making business with you.

 

[Warine]

This community has a weird carrot's hate boner

 

[Emmazrine]

lucçi is a serious option for some ppl?